23-3 Commercial Excess Liability vs. Commercial Umbrella Liability: Underlying Schedules, SIR, & Drop-Down
Key Takeaways
Use the controlling underlying wording and the excess form’s own schedule and modifications.
For an umbrella, test the independent grant and exclusions before applying underlying limits or an SIR.
Calculate a maintenance gap using the required underlying amount. Check whether a reduction is permitted aggregate exhaustion.
Test the duty to defend separately against each policy, including the kind of payments that qualify as exhaustion.
An underlying insurer’s insolvency raises separate contractual attachment and Georgia Pool inquiries.
Commercial Excess Liability vs. Commercial Umbrella Liability
When a commercial claim may reach several liability policies, identify the upper policy’s coverage grant, applicable retention, and exhaustion and defense terms. This lesson compares the base ISO CX 00 01 04 13 and CU 00 01 04 13, with an illustration from CG 03 00 01 96.
Following-Form Excess vs. Standalone Commercial Umbrella
Following-Form Commercial Excess Liability
CX 00 01 04 13 follows the provisions, exclusions and limitations of the applicable controlling underlying insurance unless its own terms direct otherwise. If they conflict, the excess wording governs, subject to the excess form’s provision against broader coverage. Its own schedule, exclusions, conditions and limits matter. For example, the contract separately addresses whether an underlying sublimit must be scheduled for the related exposure to qualify. Compare event dates and any claims-made conditions across policies.
The applicable retained limit sets the attachment for covered ultimate net loss. Confirm which underlying policy controls the particular claim. The excess grant does not independently insure a loss outside the controlling underlying territory.
Commercial Liability Umbrella
CU 00 01 04 13 insures defined bodily injury and property damage in Coverage A and personal and advertising injury in Coverage B. It pays qualifying ultimate net loss above the applicable retained limit. Read who qualifies, the umbrella’s exclusions and the underlying schedule. The schedule may list commercial general liability, auto liability and employers liability. Workers’ compensation obligations have their own statutory coverage and are excluded under the form.
An umbrella-only claim: For the base form, an otherwise-covered claim outside underlying coverage can be subject to the stated self-insured retention (SIR). The umbrella’s own coverage still needs to apply. Its base territory is worldwide except countries or jurisdictions subject to U.S. sanctions or embargoes. An endorsement can change that definition. Review the underlying policy independently, including its provisions for some foreign occurrences and suits. An umbrella also has specific aircraft, watercraft, care/custody/control and other exclusions. Test the claimed coverage instead of relying on the form’s name.
| Claim file question | CX 00 01 04 13 | CU 00 01 04 13 |
|---|---|---|
| What wording governs? | Applicable controlling underlying policy as modified by the excess wording, within its stated ceiling on scope. | Its liability grants and exclusions, plus any qualifications tied to underlying insurance. |
| What is the threshold? | Applicable retained limit under the excess form. | Available scheduled underlying limits or the declared SIR, as applicable. |
| Underlying aggregate exhausted? | Check exhaustion and the remaining retained limit under the excess wording. | A qualifying exhaustion can leave no remaining scheduled underlying limit. The SIR does not apply when exhaustion is the reason the otherwise applicable underlying insurance is unavailable. |
Self-Insured Retention (SIR) vs. Deductible
A deductible and a retention both allocate some cost to the insured. Determine separately who advances claim payments and which insurer owes a defense.
Liability deductible: CG 03 00 01 96 applies the scheduled deductible per claim or occurrence. It preserves defense terms irrespective of the deductible and permits the insurer to advance some or all of the deductible to effect settlement, with reimbursement by the insured.
Umbrella SIR: CU 00 01 04 13 applies the declared SIR to occurrences or offenses outside underlying coverage, subject to the rest of the umbrella terms. The SIR contributes no separate charge above a qualifying exhausted underlying limit. Read the defense provision independently. In the base form a suit seeking covered damages can trigger defense when the underlying insurance supplies no coverage or its limits have been exhausted. Other insurance and endorsements can affect the duty.
Maintenance of Underlying Insurance Condition
Under CU 00 01 04 13 the insured must maintain scheduled underlying insurance in full effect. A qualifying aggregate reduction or exhaustion from paid claims, settlements or judgments in accordance with the underlying policy’s terms is permitted. A lapse or coverage reduction can leave a gap. When the insured fails to maintain underlying insurance, the umbrella applies as if it were in full effect. The condition requires written notice as soon as practicable of changes, including cancellation, replacement or altered coverage or limits.
Worked Numerical Example: Maintenance of Underlying Insurance Gap
An unamended CU 00 01 04 13 umbrella schedules $1,000,000 per occurrence of underlying CGL and has a $5,000,000 limit. The contractor replaces the primary CGL with a policy that provides only $500,000 per occurrence. A covered $1,400,000 judgment follows. Assume the maintenance wording applies, there is no other insurance, and both policies have sufficient remaining aggregate where applicable.
- Primary CGL Carrier Pays: $500,000 (its full reduced policy limit).
- Umbrella Carrier Pays: $400,000 (excess over the required $1,000,000 attachment point).
- Contractor Pays: The maintenance gap is $1,000,000 − $500,000 = $500,000.
Drop-Down Mechanics & Underlying Insurer Insolvency
Paid Aggregate Exhaustion
Assume the scheduled CGL and base umbrella have concurrent policy dates and cover the same premises occurrences. Primary CGL has a $1,000,000 occurrence limit and a $2,000,000 General Aggregate. Two covered $1,000,000 premises judgments are paid by the CGL insurer and exhaust that aggregate. A third covered $600,000 premises loss then occurs. If the umbrella’s available occurrence and aggregate limits are sufficient and no other insurance applies, the insurer pays $600,000 under this form. The scheduled aggregate is exhausted with no applicable SIR.
When policies have nonconcurrent periods, Section III.5 limits the payments that reduce or exhaust the retained limit. Identify when the bodily injury or property damage occurred or the offense was committed. If the underlying insurance is claims-made, check the claim date against the umbrella policy period or any extended reporting period.
Insolvency of an Underlying Insurer
Both dated ISO forms address insolvency as a distinct condition. Under CU 00 01 04 13 the underlying insurance is treated as in full effect. The umbrella still owes its own covered layer. For a covered $1,400,000 judgment with a $1,000,000 scheduled attachment and sufficient remaining umbrella limits, the hypothetical umbrella indemnity is $400,000.
Georgia’s Insurers Insolvency Pool has a separate statutory inquiry. Under O.C.G.A. § 33-36-14(a), subject to § 33-36-20, a claimant with a covered claim within the coverage of a solvent policy must first exhaust rights under that policy. Amounts received from solvent insurers reduce the claimant’s rights under the Pool statute. Subsection (d) separately provides for recovery from specified insureds and affiliates. Evaluate the coverage actually available under each solvent policy and the Pool’s own eligibility, exclusions, dates, and limits. The Pool provision supplies no contractual umbrella drop-down.
Priority of Coverage & Transfer of Defense Duty
For CG 00 01 04 13, exhaustion ending the duty to defend requires the specified payments of judgments or settlements under A or B or medical expenses under C. The next policy’s defense obligation has its own conditions. CX 00 01 04 13 ties its duty to qualifying exhaustion under the controlling underlying coverage and a suit within the excess grant. Its policies can follow a controlling form that erodes limits through defense expenses. CU 00 01 04 13 addresses both suits seeking covered damages where underlying insurance supplies no coverage and suits following exhaustion. It also contains other-insurance and transfer-of-defense provisions.
Check the applicable supplementary-payments language. Under the base umbrella, listed supplementary payments when the duty to defend exists are in addition to the limits. When the insurer elects to join solely because it has a right to participate, it pays its own expenses without contributing to the expenses of the insured or the underlying insurer. Record the payments supporting exhaustion, confirm which insurer has authority and notify each potentially involved carrier promptly under its policy.
A Georgia manufacturer carries a $1,000,000 primary CGL policy (restricted to the U.S. and Canada) and a $5,000,000 excess policy using CX 00 01 04 13. Its controlling CGL has an express territory endorsement excluding this injury. The excess policy has no modifying endorsement for it. While demonstrating machinery at a trade show in Frankfurt, Germany, an employee negligently injures a German attendee, resulting in a $400,000 tort claim. How does the Following-Form Excess policy respond?
It drops down to act as primary coverage after the manufacturer pays a $10,000 Self-Insured Retention (SIR).
It pays the $400,000 claim in full because excess policies automatically provide worldwide territory.
The claim is outside the controlling CGL territory, and the excess form supplies no broader territorial grant.
It shares the $400,000 loss 50/50 with the primary CGL carrier under the Maintenance of Underlying Insurance clause.
A distributor carries a CU 00 01 04 13 umbrella with a $5,000,000 limit and a $25,000 Self-Insured Retention (SIR), requiring $1,000,000 in underlying CGL coverage. To save money, the distributor cancels its $1,000,000 CGL policy and replaces it with a $400,000 CGL policy without notifying the Umbrella insurer. A customer wins a $1,300,000 covered bodily injury judgment. No other insurance applies and the umbrella has adequate limits. How much will the umbrella pay under its maintenance provision?
$900,000, because the Umbrella drops down to cover everything above the $400,000 collectible CGL limit.
$300,000, because the Maintenance of Underlying Insurance condition holds the Umbrella to pay only as if the full $1,000,000 underlying limit were maintained.
$875,000, because the distributor pays the $25,000 SIR and the Umbrella absorbs the remaining gap.
$0, because any breach of the Maintenance of Underlying Insurance condition automatically voids the entire Umbrella policy.
A business carries a $1,000,000 per-occurrence / $2,000,000 general aggregate primary CGL policy beneath a $4,000,000 umbrella using CU 00 01 04 13. The two policies are concurrent and both cover the stated events. No other insurance applies and the umbrella has adequate remaining limits. During the policy year, the primary insurer pays two separate $1,000,000 covered premises injury settlements, exhausting the primary CGL's $2,000,000 general aggregate. Two months later in the same policy year, a third covered premises injury causes a $350,000 loss. How does the Commercial Umbrella respond?
It refuses to pay because the $350,000 loss does not exceed the $1,000,000 per-occurrence attachment point.
It pays only after the business exhausts coverage with the Georgia Insurers Insolvency Pool under O.C.G.A. § 33-36-14.
It pays only $175,000 under a 50% coinsurance penalty for exhausting primary aggregate limits early.
It pays the $350,000 as a covered umbrella loss after qualifying exhaustion of the scheduled aggregate.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.