24-3 Notice of Claim, Proof of Loss, Duties After Loss, Insurer Obligations, & Appraisal/Arbitration
Key Takeaways
The notice of an occurrence and the forwarding of lawsuit papers can trigger separate duties. Check the policy’s requirements and the rules on prejudice.
The Georgia claim-form requirement runs 15 calendar days from request. The insured’s own proof deadline depends on the policy, and federal flood can have a FEMA-authorized adjustment.
A timely reservation of rights communicates the insurer’s position while defending. A nonwaiver agreement requires assent.
For appraisal, identify the amount dispute and check the form for selection, expenses and the requirements for an award. Coverage and broader liability questions require a separate determination.
Georgia limits policy arbitration. The Standard Fire Policy’s suit period and the later statutory first-party property floor have different scopes and applicability dates.
24-3 Notice of Claim, Proof of Loss, Duties After Loss, Insurer Obligations, & Appraisal/Arbitration
Notice of claim and proof of loss
For first-party property loss, give notice to the insurer or other recipient specified in the policy. Record the loss and notice dates and the reason for any delay. In the HO 00 03 05 11 base form, theft also requires notice to police. A liability policy can require two separate steps: report the occurrence or offense promptly under the applicable condition, and forward demands, summonses and other suit papers as required. A first report of an incident does not establish that the insurer received the later lawsuit.
Plantation Pipe Line v. Stonewall distinguishes an express condition precedent from a provision for which prejudice must be shown. If timely notice is a valid prerequisite, an unreasonable, unjustified delay can defeat coverage without a separate showing of harm. The HO 00 03 05 11 base form expressly makes prejudice relevant to its post-loss duties. Liability files can also involve rights of injured third parties. For example, Georgia's motor-vehicle notice-of-suit statute, § 33-7-15, addresses the insurer's receipt of notice from other sources.
A signed, sworn proof of loss reports the facts and valuation requested under the policy. Check the specific form for the required details and event that starts the clock.
| Example | Proof requirement and trigger |
|---|---|
| HO 00 03 05 11 and CP 00 10 10 12 base forms | 60 days after the insurer's request. The contents required by the homeowners form include interests and liens, the cause and timing, other insurance, title or occupancy changes, estimates and the inventory required by that form. |
| Georgia Standard Fire Policy | 60 days after the loss unless the insurer extends the time in writing. |
| Federal NFIP Standard Flood Insurance Policy | The standard deadline is 60 days from the loss. Check any FEMA-authorized extension or waiver and the issued SFIP terms. The adjuster cannot personally extend a federal deadline. |
| Georgia insurer forms obligation | Section 33-6-34(11) addresses supplying necessary claim forms and instructions within 15 calendar days of a request. Under § 33-24-39, failure or refusal to furnish proof forms after written request or written notice of loss constitutes waiver of the proof requirement. |
Other duties can include reasonable protection and inspection of damaged property, furnishing records, cooperating in a defense, and submitting to an examination under oath if the applicable policy authorizes and calls for it. The insurer may ask separately for a sworn proof and a permitted EUO. Under § 33-6-34(9), asking for duplicate verification of information from formal proof cannot be used to unreasonably delay investigation or payment. Section 4-2 explains how to test a duty against the actual wording and facts.
Settlement obligations and preserving defenses
Section 33-6-34 addresses insurer conduct including reasonably prompt acknowledgment, reasonable investigation before refusal to pay, and fair settlement when liability is reasonably clear. Section 33-6-33 sets the flagrant or general-business-practice threshold and § 33-6-37 addresses the absence of a private cause of action for an article violation. The first-party property remedy under § 33-4-6 requires a covered loss, a sufficient demand when payment is due and a bad-faith refusal to pay within 60 days. See Section 12-1 for the separate remedy and deadlines.
Check how policy payment becomes due. In CP 00 10 10 12 the 30-day payment clause refers to receipt of sworn proof and requires compliance with the coverage part and agreement or an appraisal award. HO 00 03 05 11 uses 60 days after receipt of proof with agreement, entry of final judgment or filing of an appraisal award.
When the insurer will defend a potentially covered lawsuit but sees a possible exclusion or other defense, communicate a timely, clear reservation of rights to the insured while defending. State the defenses and why they may apply. In World Harvest Church v. GuideOne, an equivocal oral statement was inadequate, although Georgia law does not invariably require writing. Use a written notice to document what the insurer communicated. A nonwaiver agreement relies on agreement with the insured concerning which rights are preserved. Merely sending a proposed agreement does not create that agreement.
Hoover v. Maxum distinguishes a defense under reservation from an outright refusal to defend accompanied by a purported reservation. For a disputed defense obligation, refer the file for a coverage decision and potential declaratory relief. A reservation preserves identified issues when effective. Its effect depends on the notice, timing and conduct.
Appraisal, arbitration and legal action
Appraisal
Under a typical appraisal clause, a party may make a written demand when the dispute concerns the value or amount of an otherwise covered loss. In Georgia's prescribed Standard Fire Policy, each party selects an appraiser and notifies the other within 20 days of demand. If the appraisers fail to agree on an umpire within 15 days, either party can seek court selection. The parties each pay their own appraiser and share the other expenses of the appraisal and umpire. A written award by any two, filed with the insurer, fixes the value and amount of loss under that form. Check the issued form for the procedure and deadlines.
In McGowan v. Progressive, the Georgia Supreme Court held that appraisal of value could not dispose of the broader legal claims. In Lam v. Allstate, the appellate majority treated disagreement over how much of the roof the wind had damaged as a coverage issue beyond appraisal. If both agree the collapsed roof is covered and dispute only the cost of repairing it, follow the form's appraisal process. If they disagree about whether policy language excludes part of the work, address that issue separately from the amount.
Arbitration and suit
Section 9-9-2(c)(3) excludes insurance contracts from the Georgia Arbitration Code and preserves arbitration provisions in contracts between insurance companies. In Continental v. Equity and McKnight v. Chicago Title, courts declined to enforce policy arbitration agreements under the federal Arbitration Act because the McCarran-Ferguson Act preserved the Georgia insurance rule. Check the governing agreement and law for a particular inter-insurer arbitration.
Review the policy's action clause and any applicable minimum before recording a deadline. If a plaintiff seeks to join a Georgia motor carrier's insurer, also check §§ 40-1-112(c) and 40-2-140(d)(4). Under the post-July 2024 rules, the joinder bases include motor carrier insolvency or bankruptcy or failure after reasonable diligence to effect personal service, subject to the governing provision.
| Type of deadline | Rule to check |
|---|---|
| Contractual Georgia first-party property suit limit | The Standard Fire Policy uses two years from inception of a fire loss. In White v. State Farm, the Georgia Supreme Court held that Rule 120-2-20-.02 could not impose that floor on theft coverage in a multiple-line policy. For policies within HB 1344 Part VIII issued, delivered, issued for delivery or renewed in Georgia on or after July 1, 2027, § 33-24-59.38(a) provides a two-year floor from the date of loss for the first-party property portion. Liability and workers’ compensation are exempt. |
| Georgia simple written contract | Section 9-3-24 generally uses six years from when the obligation became due and payable. A valid shorter contractual deadline can govern the policy claim. |
| Georgia tort | Section 9-3-33 generally allows two years for injury to the person. Sections 9-3-30 and 9-3-31 generally allow four years for damage to realty and personalty, respectively. Check accrual and applicable exceptions. |
Sources: Georgia notice decision · FEMA claims manual · World Harvest · Hoover · McGowan · Lam · Georgia Standard Fire Policy · White v. State Farm · Enacted HB 1344
A commercial insured's warehouse suffers a roof collapse. The insurer and insured agree that the collapse damaged the same roof components and they agree on the repairs needed, but the insurer's adjuster estimates repairs at $115,000 while the insured's contractor estimates $180,000. The CP 00 10 10 12 appraisal clause applies, and the insured demands appraisal. Which statement accurately describes how the Appraisal panel operates?
The umpire must independently rewrite the estimate and overrule both appraisers if their numbers differ by more than 20%
The insurer pays both appraisers and the umpire if the final award exceeds the insurer's initial $115,000 estimate
Each pays its own appraiser and shares the other appraisal and umpire expenses equally. A decision agreed to by any two sets the loss amount.
The appraisal panel will decide both the dollar amount of the roof repair and whether an Ordinance or Law exclusion bars code-upgrade costs
A Georgia insured files a homeowner's theft claim and asks the insurer in writing for proof-of-loss forms on June 1. On June 28, the insurer still has not sent any claim forms or instructions. Which Georgia provision specifies the missed 15-day deadline?
O.C.G.A. § 33-4-6; the insured automatically wins an immediate 50% bad-faith penalty on June 29
O.C.G.A. § 33-6-34(11) requires necessary claim forms with instructions within 15 calendar days of a request.
O.C.G.A. § 9-9-2(c)(3); the insurer forfeits its right to request an Examination Under Oath
O.C.G.A. § 9-3-24; the general limitation period for written contracts sets the deadline for mailing claim forms
A Georgia commercial insured is sued for negligent site maintenance, and the plaintiff's complaint also includes allegations of intentional assault that may be excluded. The insurer wants to provide a defense immediately without waiting for the insured to sign paperwork, while preserving its right to contest indemnity later. What should the adjuster issue?
A unilateral Reservation of Rights (ROR) letter specifying the potential coverage defenses while defending the insured
A Non-Waiver Agreement, which takes legal effect immediately without the insured's signature
A binding arbitration demand under O.C.G.A. § 9-9-2(c)(3) to resolve the intentional-act issue before defending
A formal Proof of Loss request giving the plaintiff 60 days to substantiate damages
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.