10.1 Non-Technical Skills and Speaking Up
Key Takeaways
Checking, concentration and clear communication help you apply the technical rules when the situation changes.
Check the details that could contradict the plan, including the line name, access point and limits.
If a concern cannot be resolved safely, stop the work and follow the Worksafe process.
Report fatigue concerns and use the employer’s fatigue arrangements. A roster check alone does not establish fitness for duty.
Use non-technical skills to check the actual work
RSSB’s non-technical skills guidance describes social, cognitive and personal skills that help people apply technical procedures. For a controller of site safety (COSS) these skills include maintaining awareness of the work group, noticing a mismatch, communicating an instruction clearly and deciding when to stop. They apply from the planning and briefing stages through any change, handover and handback.
A check is most valuable when it could show the plan is wrong. If you expect work to take place on the Up Main, look at the actual line name, access point and limits in the pack and compare them with what is being agreed at the site. RAIB’s Bookham Tunnel report describes a near miss where the Safe Work Pack contained protection details for another tunnel. Multiple checks missed the mismatch. Use the authority and records for the actual line and location. A useful independent check is to compare the line description on the authority with the planned limit and the physical reference on site. If the references refer to different places, stop before relying on the protection. Your familiarity with the location cannot supply a missing authority.
| Situation | Behaviour to use |
|---|---|
| A similar line name appears in two documents | Stop to resolve the discrepancy. Use precise route and location references, and repeat back the safety-critical detail as required. |
| Noise or a changed work position prevents you from observing or advising someone | Stop the work and move the group to safety under Handbook 7. Recheck whether the protection still works before resuming. |
| A new worker is hesitant to question the plan | Invite them to explain what they see or what is unclear. Confirm the answer and rebrief affected people when an arrangement is corrected. |
| Several requests arrive during a safety-critical exchange | Finish or safely pause the exchange. Tell the group to wait, then deal with other requests without losing the line, limits or authority details. |
| A worker reports insufficient rest or difficulty concentrating | Treat it as relevant to fitness for duty. Raise it promptly and follow the responsible employer’s process for deciding whether the work can be carried out safely. |
Stop and resolve a safety concern
Under Network Rail’s Worksafe process, stop work, move to a position of safety and promptly explain the concern to the person in charge. They discuss and assess it with you. Work can restart only when the parties agree that the task has been suitably assessed and can proceed safely. If the concern remains unresolved, the work stays stopped and the person in charge consults their manager. The COSS still needs to confirm any revised group protection and rebrief those affected. A complaint reported later cannot protect a group exposed now.
Worked decision: an unexpected line name
During a group briefing a colleague says the access gate is beside the Down Relief. The pack and the planned blockage refer to the Down Main, and the supervisor believes both names refer to the same track. The COSS keeps the group in safety and checks the line identifiers and limits against the work location. The group waits while the discrepancy is resolved with the appropriate people. If the authority was given for another line, the COSS cannot use it for this site. Once a suitable arrangement is in place, repeat the affected part of the briefing and check that the group can identify the correct lines and where they may go.
Fatigue is a safety issue
Regulation 25 of the Railways and Other Guided Transport Systems (Safety) Regulations 2006 places a fatigue-management duty on the controller of safety-critical work. They must have arrangements to prevent, so far as reasonably practicable, a safety-critical worker carrying out the work while fatigue would significantly affect safety. ORR identifies factors including travel, recovery, workload and shift timing. Follow the applicable dutyholder's arrangements and report any concern before undertaking the work. A person may be unfit even if no working-time limit has been exceeded. If a fatigued worker was needed for a safety duty, confirm that competent cover is available and revisit the plan before exposing the group.
The line name read back by the signaller differs from the line name in the planned work. What should the COSS do?
Assume it is an informal name for the same line
Keep the group clear and resolve the line and limits before relying on any authority
Accept the authority because the job is already booked
Let the group start while the planner compares the records
A worker reports fatigue before undertaking a safety-critical duty. Their roster is within the stated working hours. What is the appropriate response?
Ignore the report unless a train is already approaching
Ask them to start and postpone the discussion to the next break
Treat the working-hour record as proof they are fit
Take the report seriously and apply the fatigue and fitness-for-duty arrangements before the work
Under Worksafe, what should a worker do first if they believe the planned protection is unsafe?
Stop, move to a position of safety and tell the person in charge why
Keep working and raise the issue after handback
Relocate to another line and continue independently
Ask a colleague to continue the disputed task without an assessment
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.