9.2 Claims Investigation, Evidence Gathering, and Witness Statements
Key Takeaways
Establish the actual claim timing and applicable law before setting deadlines.
Use photographs and a custody record to preserve evidence, including when litigation is reasonably foreseeable under Georgia law.
Apply the law governing the communication and document permissions and procedures. An ordinary recording is an unsworn interview.
Evaluate the policy's EUO duties, material compliance and applicable legal requirements before deciding the consequence of refusal.
Preserve objective fraud indicators and use the actual policy and statutes for coverage, referral or reporting decisions.
9.2 Claims Investigation, Evidence Gathering, and Witness Statements
Promptly establish what happened, what was damaged or who was injured, and what the policy promises. Identify the notice date, the coverage type and the applicable statutory or regulatory timetable. Georgia's Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act includes standards for acknowledgment and investigation, and Rule 120-2-52 supplies distinct applicable first-party P&C timelines. Apply those provisions within their scope and use the actual policy's duties. Read 12-1 for the timing distinctions.
| Step | Work to document |
|---|---|
| Intake and policy | Record reported time, location, parties and circumstances. Obtain declarations, forms, endorsements and applicable limits for the loss date. |
| Contact and mitigation | Explain next steps, request specific material and address immediate safety and reasonable loss prevention. Document what was advised or authorized. |
| Inspect and preserve | Identify what changed, test possible causes and obtain evidence before repair or disposal. Preserve relevant failed components, photographs, reports and electronic records as appropriate. |
| Interview and corroborate | Record each witness's location and opportunity to observe, their actual recollection and changes in the account. Compare independent records. |
| Scope and value | Distinguish pre-existing conditions, direct and consequential effects, alternative repair options, liability evidence and possible recovery from another party. |
| Communicate outcome | Explain the coverage position with applicable terms and facts. Record unresolved issues, next steps, payments and communications. |
Inspect and preserve the scene
Choose an inspection sequence that is safe and preserves evidence. Wide views establish location and context, medium views show relationships, and close-ups document details such as fractures, connections and serial numbers. Include scale when it will help later comparison. Record orientation, time, source and any processing where relevant. Keep original files and document changes in derivative images. A photograph can support or refute an account but may not establish the mechanism without other evidence.
In Georgia, Phillips v. Harmon ties the obligation to preserve relevant evidence to litigation pending or reasonably foreseeable to the party controlling it. Notice can arise from facts and conduct without a filed suit. If a failed connector may bear on liability or subrogation, document it in place, preserve it securely when authorized, record its identity and custody, and arrange appropriate notice and examination before destructive testing. If emergency remediation cannot wait, document the scene and what was changed or removed. Georgia courts assess circumstances when deciding whether to impose a sanction. Evidence loss can weaken recovery without automatically defeating the entire claim.
Interview, record and distinguish sworn duties
Get the witness's open narrative before asking detailed questions. Record location, timing, lighting, vantage point and how the witness learned each key fact. Separate firsthand observations from inference and information supplied by others. Follow up on differences without suggesting answers.
Georgia § 16-11-66(a) permits interception of the stated oral, wire or electronic communication if the interceptor is a party or a party gave prior consent. This is not a broad rule for video or a cross-state call. Federal § 2511(2)(d) has its own condition on a criminal or tortious purpose, and an interstate call can require a separate applicable-law analysis. A routine adult claims interview can be recorded after documenting permission under applicable law and company procedures. Preserve the original recording, identify participants and explain material interruptions. An ordinary interview does not become sworn testimony by being recorded. Capture corrections and the witness's acknowledgment as appropriate. Admissibility is a separate evidentiary inquiry.
An examination under oath (EUO) is a sworn examination under an applicable insurance condition. HO 00 03 05 11 calls for submission as often as reasonably required, outside the presence of another insured, and a signed examination. Its duties provision addresses failure prejudicial to the insurer. Verify who must appear, the request's scope, notice and relevance, compliance or excuse, and the policy's legal consequence. An insurer may use counsel and a reporter, but the contract and applicable law govern. In Halcome v. Cincinnati, a Georgia court evaluated the refusal to supply relevant financial evidence in the specific suspected-fraud setting. A missed appointment or refusal to give a routine unsworn interview is a different inquiry.
Investigate indicators without deciding intent prematurely
Staging a loss and deliberately inflating a genuine loss are different fraud fact patterns. An inconsistent invoice, sudden coverage change or physical fact inconsistent with the reported mechanism calls for verification. Obtain reliable records, retain relevant evidence and document alternate explanations. Financial difficulty alone does not establish deceit or who caused a fire. Escalate reasonably supported concerns through appropriate insurer or investigator procedures. Apply the actual concealment or fraud clause and distinguish any statutory reporting or notification action from coverage and from a criminal prosecution. Under the version of Georgia § 33-1-16(g) effective through 2026, the statute permits specified notifications to law enforcement on its stated grounds and provides related qualified protections. The Commissioner's investigative power is a separate matter. Check effective dates for later law.
Note
If a fire examiner identifies evidence of multiple origins in a burned vehicle and insurer records show a recent coverage change, preserve the original records and request the examiner's supporting findings. Compare scene evidence, witnesses, invoices and prior damage. A concern about intentionally setting the fire supports qualified escalation and analysis. It does not establish that the insured started it or that coverage must be denied.
An adjuster participates in an ordinary adult audio interview taking place entirely in Georgia. What does O.C.G.A. § 16-11-66(a) provide about party status or prior consent?
A certified notary must attend and certify the recording within 48 hours.
Every recorded witness interview must end with sworn testimony.
Only a court can authorize recording an ordinary interview even with consent.
The interception exception can apply when the recorder is a party or one party previously consented.
How does a properly requested examination under oath under HO 00 03 05 11 differ from a routine unsworn claims interview?
Only regulators can conduct an EUO.
An EUO is a sworn examination required under the stated policy terms. Noncompliance must be analyzed under those terms and applicable law.
An ordinary recording becomes an EUO as soon as the recording begins.
A single missed appointment automatically voids the entire contract.
A fire examiner reports physical evidence suggesting a vehicle fire may have been deliberately set, and insurer records show a recent material coverage change. What is the sound investigative response?
Preserve the evidence, verify the examiner's findings and coverage history, and escalate the supported concern under the applicable procedures.
Treat the owner as the perpetrator solely because the coverage changed.
Apply a flat statutory fraud deduction to any payment.
Release the physical evidence to a repair vendor and close the file.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.