16-4 Equipment Breakdown: Business Income, Spoilage, Expediting Expense, and Claims
Key Takeaways
Check the declarations to establish which EB coverages apply and their limits.
Expediting speeds insured repairs or replacement. Extra Expense addresses qualifying additional operating costs.
A utility waiting threshold and a time deductible work differently under EB 00 20 01 13.
Apply the written request, agreed amount and coverage-position conditions before using a joint or disputed loss agreement.
Equipment Breakdown: Business Income, Spoilage, Expediting Expense, and Claims
A covered compressor failure can create several costs at the same time. Use base EB 00 20 01 13 as an example. For the coverages in A.2, check that a limit or INCLUDED appears on the declarations. Identify the covered cause, eligible costs, other insurance, policy limits and deductible for each. The limit for One Breakdown applies across the coverages. An included limit does not add to it.
Identify the covered cost
| Coverage | How to apply it |
|---|---|
| Property Damage | Direct damage to Covered Property at the described premises. This includes property the insured owns or holds in its care, custody or control for which it is legally liable. The valuation terms compare cost to restore or replace with the amount actually and necessarily expended. Absent written agreement, property not repaired or replaced within 24 months uses the lesser of repair or replacement cost and actual cash value. Check other exceptions. |
| Expediting Expenses | Necessary extra costs to make temporary repairs or speed permanent repairs or replacement of damaged Covered Property, such as qualifying rush freight. |
| Business Income and Extra Expense, or Extra Expense only | If selected, quantify actual lost net income and continuing normal expenses and separately determine necessary excess costs of operating during restoration. A rented temporary operating space can be Extra Expense. Verify that the same cost is counted only once. |
| Spoilage Damage | Qualifying raw materials, work in process or finished products must be in storage or manufacture and owned or subject to legal liability under a written contract. The spoilage must be due to the stated lack or excess of power, light, heat, steam or refrigeration. Necessary loss-reduction expenses are payable up to the amount of loss otherwise payable under this grant. |
| Ordinance or Law | When selected and a covered Breakdown damages the building or structure, check qualifying loss in value, demolition and increased construction costs due to a law in force at the Breakdown. Apply the form's exclusions and actual spending requirements. |
| Data and Media or Hazardous Substance | Section C.5 places distinct limitations within Property Damage, with a base $25,000 for each unless a higher limit or INCLUDED is shown. One addresses necessary data and media restoration or qualifying reprogramming; the other addresses additional clean-up, repair or disposal costs for qualifying contamination. Ammonia has its own treatment under C.5.a for spoilage and is outside the Hazardous Substance definition. |
The base restoration definition starts at the later of the Breakdown or 24 hours before insurer notice and ends five consecutive days after reasonable repair or replacement. If the declarations specify an Extended Period of Restoration number, that number replaces five days. Ordinance or Law and data restoration can change aspects of the time-element period under their own terms. A time deductible is measured immediately following a Breakdown under section D and removes covered loss during that period. Check the form for dollar, daily value or other stated deductible terms.
Utility interruption
Under A.2.e, the named base form extends the applicable Business Income and Extra Expense, Extra Expense only or Spoilage grant when the required Utility Interruption coverage exists. The interruption must result from Breakdown of qualifying local supplier equipment used to provide services to the premises. Check the covered service, causal link and the distinct utility exclusions.
The base waiting period is a duration threshold. Once the interruption lasts at least the declared consecutive time, the grant attaches from the start of the interruption, subject to applicable deductibles and other provisions. In a 40-hour outage and a 24-hour utility threshold, evaluate damage from hour zero under the extension. If there is also a separate applicable time deductible, apply it by its own terms. An 18-hour outage fails the 24-hour utility threshold.
Joint or Disputed Loss Agreement
Compare the agreement in EB 00 20 01 13 E.3 with the substantially similar CP 12 70 09 96 endorsement. Both policies must be in force and insure the damaged property. The insured and both insurers agree to the total amount of the loss, and the insurers take positions within the provisions on disputed coverage or allocation. If both deny and neither contends the other policy provides coverage, the agreement does not apply.
After a written request, each insurer pays the amount it agrees its policy covers and one-half of the disputed amount, subject to the equivalent agreement and applicable policy caps. The payments preserve the parties' other rights. Where both insurers admit some liability and agree to arbitrate, the forms provide for payment within 90 days and arbitration within 90 days after payment. Where the specified cross-contentions apply, the forms call for submission to arbitration within 90 days after payment. Insurers adjust their final shares after resolution under the applicable provisions. The Georgia statutory bad-faith demand procedure under O.C.G.A. § 33-4-6 is a separate claims rule.
Worked file
At an Athens pharmacy, assume the prompt-notice, cause, valuation and deductible conditions are satisfied under the stated EB edition. A covered compressor Breakdown leads to $48,000 of qualifying property damage, including a leased instrument the pharmacy holds and is legally liable for. Limits are sufficient for the following additional losses:
- Rush freight and overtime to complete physical compressor replacement sooner cost $11,000 beyond normal replacement. Allocate this to Expediting Expenses.
- Qualifying PCB remediation beyond ordinary repair costs is $9,500. Apply the Hazardous Substance limitation.
- Eligible temperature-driven spoilage is $31,000. The pharmacy spends $3,000 on temporary cold storage and avoids $7,000 of additional otherwise payable spoilage. The mitigation expense fits within the avoided loss. The eligible spoilage amount is $34,000.
- A distinct 24-hour time deductible applies to Business Income. Restoration-related operations are interrupted for 36 hours and the documented payable income loss for the remaining 12 hours is $4,500. No additional loss is shown after resumption.
Total $107,000 before any further adjustments. Keep separate documentation for physical repair, expedites, extra operational costs and perishable stock.
An insured poultry processor replaces a compressor damaged by a covered Breakdown. It incurs $14,000 of necessary extra rush freight and overtime solely to speed permanent installation. The EB 00 20 01 13 schedule includes Expediting Expenses and all applicable provisions are satisfied. Which grant addresses that extra amount?
Ordinance or Law
Normal Property Damage valuation alone
Utility Interruption
Expediting Expenses
A seafood distributor has Spoilage Damage and Utility Interruption under base EB 00 20 01 13. A qualifying supplier Breakdown interrupts power for 40 hours. The declared utility threshold is 24 consecutive hours, there is enough insurance, and no separate deductible. Eligible temperature-driven spoilage incurred in the first 24 hours is $42,000. What is payable?
$0 because all spoilage occurred before hour 24
$42,000 because the qualifying outage meets the threshold and coverage attaches at interruption
$21,000 split with the utility under the joint loss agreement
$35,700 after a 15% vacancy adjustment
A hotel and both insurers agree the loss is entirely disputed between the commercial property and equipment breakdown carriers and totals $200,000. Each carrier denies payment under its own form but contends the other policy owes it. The damaged property is insured by both in-force policies, which have equivalent CP 12 70 09 96 and EB 00 20 01 13 provisions. The hotel makes a written request, and the applicable caps permit payment without other adjustment. What follows?
Both wait for a court to allocate all liability before paying
The property insurer automatically pays the full claim
Each advances $100,000 and they submit the allocation to arbitration within 90 days after payment
The association paying claims of insolvent insurers pays the entire hotel loss
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.