8.1 Commercial General Liability (CGL): Occurrence vs. Claims-Made and Coverage A (BI/PD)
Key Takeaways
CG 00 01 04 13 includes injury timing, territory and prior-knowledge tests. Notice and forwarding suit papers remain relevant.
CG 00 02 04 13 tests injury or damage against the retroactive date and term end, and tests the date a claim is first made.
The unamended basic extended reporting clause uses different periods for previously reported and unreported occurrences. A paid supplemental endorsement has distinct terms.
Identify whether a covered Coverage A claim draws from the general or products-completed operations aggregate.
Georgia's duty-to-defend analysis includes potentially covered allegations and can require consideration of facts the insured supplies.
8.1 Commercial General Liability (CGL): Occurrence vs. Claims-Made and Coverage A (BI/PD)
Compare the unamended ISO CG 00 01 04 13 occurrence form and CG 00 02 04 13 claims-made form. Both organize coverage around Coverage A for bodily injury and property damage, Coverage B for personal and advertising injury and Coverage C medical payments. Establish which form and amendments were in force for the exposure. Coverage A decisions require the insured's status, the injury or damage, timing and territory, and the applicable limits and exclusions.
Use the injury, claim and notice dates
| Inquiry | CG 00 01 04 13 | CG 00 02 04 13 |
|---|---|---|
| Injury or damage | From an occurrence in the coverage territory, with injury or damage during the term and the applicable prior-knowledge condition. | From an occurrence in the coverage territory. Injury or damage must be before term end and on or after any retroactive date. |
| Claim | The date a claimant first makes a demand is distinct from the date of injury. | A claim must first be made against an insured in the policy period or in an applicable extended reporting period. |
| Notice and cooperation | Check how the insured reports an occurrence, records and forwards a claim, and sends suit papers. | Apply the first-made definition and separately check the policy's duties for notice of an occurrence, claim or suit. |
Under CG 00 01, an occurrence is an accident, including continuous or repeated exposure to substantially the same general harmful conditions. Check when the injury or property damage actually occurs and whether a specified insured or authorized employee already knew before the policy period of any injury or damage. Check the form's treatment of continuation, change or resumption. A late demand can relate to an earlier injury. The coverage review still tests notice, cooperation and the applicable suit facts. For latent or progressive damage, secure records and expert evidence of when damage first occurred and how it developed.
Under CG 00 02, measure first-made timing by the earlier of applicable receipt and recording of claim notice by an insured or the insurer, or the insurer's settlement, as stated in A.1.c. The separate duties provision includes written claim or suit notice to the insurer as soon as practicable. A specialty claims-made-and-reported agreement can add a different reporting deadline. A missing retroactive date removes that specific cutoff. Coverage scope, claim timing, exclusions and amendments still apply.
Extended reporting under the CG 00 02 base form
The form provides extended reporting when cancelled or not renewed, or when the insurer renews or replaces with a later retroactive date or a form that does not cover the stated causes on a claims-made basis. Extensions preserve an opportunity for qualifying claims tied to in-scope pre-expiration injury, damage or offenses. They do not extend the policy period.
- Basic extension. The automatic extension is free. Claims from qualifying occurrences or offenses reported under the specified duties clause no later than 60 days after expiry have five years measured from expiry. Claims from previously unreported occurrences or offenses have 60 days. This extension leaves policy limits in place and is unavailable when subsequent insurance covers the claim or would cover it but for exhaustion of its amount.
- Supplemental extension. The unamended form offers an unlimited extension by paid endorsement starting after the basic extension. The insured submits a written request within 60 days after the term and pays the premium when due. The base cap is 200% of the annual coverage-part premium. The clause adds separate supplemental aggregates corresponding to the applicable declared aggregates for claims first received and recorded in the supplemental period. It also specifies that the endorsement is excess over other valid collectible insurance in force as described there. Check any changes to the actual issued extensions.
Worked timing. A warehouse's base CG 00 02 expires December 31, a qualifying liability-causing injury occurred before expiry and after the retroactive date, and the insured properly reports the occurrence 20 days after expiry. The claimant first makes a qualifying demand two years later. Assume the form was not renewed, no subsequent policy covers the claim and all remaining conditions are met. The demand is within the five-year branch. If the occurrence were still unreported when the first claim arrived two years later, the 60-day basic branch would not reach that demand. An applicable supplemental endorsement would need separate review.
Coverage A, hazard and limits
Coverage A insures damages the insured is legally obligated to pay because of covered bodily injury or property damage. The form defines bodily injury to include sickness, disease and resulting death. It includes physical injury to tangible property and its resulting loss of use, and qualifying loss of use without physical injury. Electronic data is not tangible property for this definition. The territory includes the U.S., its territories or possessions, Puerto Rico and Canada. The form separately addresses transit between covered places and qualifying worldwide products, short-term business and specified electronic offenses, with the stated suit or insurer-agreed settlement requirement.
A customer slip in a store or a roofer dropping equipment during ongoing work presents a premises or operations exposure. A product after the insured gives up physical possession, or finished work that causes injury away from premises the insured owns or rents, can present a products-completed operations exposure. Under CG 00 01, work is generally completed at the earliest of finishing all work in the contract, finishing work at a particular job site in a multisite contract, or putting the part at issue to its intended use by someone other than another contractor or subcontractor working on that project. Otherwise completed work that needs service or correction can remain in that classification. Abandoned work and the form's stated exceptions have additional terms.
| Claim classification | Common provision under the stated base form |
|---|---|
| Premises or ongoing operation | General Aggregate, subject to per-occurrence and applicable other limits. |
| Products-completed operations hazard | Separate aggregate for covered Coverage A damages, subject to the definition and any classification schedule affecting treatment. Coverage C excludes injury included in this hazard. |
Defense, settlement and indemnity
Compare the complaint and policy. Under Georgia's Penn-America v. Disabled American Veterans, potentially covered allegations can call for defense of the suit even if indemnity remains uncertain. Under Colonial Oil v. Underwriters, due consideration and a reasonable investigation may be required if the insured presents facts that could bring a facially excluded suit within coverage. Actual covered liability and the insurer's payment obligations are separate questions. Use the reservation and notice units for unresolved defenses.
The base form's Supplementary Payments include insurer-incurred expenses and other listed items outside the liability limits. The duty ends when the applicable limit is used in payment of Coverage A or B judgments or settlements or Coverage C medical expenses. Verify which applicable limit is exhausted. A reserve or a defense bill does not by itself make that payment.
Read each exclusion with its exceptions
| Exclusion | Claim check under CG 00 01 04 13 |
|---|---|
| Expected or intended injury | Apply from the insured's standpoint. The clause excepts bodily injury from reasonable force to protect persons or property. |
| Contractual and liquor liability | Evaluate liability that would exist without the contract and defined insured contracts executed before injury or damage. Apply the stated alcohol-business condition and actual causation under the liquor wording. |
| Workers' compensation and employer's liability | Check statutory obligations and qualifying employee injury separately. Employer’s liability has an insured-contract exception and other stated terms. |
| Pollution | Apply the specific discharge and location or operations provision. Building equipment fumes, hostile fire and operating fluid exceptions have different conditions. |
| Aircraft, auto, watercraft and mobile equipment | Check definitions, the qualified exceptions and the facts of transport, operating equipment and compulsory auto insurance law. The mobile equipment exclusion addresses transport by a qualifying auto. |
| Damage to property, product, work or impaired property | Identify which property was damaged and when. The unamended your-work exclusion has a qualifying subcontractor exception. Apply other terms, including the separate withdrawal or recall exclusion. |
| Electronic data | Separately check the data exclusion and its exception for liability because of bodily injury. |
The unamended CG 00 02 04 13 form covers a manufacturer for the January 1, 2024 to January 1, 2025 term with a January 1, 2022 retroactive date. An equipment malfunction damaged a neighbor’s building on November 10, 2021. All the claimed physical damage occurred on that date. The neighbor’s demand is first made on August 14, 2024. How does the retroactive date apply?
Coverage applies in full because the claim was formally asserted against the insured during the active 2024 policy period.
The property damage predates the retroactive date, even though the demand was first made during the term.
Coverage applies automatically under the Basic Extended Reporting Period five-year midi-tail provision.
Coverage must be shared on a pro-rata basis between the insurer that covered the risk in 2021 and the 2024 claims-made carrier.
An Atlanta store is insured under CG 00 01 04 13 without a defense-cost endorsement. A customer’s suit alleges one count outside coverage and a separate negligence count from an accidental slip on an unmarked wet floor that potentially falls within the policy. No applicable limit is exhausted and notice duties are met. What is the defense obligation?
The insurer must defend the entire lawsuit at its own expense outside policy limits, because the duty to defend is broader than the duty to indemnify and is triggered when any complaint allegation potentially falls within coverage.
The insurer has no duty to defend the lawsuit because the presence of an intentional assault allegation completely invalidates the commercial liability policy.
The insurer is obligated to defend Count II only, leaving the department store to hire and pay for its own independent defense counsel for Count I.
The insurer must provide a defense, but all legal fees and court expenses incurred will be deducted directly from the policy's $1,000,000 Each Occurrence limit.
A CGL-insured electrical contractor finishes rewiring a restaurant it does not own or rent. The restaurant resumes normal operations. Five months later the installed junction box overheats and a fire damages the restaurant’s separate cooking equipment. The contractor has CG 00 01 04 13 without an amendment affecting the relevant classification. Which hazard classification fits the resulting equipment damage?
Premises Liability, because the fire occurred on the physical premises of an operating commercial dining establishment.
Operations Liability, because the property damage was proximately caused by electrical installation work performed by the insured.
Completed Operations Hazard, because the contractor's work had been finished, accepted, and put to its intended commercial use prior to the occurrence.
Contractual Liability, because the electrical work was executed pursuant to a written commercial trade contract.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.