14-4 Standard Fire Policy: Appraisal, Company Options, and Valuation

Key Takeaways

  • Under the prescribed form’s appraisal clause, each party selects and notifies the other of its appraiser within 20 days. If the appraisers cannot agree on an umpire for 15 days, either party can request court selection.

  • An itemized written award agreed to by any two and filed with the insurer fixes actual cash value and loss. Assess coverage separately.

  • Track receipt of proof for the company’s option notice. The form prohibits abandonment and authorizes specified settlement options.

  • Payment, suit and assignment of recovery rights have separate triggers under the form.

  • Section 33-32-5 determines building value for qualifying total Georgia residential fire losses. Check depreciation, the initial 30-day rule and statutory exceptions.

Last updated: November 2026

14-4 Standard Fire Policy: Appraisal, Company Options, and Valuation

For a loss under Georgia’s prescribed Standard Fire Policy, lines 123–165 govern appraisal, settlement options, payment, suit and recovery from responsible parties. O.C.G.A. § 33-32-5 supplies a separate valuation rule for certain Georgia residential fire losses.

Appraisal and Loss Ascertainment

When the parties disagree on value or amount, either can demand appraisal in writing. Under lines 123–140 the parties select competent, disinterested appraisers and notify each other of their selections within 20 days of the demand. The appraisers select a competent, disinterested umpire. If they cannot agree for 15 days, either party may request selection by a judge of a court of record in the state where the property is located.

The appraisers state actual cash value and loss separately for each item and send only their differences to the umpire. An itemized written award by any two, filed with the insurer, determines actual cash value and loss. Each party pays its own appraiser and shares the other appraisal and umpire expenses equally. The award determines value or amount. Resolve disputed coverage separately. Section 10.2 distinguishes the Georgia form from other appraisal clauses.

Company Options and Payment

Lines 141–147 allow the insurer to take all or part of the property at the agreed or appraised value or repair, rebuild or replace the damaged property with like kind and quality within a reasonable time. The form provides for notice of intent within 30 days after receipt of the required proof. Georgia § 33-32-3 requires that the option to rebuild or reinstate be reserved in the contract. Lines 148–149 prevent the insured from abandoning property to the insurer. An insured cannot force payment as a total loss by handing over the property.

Apply the clauseTrigger under Georgia’s prescribed form
Notice of intent to exercise a company optionWithin 30 days after the company receives the required proof of loss.
Loss payable, lines 150–156Sixty days after the company receives proof and the loss is ascertained by written agreement or filing of the appraisal award with the company.
Suit, lines 157–161Comply with the policy requirements and commence the suit within two years of inception of the loss, subject to any applicable waiver or governing law.
Subrogation, lines 162–165The insurer may require assignment of recovery rights against another party to the extent it paid the loss.

Worked timing. The insurer receives the signed proof and an itemized appraisal award on June 1. Assume it owes the loss, no separate option has been exercised and no other timing rule applies. The form’s 60 days expire July 31. The suit clause is measured from inception of the loss, a separate event. Document when each required item was received.

In White v. State Farm, the Georgia Supreme Court held that Rule 120-2-20-.02 could not extend the fire form’s two-year minimum to non-fire theft coverage in a multiple-line policy. For policies covered by enacted HB 1344 Part VIII issued, delivered, issued for delivery or renewed in Georgia on or after July 1, 2027, § 33-24-59.38 sets a two-year minimum from the date of loss for the first-party property portions. Liability and workers’ compensation coverage are exempt. See Section 24.3.

Georgia’s Valued Policy Law

Under § 33-32-5, check each element before using the policy amount as the value of a building. The policy must be issued to a natural person or persons or to an entity wholly owned by natural persons. It must insure a specifically described one- or two-family residential building or structure in Georgia. Fire must wholly destroy it without fraudulent or criminal fault by the insured or someone acting on the insured’s behalf.

The building amount then establishes the value, subject to depreciation since issuance or last renewal. If the total fire loss occurs within 30 days of the policy’s original effective date, use actual loss subject to the amount of insurance. Subsection (b) also excludes partial loss, qualifying undisclosed concurrent fire coverage, a blanket form covering two or more buildings for one amount, and completed-value builders’ risk. Subsection (a) permits coinsurance and preserves qualifying repair or replacement when provided in the policy at the insurer’s expense without an insured contribution. Determine the payable amount or selected settlement method after determining the statutory building value.

Worked valuation. A qualifying house is wholly destroyed by fire six months after inception. If building insurance is $260,000, there is $5,000 in depreciation since inception and no other exception applies, the statutory building value is $255,000. If the same loss had occurred within 30 days of original inception and actual loss was $230,000, the statutory measure would instead reflect that actual loss within the $260,000 amount.

Fire and Direct Causation

The form insures direct loss by fire subject to its exclusions. In the traditional fire-insurance usage, a fire used as intended within a fireplace is described as friendly, while an accidental fire outside that intended setting is hostile. A second fire caused by sparks that ignite a rug or wall after leaving the fireplace presents a clear case for investigating direct fire damage. Check the issued form and distinguish effects of ordinary operation from damage caused by an accidental fire.

Document which event caused the damage. An applicable covered fire can cause damage through smoke or firefighting efforts. For an explosion or riot that causes fire, the form separately limits recovery to the ensuing fire loss, as explained in Section 14.2. Apply exclusions, required causation and settlement limits to the actual damage.

Loading diagram...
SFP Appraisal Process and Payment Timeline (Lines 123-156)
Test Your Knowledge

An insured and an adjuster agree that a warehouse fire is covered under Georgia’s prescribed Standard Fire Policy, but the insured claims the Actual Cash Value of the roof damage is $140,000 while the adjuster estimates $95,000. The insured sends a written demand for appraisal. How is the umpire selected if the two party-appointed appraisers cannot agree on one?

A

The insured's appraiser automatically acts as the tie-breaking umpire after 20 days

B

The Georgia Commissioner of Insurance directly calculates the ACV without an umpire

C

The appraisal is canceled and the insured must immediately file a breach-of-contract lawsuit

D

If the two appraisers fail for 15 days to agree on a competent and disinterested umpire, either party may request a judge of a court of record in the property's state to select the umpire

Test Your Knowledge

A Georgia homeowner's specifically described single-family residence insured for $280,000 (Coverage A) under a policy issued 18 months ago to the homeowner is wholly destroyed by an accidental fire with no statutory exclusion, criminal fault, fraud or depreciation since the last renewal. Independent real estate appraisals show the pre-fire market value of the structure was $245,000. Under Georgia's Valued Policy Law (O.C.G.A. § 33-32-5), what value governs the structure claim?

A

$245,000, because the Standard Fire Policy never pays more than Actual Cash Value

B

$210,000, after applying an automatic 25% statutory depreciation schedule

C

$280,000, because the policy face amount is taken conclusively as the value of a qualifying 1- or 2-family residence wholly destroyed by fire

D

$0, unless the homeowner submits a contractor's replacement bid within 30 days

Test Your Knowledge

A spark escapes a homeowner’s operating fireplace, ignites the living room rug and starts a fire that destroys part of the room. The property is insured under Georgia’s prescribed Standard Fire Policy, and no exclusion or other restriction applies. How should the adjuster classify the damage from the escaped fire?

A

An excluded explosion because the spark left the fireplace.

B

Direct fire loss from an accidental fire outside the intended fireplace.

C

Damage covered only by the five-day removal provision.

D

Loss that can be valued only under Georgia’s Valued Policy Law even though the building is partly damaged.

Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.