18-4 Title Insurance: Owner's vs. Lender's Policies, Title Searches, and Loss Adjustment
Key Takeaways
Title insurance addresses specified defects and loss affecting the insured title or mortgage, including limited applicable post-policy-date risks.
The 2021 Owner’s and Loan forms use different rules for continuation, insured successors and loss valuation.
Read the actual Schedule B exceptions and endorsements before deciding if a particular lien, survey issue or other matter is covered.
Separate the Georgia lawyer’s closing role from the insurer’s defense, cure and payment options.
Value a covered title loss at the date and under the limits specified in the issued form.
18-4 Title Insurance: Owner's vs. Lender's Policies, Title Searches, and Loss Adjustment
A title claim concerns a defect in the legal interest in land or in a security instrument. Georgia defines title insurance in § 33-7-8. The examples below use ALTA Owner's and Loan Policies, 2021 v. 01.00. Use the issued policy, including the actual schedules and endorsements, to decide the claim.
Identify the estate, policy and insured
A title search gathers land records to identify ownership, encumbrances and items to clear or list in the policy. Title insurance indemnifies covered monetary loss and has defined defense and cure obligations. The premium is generally paid once at closing. Check the Date of Policy, which the form identifies in Schedule A. The 2021 Owner's form principally covers stated risks as of that date, and Covered Risks 9 and 10 expressly reach specified later events. The Loan form also has specified post-date risks, including a qualified construction-financing branch. A discovery after closing can concern an earlier defect.
| Question | 2021 Owner's Policy | 2021 Loan Policy |
|---|---|---|
| What is insured? | A named estate or interest in the land and specified risks affecting title. | The insured mortgage and specified risks, including covered problems with its enforceability or priority. |
| Who can claim? | The named insured and qualifying successors or grantees in Condition 1.g, including specified successors by operation of law. An ordinary purchaser does not become insured merely by buying the property. | The named insured and specified other insureds in Condition 1.j, including a future owner of the indebtedness that meets the definition. Confirm the actual sale or transfer, holder status and applicable predecessor defenses. |
| How does coverage continue? | Condition 2 addresses the insured's retained interest, a qualifying purchase-money obligation and liability on transfer warranties. | Condition 2 includes qualifying ownership after acquiring the title and specified retained interests or obligations. Voluntary satisfaction or release of the insured mortgage terminates liability subject to Condition 2. |
| Where are the dollar limits? | Start with the Amount of Insurance in Schedule A and apply the adjustments in the form and endorsements. | Start with the Amount of Insurance in Schedule A, then separately use the defined Indebtedness and other loss limits under Condition 8. Principal paydown can affect indebtedness. It does not automatically rewrite Schedule A. |
In a refinance, identify the original insured mortgage, the status of any prior lender's loan and whether it has been voluntarily satisfied. A new lender examines its own mortgage and contract. The original loan policy does not become ownership coverage for the borrower.
Compare covered risks, exclusions and exceptions
Schedule A specifies the insured, land, legal interest, date and insurance amount. Schedule B contains actual exceptions, which can include listed easements or title-specific matters. A risk in the printed grant can be removed by an applicable exception. For example, forgery, lack of authorization, an improper deed recording or an indexing defect can trigger Covered Risk 2 in the 2021 owner's form. Missing heirs may affect how title is vested, and the form separately covers lack of a right of access. An assigned parking arrangement or the quality of a driveway does not itself establish loss of a legal access right.
An easement, encroachment, possession claim, unrecorded lien or survey problem requires reading the actual schedule and endorsements. The 2021 owner's base form does not make this list a universal Schedule B. For government regulation or eminent domain, compare the actual exclusions with their respective limited Covered Risks. For a recent Georgia mechanic's lien, § 44-14-361.1 sets a 90-day filing period with its own triggers and other requirements. If work ended before closing and a lien is later recorded, check the work and filing dates, priority, covered risk, exclusions and actual Schedule B. The fact it was unrecorded on the Date of Policy does not answer the coverage question by itself.
Georgia closing and title claim handling
Georgia's Supreme Court approved UPL Advisory Opinion 2003-2 and Formal Advisory Opinion 13-1. A lawyer ordinarily controls the Georgia closing and cannot delegate that legal responsibility or reduce it to merely witnessing a signing. The opinions distinguish legal functions, including a title opinion and oversight of conveyance, from gathering facts or preparing title abstracts. Check § 44-5-30 for Georgia deed attestation and its electronic-filing exception, and § 44-14-13 for the applicable disbursement rules. The lawyer's closing role and the title insurer's policy obligations are separate.
Obtain the full policy and schedules, instruments creating or releasing the alleged interest, the closing file, and any complaint or demand. Condition 3 generally requires prompt written notice of a covered-type matter and addresses prejudice from delay. Condition 4 allows the insurer to require signed proof describing the defect and the basis of the claimed loss.
- Defense and cure. Check Conditions 5 and 9 for defense of the covered matter at the insurer's expense and reasonable cure, including litigation where applicable. A recorded corrective instrument or an agreed release may resolve the loss. Scope defense and authorized costs to the contract.
- Payment and settlement options. Condition 7 addresses limit tender or other settlement. Under the Loan form it also allows purchase of the defined indebtedness in exchange for transfer of the debt, mortgage and collateral.
- Monetary valuation. The Owner form uses the lesser of the adjusted insurance amount and the fair market value difference between title as insured and title subject to the covered matter. Discovery is the usual valuation date under that form. Condition 8 allows different dates in specified cases, including a qualifying election after total failure of title. Under the Loan form, consider the insurance amount, indebtedness, value difference and any applicable government-mortgage basis, and use the applicable Condition 8 date. Authorized defense costs and expenses are treated separately as specified.
Worked easement claim. A Georgia homeowner's 2021 Owner's form shows $420,000 in Schedule A. An unexcepted, covered easement is discovered two years later. Stipulate the insurer settles the loss in money, the title is worth $450,000 as insured and $405,000 with the easement at the applicable discovery date, and no other adjustment applies. The loss calculation gives $45,000 within the limit. Condition 10 generally reduces the insurance amount by the indemnity paid. It leaves $375,000 in this example, with qualifying costs, fees and expenses treated separately.
A Georgia lender sells both the loan and its insured mortgage to an investor that acquires the indebtedness for its own account. The original policy is the 2021 ALTA Loan Policy. The credit remains outstanding. What does the investor establish for possible insured status?
The policy converts to coverage of the borrower’s equity after any note transfer.
The investor can qualify as a future owner of the indebtedness under Condition 1.j, subject to the form’s requirements and defenses.
Sale of the mortgage automatically voids the policy without renewal premium.
The insurer must pay the original principal whenever the investor demands it.
Work on a Macon house ends shortly before closing. A contractor later timely records an otherwise valid lien. The buyer’s actual Schedule B expressly excepts unrecorded mechanics’ liens for pre-closing work, and no endorsement removes that exception. The lien was unrecorded at the Date of Policy. Why does the policy exclude this claim?
All title policies exclude every lien a buyer discovers after closing.
A mechanic’s lien can attach only to personal property.
The actual Schedule B exception reaches this lien and the issued endorsements leave it in place.
A recorded lien is covered regardless of any actual exception.
A Georgia buyer with a 2021 ALTA Owner’s Policy discovers an undisclosed prior heir who asserts a valid ownership share. Stipulate the claim is covered and unresolved. Which combination describes available insurer options under the form?
Pay only the depreciated Actual Cash Value of the missing heir's portion after subtracting a $1,000 deductible.
Cancel the policy retroactively and refund the one-time closing premium.
Refer the claim to the buyer's Homeowners Coverage A policy because real property ownership is a dwelling exposure.
Provide the applicable defense, seek a permitted cure or settlement, or pay covered monetary loss under the policy’s measure and limit.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.