23-2 Medical Malpractice, Consent-to-Settle & Hammer Clauses, D&O, Fiduciary, EPLI, & Adjuster/Producer E&O
Key Takeaways
For a health care claim, identify the alleged professional skill or ordinary premises duty. Test NPDB reporting separately if a payment is made.
Compare the exact consent, settlement recommendation and refusal provisions. Apply the clause’s cost and limit terms to the calculation.
Determine whether a D&O claim concerns an insured person’s unindemnified loss, the organization’s indemnification, or its own covered claim.
ERISA fiduciary liability, fraud or dishonesty covered by the plan’s bond, and negligent benefits administration require review under their respective grants.
Check which claimant, act, limits and exclusions the actual EPLI or E&O form covers.
Medical Malpractice, Consent-to-Settle, D&O, Fiduciary, EPLI, & Specialty E&O
A claim can implicate the clinical services, governance, employment or plan administration of the same organization. Classify the alleged act, then identify the wording covering the actor and the relief sought. New allegations can require review under several forms.
Medical Professional Liability and Premises
Medical professional liability insures specified professional services as defined in the contract. Examine whether an individual clinician, group or health care institution is an insured for the service at issue. For example, the HPSO G-121493-B consent endorsement modifies the defense and settlement terms for the underlying health care providers’ Coverage Part, including defined professional liability and Good Samaritan claims. Read the underlying form for the grant and definitions.
Under Georgia law, a medical malpractice claim can involve a breach of the skill and care required of a health care professional. For instance, examine clinical judgment in a surgery, prescribed dosage or patient transfer. Bazemore explains why a failure to follow a care order may involve ordinary negligence on some facts, while Crisp Regional Nursing tied the need for transfer assistance to professional judgment in its case. Determine whether a § 9-11-9.1 affidavit is required. A visitor’s injury from a wet lobby floor generally raises ordinary premises questions. Refer the injury and alleged conduct to each potentially applicable policy.
Consent-to-Settle Clause & The Hammer Clause
Under CG 00 01 04 13, the insurer may investigate and settle at its discretion. Compare the actual professional liability form and endorsements. CNA79034XX (04-2020) requires the first named insured’s informed consent. CNA101445XX (7-23) requires written consent of the named insured or its authorized person, subject to a reasonableness condition and stated exceptions such as a final nonappealable judgment. Determine whether a settlement cap also applies from the operative wording.
National Practitioner Data Bank (NPDB): Check whether a reporting entity exchanged money for the benefit of a named or identifiable practitioner because of a written monetary claim alleging provision or failure to provide health care services. Review the written claim and release or adjudication. The NPDB guide gives examples in which payment solely for a multi-practitioner entity or from a practitioner’s personal funds is outside reporting. For a reportable payment, the reporting period is 30 days from payment. A decision to proceed to trial can still lead to a reportable payment after judgment.
How a Settlement-Refusal Clause Changes the Calculation
- Hard hammer: G-121493-B (07-01) requires consent of the named insured, then caps the insurer’s loss if the insured refuses a settlement recommended by the insurer and acceptable to the claimant. Subject to the available limit, the cap is the amount for which the claim could have settled plus reasonable and necessary claim expenses incurred with insurer consent through the refusal.
- Modified hammer: Another contract can split covered damages and defense costs above its base amount. Check the actual percentages, the refusal date, the expenses included and the available limits. For the worksheet below, assume a hypothetical modified clause pays 80% of both components above the same base.
Worked Numerical Example: Hard vs. Soft Hammer Clause
A claimant is willing to settle a covered claim against an insured orthopedist for $200,000. The insurer recommends accepting that amount. The insured refuses after $50,000 in reasonable and necessary defense costs the insurer consented to. Later there are $100,000 in additional covered defense costs and a $450,000 verdict. Assume sufficient limits and ignore deductibles. Apply the hard clause and the stipulated modified clause separately.
- Total Final Claim Cost: $450,000 (verdict) + $50,000 (pre-refusal defense) + $100,000 (post-refusal defense) = $600,000.
- Under a Pure (Hard) Hammer Clause (100% insured responsibility above baseline):
- Under an 80/20 Soft Hammer Clause (Insurer pays 80% of excess verdict and post-refusal defense; Insured pays 20%):
- Excess above baseline = $250,000 (excess verdict) + $100,000 (post-refusal defense) = $350,000.
- Insurer pays: $250,000 baseline + 80% of $350,000 ($280,000) = $530,000.
- Insured pays: 20% of $350,000 = $70,000.
The hard clause in this example leaves the insured with $350,000. The stipulated 80/20 clause leaves $70,000 with the insured. In a claim file, record the offer, the claimant’s acceptance terms, the insurer’s recommendation and the refusal date before applying the policy.
Directors & Officers (D&O) Liability Insurance
The executive protection coverage section filed by Richardson Electronics illustrates three grants commonly called Sides A, B and C. It differentiates the insured person’s wrongful-act claim from the organization’s indemnification and its own securities claim.
| Insuring Agreement | Role | Trigger To Check |
|---|---|---|
| Side A / Clause 1 | Pay covered loss on behalf of an insured person | The organization has not indemnified the person for the loss. Consider insolvency, the scope of available indemnity and the policy’s retention terms. |
| Side B / Clause 2 | Pay on behalf of the organization | The organization grants indemnity for the insured person’s covered loss as permitted or required by law. Check the corporate retention. |
| Side C / Clause 3 | Pay covered loss of the organization itself | The filed example covers defined securities claims against the organization. Check the purchased entity grant. |
Read the insured capacity, the definition of wrongful act, reporting and claim timing, exclusions, retention and loss allocation before choosing a grant. The cited policy has a separate derivative-demand investigation clause. Check the particular insured-versus-insured and conduct exclusions, including their exceptions and any required adjudication.
Fiduciary Liability Insurance vs. ERISA Fidelity Bond vs. EBL
Under 29 U.S.C. § 1109, a plan fiduciary who breaches an applicable ERISA duty may be personally liable to restore losses to the plan and may be liable for other relief specified by the statute. Identify what duty the complaint actually alleges and what relief it seeks.
| Coverage | Claim or Loss to Review | Governing Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Fiduciary Liability Insurance | Alleged breach of applicable plan duties, such as imprudent plan investments. Some grants also include specified plan administration errors. | Read the definition of wrongful act, insured and loss, including any treatment of benefits that are otherwise due under the plan. |
| ERISA Fidelity Bond | Plan loss caused by fraud or dishonesty of an official subject to § 1112. | Determine the covered handler and amount handled. The usual minimum is 10% of funds handled, subject to a $1,000 floor and a normal $500,000 ceiling on the required amount. The statutory ceiling is $1,000,000 for plans holding employer securities and pooled employer plans. Check exemptions, the Labor Secretary’s authority, and approved surety terms. |
| Employee Benefits Liability (EBL) | Alleged negligent administration such as failure to enroll an eligible employee, where within the definition of administration. | The ABA specimen CG 04 35 (12/07) PRO defines benefit programs and uses a retroactive date if shown and a claims-made provision. Check exclusions, amount of loss and the actual endorsement. |
Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI)
A Travelers EPL-3001 (01-09) coverage part illustrates how claims for defined wrongful employment practices can be insured. Its definitions cover allegations such as discrimination, harassment, retaliation, wrongful termination and certain employment-related defamation or failure to promote. Classification depends on the pleaded act, claimant and capacity under the policy.
In the filed Travelers example, third-party wrongful act coverage depends on the election shown in Item 5. A customer’s discrimination claim requires a review of that grant. A wage-and-hour endorsement can separately address a limited category of defense expenses. Read the endorsement and loss definition to distinguish those expenses from indemnity and check its exclusions, retention and sublimit.
Lawyers, Insurance Agents/Brokers, & Claims Adjusters E&O
- Lawyers: Investigate the underlying deadline and causation if a client alleges a lawyer lost a viable claim by missing a filing date. Verify the named insured, covered legal services and reporting under the actual form.
- Agents and Brokers: For an alleged failure to procure requested insurance, verify the undertaking, what was available and ordered, the issued policy and the loss attributable to the alleged error. Georgia decisions including Charles Parrott & Associates v. Hunt evaluate the parties’ roles and the specific requested coverage.
- Claims Adjusters: Alleged valuation or documentation errors may implicate a policy written for specified adjusting services. Verify whether the relevant duty and authority belonged to the adjuster or another party under the engagement and governing law. Check insured status, the applicable service definition, reporting date and exclusions before assessing coverage.
A surgeon’s policy applies the hard settlement-refusal terms in G-121493-B. The stated claim costs are reasonable and necessary, the insurer consented to the pre-refusal expenses, and no deductible applies. The claimant offers to settle for $300,000 after $60,000 in defense costs have been incurred. The insurer recommends accepting the $300,000 settlement, but the surgeon refuses consent and takes the case to trial. Additional defense costs of $90,000 are incurred, and the jury returns a $550,000 verdict. Assuming ample policy limits remain, how much must the surgeon pay out of pocket?
$250,000, because the surgeon is responsible only for the excess verdict above the $300,000 recommended settlement.
$340,000, representing the $250,000 excess verdict above $300,000 plus the $90,000 in post-refusal defense costs.
$90,000, representing post-refusal defense costs while the insurer pays the full $550,000 jury verdict.
$0, because the Consent-to-Settle Clause prevents the insurer from penalizing an insured who elects to go to trial.
A manufacturing corporation files for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, leaving its treasury unable to advance legal fees or indemnify its Chief Financial Officer (CFO) when shareholders sue the CFO individually for accounting misstatements. Assume a qualifying insured person, covered loss and timely reporting under a policy with the three grants shown in this lesson. Which grant applies directly to the CFO personally?
Side B (Corporate Reimbursement Coverage), because the CFO was acting within the scope of corporate bylaws.
Side C (Entity Securities Coverage), because the claim involves corporate accounting statements.
Fiduciary Liability Coverage, because executives owe statutory duties under ERISA § 1109.
Side A (Non-Indemnifiable Loss Coverage), because the insolvent corporation cannot indemnify the individual officer.
The employer’s benefits administrator forgets to submit a subordinate's signed health-insurance enrollment form to the carrier, leaving the worker uninsured when emergency surgery is required two months later. The worker was eligible and the health plan is scheduled. Which listed endorsement expressly includes enrollment in its definition of administration?
Employee Benefits Liability endorsement CG 04 35 (12/07) PRO.
Fiduciary Liability Insurance covering ERISA discretionary investment breaches.
ERISA Fidelity Bond covering dishonest acts by plan officials.
Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI) covering wrongful workplace practices.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.