6.3 Equipment Warning: ATWS, SATWS and TOWS
Key Takeaways
Handbook 7 lists four types of equipment warning. The applicable infrastructure instructions determine which methods are available for the work.
Verify competent use, coverage of all approaches, enough time to be in safety at least ten seconds before arrival, and audibility for every worker; test the warning before work.
TOWS is train-operated and SATWS warning cancellation is manual. LOWS is a term for lookout-operated equipment in the Rule Book and historical reports.
On a warning, move immediately to safety and stay there until the COSS gives permission to leave. If the warning system is in doubt, stop and reassess from safety.
A device being available or named in the Rule Book does not establish that it is permitted for this work and location.
Equipment warning has its own conditions
A Controller of Site Safety (COSS) should distinguish equipment warning from both unassisted lookout warning and a line blockage. RSSB Handbook 7 Issue 10, section 6.7 addresses four kinds of equipment warning. None closes an open line to traffic. Check first whether the work itself affects the safety of the line. For example, a warning device cannot take the place of the line protection needed for work that changes the condition of the track.
RSSB Handbook 1 Issue 9, sections 1 and 5.6 explains the terms and how workers respond to an equipment warning. Recognise each type by what starts or cancels the warning, then apply the approved instructions for the actual installation. A rule about one type of receiver, radio channel or alarm cannot be assumed for every system.
| Handbook 7 type | What distinguishes it |
|---|---|
| Automatic track warning system (ATWS) | The system automatically warns of a train approach. |
| Semi-automatic track warning system (SATWS) | The warning is cancelled manually. Cancellation is a safety step. |
| Train-operated warning system (TOWS) | A train operates the warning system. |
| Lookout-operated warning system (LOWS) | A lookout operates the warning equipment. |
The human input on LOWS is one reason that equipment warning is not synonymous with automatic detection. Conversely, the name TOWS does not tell you which detectors are installed or how a specific fault appears. Learn what the agreed warning means and what personnel must do when they receive it. The LOWS definition also helps when reading historical incidents.
Decide whether equipment warning is usable
Confirm that the method and installation are permitted under the current infrastructure manager’s instructions and the planned arrangements for this work. A method listed in the Rule Book may be unavailable under the rules for a particular infrastructure or job. Do not use a device merely because it is installed or because a similar setup was used in the past.
Before starting, check all four requirements in Handbook 7 and test the warning:
- You or someone in the group is competent to use the equipment at this location. Experience of a different installation is not enough to assume this.
- It gives adequate warning of all approaching trains on the relevant lines. Check the approach coverage against the work location, including a direction from which trains can approach even if it is unusual.
- When warned, every member of the group can stop work and reach the position of safety at least ten seconds before the train arrives.
- No noise from the work prevents any member of the group from hearing the warning. Check the positions where people will actually work and the conditions they will be working in, rather than listening only from the quietest point.
If the equipment is already being used when you arrive, agree what is happening with the other user before relying on it. When leaving, agree whether the equipment is to stay in use. Turning off a device without that discussion could remove a warning another group is relying on.
Worked check: timing and audibility
Suppose the approved setup for a task gives 24 seconds between the warning and the arrival of an approaching train on the fastest relevant approach. It takes the last member of the group five seconds to stop and seven to reach the position of safety. That leaves 24 − (5 + 7) = 12 seconds in safety, so the timing check passes on those assumptions. The rule is about time already in safety before arrival; it does not set a universal deadline of ten seconds from the warning to reach safety.
Now assume a worker at the far end cannot hear the test warning under the expected work noise. The arrangement fails the audibility requirement even though the timed exercise passes. Do not start until a suitable arrangement has been set up, tested and briefed. A different equipment setup might work if the approved instructions allow it and it meets all the checks; a line blockage is a different form of protection. Substituting an informal lookout leaves the work unprotected by its approved system.
Respond to a warning or loss of assurance
On the warning, stop and move to the briefed position of safety immediately. Stay there until the COSS gives permission to leave. A warning stopping is not a return instruction. A Network Rail safety alert about a 2022 LOWS near miss at Sharnbrook explains why a train passing on one line does not resolve a warning on another. The report advises standing the group down in safety and confirming what is happening when a warning is in doubt.
If the warning arrangement develops a fault or its status cannot be established, stop relying on it and get the group to safety. Follow the equipment and site instructions for handling the fault. Reassess before anybody returns to work. The absence of a siren does not establish that the installation is healthy or the line clear.
An equipment test gives enough time to reach safety, but a person cannot hear the warning under the noise expected for the task. What should the COSS do?
Start if the fastest worker can reach safety
Start and ask a worker to listen for the device on behalf of the group
Keep the group clear and arrange a safe system that meets the audibility requirement
Reduce the minimum time workers must already be in safety
What distinguishes TOWS from LOWS in the definitions in Handbook 1?
A TOWS warning must be triggered manually by the signaller
A LOWS warning is operated by the first train to pass the site
Either system closes the route when it sounds
A train operates the TOWS warning; a lookout operates the LOWS warning
A train passes and the equipment warning stops. The COSS has not given permission to leave the position of safety. What does a worker do?
Remain in the position of safety
Return to the site of work because the warning has stopped
Return if no second train can be seen
Wait ten seconds and then resume work without asking
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.