9.3 Environmental & Track Defect Hazards
Key Takeaways
Report a track defect, flood or structural damage that might endanger trains immediately, and take necessary action to stop trains under Handbook 1.
Report observable facts and the affected line. Do not wait to measure the defect or assign a track engineering classification before reporting a danger.
Poor visibility rules out lookout warning. Stop and move the group to safety if the conditions or sightline no longer allow the safe system to work.
Under Handbook 7, work noise must not prevent anyone hearing an equipment warning. A failed warning test requires a suitable change before work.
Distinguish a threat to trains from a failed workgroup control
The Controller of Site Safety (COSS) needs to identify which part of the plan has ceased to be safe when a condition changes. An apparent buckle in a running line may endanger trains even after the team has stepped clear. Dense mist at a work site might invalidate lookout warning without itself obstructing the railway. These situations can happen together. Apply the relevant actions for both. RSSB Handbook 1 Issue 9, section 8 lists track defects, floods, obstructions and damage to structures or earthworks among hazards that might put trains in danger.
Recognise and describe the physical hazard
| Observation | What makes it dangerous |
|---|---|
| A broken rail or visibly displaced rail joint | The running surface or the support at the joint may no longer carry a train safely. |
| Rails visibly out of alignment during hot weather | Heat makes steel expand. Where the track structure no longer resists the forces, the rails may move sideways. |
| Debris across a running line after heavy rain | Debris can obstruct a train, and damage to drainage or earthworks may affect more than one line. |
| Poor support under sleepers or sudden uneven track | Changes in the way the rails are supported can create a track geometry fault. |
Network Rail's explanation of rail buckling explains that direct sunlight can make rails hotter than the air. A local speed restriction may be used to manage heat risk. It does not follow that a visibly buckled line is safe for trains at a reduced speed. Report the condition you see and leave the assessment of fitness for traffic to the responsible railway roles. The Rail Accident Investigation Branch's Carmont synopsis describes a train striking debris washed from a drainage trench. Its Willesden investigation describes a derailment involving track twist, uneven wheel loads and poor support. These examples explain why a hazard need not look like a complete break to matter.
Get the workgroup to safety. Report the line, exact location and what is known or suspected immediately to the appropriate recipient, and take necessary action to stop trains. Do not wait for a measured crack width, rail temperature, or confirmation of the engineering cause. A trained track worker providing emergency protection follows the separate Handbook 2 rules taught in section 9.1. Do not treat an emergency clip or an attempt to phone as assurance that the line is safe.
Recheck protection when work conditions change
RSSB Handbook 7 Issue 10, section 6 requires the COSS to stop and move the group to safety when the safe system ceases to protect it. Check the actual work and access conditions. A warning tested at the start of the shift may no longer reach a worker when another machine starts or the work moves. For equipment warning, section 6.7 requires that work noise does not prevent any member of the group hearing it. Keep the group clear and reassess the arrangement if a test or change shows that the warning is inadequate.
For a separately authorised lookout arrangement, lookouts cannot be used in poor visibility, darkness or in or near a tunnel. A site lookout who loses the view or cannot give an adequate warning gives the warning and then tells the COSS. A horn, whistle or touch must be selected for the work and location and tested as part of the planned arrangement. A touch warning is not an automatic change whenever noise rises. RSSB Handbook 3 Issue 4.
Worked decision: two changes in the same shift
On a hot day the group finds a visible sideways kink in an adjacent line. The COSS reports the affected line and location immediately, rather than treating the expected temperature as a safe operating limit. On a different shift, new plant noise prevents a worker from hearing the tested equipment warning. Even when no physical defect is suspected, the equipment-warning safe system has failed its audibility condition. Stop the work, get the group clear and use a safe system that meets the actual conditions before allowing work to resume. Each response follows from the specific hazard. Workers being clear does not resolve a defect affecting trains, and a line apparently free of defects does not cure a failed warning.
A COSS with the separate lookout competence sees that dense fog has reduced visibility during a planned lookout arrangement. What should the COSS do?
Continue because the arrangement was accepted before the change
Stop work and move the group to a position of safety
Post an intermediate lookout to relay warnings
Carry on provided the allowable line speed stays under 25 mph
On a hot day a COSS sees a pronounced kink in an open running line. What should the COSS do?
Wait for a rail-temperature measurement before reporting
Decide that a reduced train speed makes the line safe
Wait for a driver to confirm the kink is severe
Report the line and precise location immediately and take necessary protective action
Plant noise during a job prevents a member of the group from hearing equipment warning. What does Handbook 7 require?
Add time to the warning calculation and continue
Use an unbriefed worker to relay warnings by touch
Stop relying on the failed arrangement and move everyone to safety before reassessing
Continue as long as another group member can hear the warning
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.