7.2 Optical, CMM and Surface Texture Inspection
Key Takeaways
An optical comparator shows a magnified projection. Confirm illumination, lens, stage alignment and whether the projected view represents the intended feature.
CMM qualification establishes effective dimensions for the stylus configuration. Datum evaluation separately needs the correct references, sampling and fit.
Ra averages absolute heights of the roughness profile about its mean line. Rz and the filter settings depend on the governing standard and its edition.
Use the drawing’s parameter, units, lay and process notes. Evaluation length is the part of the trace used for calculation, and physical traverse can be longer.
7.2 Optical, CMM and Surface Texture Inspection
Inspect a projected feature
An optical comparator uses a lens to show a magnified view of a part. In transmitted illumination the part blocks light to create a silhouette. Reflected or surface illumination can show visible details on the facing surface. A front view of a blind hole shows the opening, while depth and hidden geometry require a suitable additional view or measurement. Choose a projection direction that shows the feature and orient the part to the nominal geometry, including thread alignment when required.
Use a matching overlay or a qualified measured stage and edge-detection method. A Mitutoyo PJ-H series profile projector, for example, supports lenses with different magnifications and transmitted or reflected illumination. At ideal 100× magnification, a 0.0001 in feature difference projects to 0.010 in on the screen. That is a scale calculation. It does not establish the system’s error, smallest valid feature or part acceptance. The stage readout can report actual part movement independently of the enlarged screen image. Verify the specific model, lens and method before comparing observations to the drawing.
Prepare a CMM measurement
A coordinate measuring machine uses measured coordinates to evaluate the geometry. Touch-trigger systems collect contacts at discrete locations. Scanning sensors can record more of a trace or surface. The appropriate sensor and coverage depend on feature access and tolerance. As examples, Renishaw TP20 uses kinematic touch-trigger sensing and TP200 uses strain gauges. The TP200’s stylus module still uses a kinematic coupling. Do not assume identical triggering electronics because it attaches to a similar stylus system.
Qualify the actual stylus and orientations using the machine and probe procedure. Renishaw describes using a known reference sphere to determine effective stylus diameter and position with the software. The number and distribution of contacts differ by system and chosen mode. Qualification is distinct from calibrating the machine itself. Contamination, a damaged tip or a configuration change can affect repeatability. Check requalification requirements before running the routine.
For the geometric evaluation, read which references the drawing requires and their order. A preliminary setup alignment helps the machine find the workpiece. Verifying the final datum reference frame requires appropriate sampled data and the specified constraint and fitting approach. Three non-collinear points define a mathematical plane, but that alone does not demonstrate the intended simulator for an imperfect whole surface. Some drawings identify discrete datum targets and thereby require different sampling. For example, Hexagon’s PC-DMIS documentation distinguishes a simple constructed datum plane from fitting using measured surface data and explains options for approximating the specified datum under ASME. Build and validate each measurement method rather than accepting any plane labeled A.
| Instrument or step | Main evidence |
|---|---|
| Profile projector or comparator | Outline or visible projected feature in a defined direction |
| Touch-trigger CMM | Sampled coordinates from qualified contacts |
| Scanning CMM | Measured trace or sampled surface coordinates for suitable geometric fits |
| Stylus roughness instrument | Filtered height profile and texture parameters for a specific trace |
Read the texture requirement
ASME Y14.36-2018 covers drawing symbols for surface texture. Follow the leader to the controlled surface and read its parameter, value, units and any additional process or lay annotations. The basic symbol can be supplemented to require or forbid material removal. Lay indicates the dominant pattern direction; waviness is the more widely spaced component of texture, and roughness is the finer-spaced component. Profile measurements use appropriate processing to reduce effects from gross form and separate scales of variation. Use the invoked standard and edition. ASME B46.1-2019 (R2026) defines parameters and procedures, and ISO 21920-2 and -3 cover profile parameters and specification operators in the ISO system.
Under ASME B46.1-2019, Ra is the average absolute height of the roughness profile about its mean line. Rq is the root-mean-square height. Rz is the average of the maximum peak-to-valley heights obtained in successive sampling lengths over the evaluation length. Read the standard when interpreting Rz or a legacy drawing. For example, equal-interval roughness heights of −2, −1, +1 and +2 µm give Ra 1.5 µm and Rq µm in this simple arithmetic exercise. The ratio between them depends on the profile.
A microinch is one millionth of an inch, and 1 µm is approximately 39.37 µin. A drawing limit of Ra 32 µin is about 0.813 µm. A reading of Ra 0.76 µm falls below that numerical limit if the specified surface, trace and settings apply. Retain the measured units, uncertainty and decision rule. A value that passes on the wrong trace or after selecting a different cutoff is not sufficient for acceptance.
Set the profilometer for the job
Verify the instrument and reference specimen per its procedure, prepare a clean surface and select the specified trace direction. Consider the lay and the measurement direction shown on the drawing. Select the appropriate stylus, filter, sampling and evaluation lengths from the invoked standard and approved procedure. The long-wavelength roughness cutoff separates scales by attenuating longer components; it is not an abrupt on/off threshold. A cutoff of 0.8 mm can apply in some conditions. If a particular method uses five sampling lengths of 0.8 mm, the evaluation length is 4.0 mm. The traverse needs more travel for filter end effects. Check that the chosen site and instrument can accommodate it. Record settings and location so another inspector can reproduce the trace.
Mitutoyo PJ-H profile projector, Renishaw probe types, Renishaw stylus qualification, Hexagon datum fitting, ASME texture symbols, ASME B46.1 measurement guidance and NIST height parameters
A routine used three arbitrary points to locate a part on the CMM. What further decision is needed before accepting a tolerance tied to a whole planar datum feature?
Treat the preliminary plane as final because it contains all three points
Reset the machine spindle so the plane is level to gravity
Use representative data and the fitting and datum procedure required for the drawing
Use the plane as the location of a cylinder even though the drawing calls for a plane
Under ASME B46.1-2019, which statement distinguishes Ra from Rz?
Ra averages absolute roughness profile heights about the mean line; Rz averages the successive peak-to-valley maximum heights of sampling lengths
Ra measures only peak heights; Rz measures only valley depths
Ra is expressed only in micrometers; Rz is expressed only in inches
Ra measures lay; Rz reports the cutoff length
An approved trace calls for five 0.8 mm sampling lengths. What evaluation length does that specify?
0.8 mm, with 4.0 mm physical travel always sufficient
8.0 mm, including end effects
5.8 mm from adding the number of samples to the length
4.0 mm, with additional physical travel as needed for the filter
What does suitable probe qualification on a known sphere establish for the stylus configuration?
The drawing datum reference frame for every future part
Effective stylus diameter and position used by the CMM measurement routine
The zero wear point on a CNC spindle bearing
The surface texture cutoff for the workpiece
A limit is Ra 1.0 µm and a correctly configured measurement reports Ra 45 µin. How do the numerical values compare?
45 µin is exactly 1.0 µm
45 µin is 0.45 µm and is below the limit
45 µin is about 1.14 µm and exceeds the limit
45 µin is above the limit only if the parameter was Rz
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.