20-3 Ordinance or Law Coverage: Coverages A, B, and C in Property Claims
Key Takeaways
Identify the actual ordinance and required work, ground ordinary loss and additional costs in the issued form, and verify replacement or repair conditions.
In CP 04 05 10 12, check the scheduled building and selected coverages, the applicable law, and the extent to which covered damage triggered compliance.
Coverage A shares the building limit. B pays qualifying actual demolition and site clearing. C pays eligible increased construction costs on completion, within the form's timeline.
Apply separate or combined B and C limits as scheduled. Measure the qualifying increased cost at the indicated premises.
CP 15 31 10 12 can add qualifying ordinance delay to the period of restoration under the issued time-element form.
20-3 Ordinance or Law Coverage: Coverages A, B, and C in Property Claims
When a building official requires additional work following covered damage, separate ordinary covered repair from the losses and costs imposed by a law. Obtain the applicable ordinance and the official requirement. A building may have to comply with upgrade, demolition or relocation requirements. The applicable jurisdiction and facts determine the required work.
Base Coverage Options
Ordinance or law exclusions in the commercial and homeowners forms generally restrict recovery for the costs of code compliance. Check the specific additional coverage and any endorsement.
| Form | What can qualify under the additional coverage |
|---|---|
| CP 00 10 10 12 Increased Cost of Construction | Eligible increased cost to repair or replace damaged parts of a covered replacement-cost building under a qualifying ordinance in force at the time of loss. The ordinary cap is the lesser of $10,000 or 5% of the applicable building limit. For qualifying blanket coverage, use the lesser of $10,000 or 5% of the building value at time of loss times the applicable coinsurance percentage. This coverage adds insurance and requires actual repair or replacement as soon as reasonably possible within two years unless extended in writing during that period. |
| HO 00 03 05 11 Ordinance or Law | Up to 10% of Coverage A as additional insurance for qualifying increased costs after covered damage. The clause includes required work on the damaged part, demolition and reconstruction of undamaged parts where covered damage requires total demolition, and specified removal or replacement of undamaged parts needed to complete repairs. Loss in value caused by the law is excluded under this additional coverage. |
An estimate should identify which costs restore covered damage and which meet the minimum applicable ordinance. Costs to cure noncompliance already required before the loss are restricted under the commercial provision. A claim for direct damage and removal of covered damaged debris uses different terms from an undamaged portion condemned under an ordinance.
Scheduled Commercial Endorsement CP 04 05 10 12
Check which of A, B and C the schedule selects for the affected building. The ordinance must be in force at the time of loss in this edition and concern the described building or land-use requirements within the endorsement. Confirm that compliance is required due to covered direct physical damage, or due to the combined damage if there are both covered and uncovered components. When both caused the requirement, apply the form's proportional rule. When only the uncovered damage is the subject of the ordinance, the endorsement does not pay for that requirement. Apply the minimum code standard and check the exclusions for previously required compliance and contamination.
| Coverage | Function and limit |
|---|---|
| A, Loss to the Undamaged Portion | Covers the loss in value of undamaged parts of the same building from required demolition. A shares the building limit with the covered damaged portion. The form's loss payment terms distinguish replacement cost with repair or replacement from actual cash value when the building is not repaired or replaced. |
| B, Demolition Cost | Covers actual expenses of tearing down and clearing the undamaged portion as required by law, subject to the scheduled B amount or shared B/C limit. Separate from the basic damaged-property debris calculation, which has its own grant for eligible debris and limit triggers. |
| C, Increased Cost of Construction | Pays qualifying minimum code increases for repairing or reconstructing damaged parts and reconstructing the specified undamaged parts when demolition is required. Check similar occupancy unless precluded by zoning, the actual completion condition and the B/C schedule. |
Under Coverage C, the property must actually be repaired or replaced as soon as reasonably possible, generally within two years after loss. The insurer may extend the period in writing during those two years. If the insured elects a new site, use the qualifying increased cost cap at the original premises, subject to the schedule. When the law requires relocation, the applicable cost uses the new premises, subject to the schedule. Allocate each expense once. Check the issued form and any amendments before combining coverage from multiple provisions.
Worked Building Claim
A $1,000,000 building is insured for replacement cost under CP 00 10 10 12. A covered fire causes $600,000 of eligible direct damage. An applicable ordinance in force requires demolition of the undamaged portion, with a covered value loss of $300,000 and $85,000 in actual demolition/clearing costs. The owner spends $190,000 in eligible mandatory code upgrades to the damaged portion and completes work within 14 months. Eligible, timely reported debris removal for the damaged portion is $50,000. For this example, there is no applicable deductible, coinsurance penalty or other adjustment. With the endorsement, A is selected, B has a $100,000 limit and C has a $250,000 limit.
| Component | Base forms | With the scheduled endorsement |
|---|---|---|
| Direct damage | $600,000 | $600,000 |
| Qualifying damaged debris | $50,000 | $50,000 |
| Loss of undamaged portion | $0 | $300,000 under A |
| Demolition and clearing of undamaged portion | $0 | $85,000 under B |
| Mandatory upgrades to damaged portion | $10,000 under base provision | $190,000 under C for the same eligible work |
| Total | $660,000 | $1,225,000 |
The debris allowance is within the 25% calculation and the remaining building limit in both cases. The building items and ordinary damaged debris total $950,000 with A. B and C pay the separate scheduled expenses subject to their limits.
Additional Restoration Time
Under base Business Income CP 00 30 10 12, the period of restoration excludes increased time attributable to enforcement or compliance with the described ordinances, including construction, repair or demolition requirements. A physical-damage CP 04 05 endorsement addresses different coverage. CP 15 31 10 12 can include qualifying additional time necessary to repair or rebuild to the minimum standards of the ordinance in force at loss. Verify the covered cause, actual necessary suspension, code requirement and duration, and check the endorsement's contamination exclusions. The endorsement retains the 72-hour Business Income start and immediate Extra Expense start stated in its wording.
A building has CP 00 10 10 12 with a specific $600,000 building limit and replacement-cost coverage. A covered fire damages one wing. Under a code in force at loss, the insured incurs $42,000 in minimum upgrades to that damaged wing while completing qualifying repairs within a year. Assume the code costs meet the built-in provision and CP 04 05 is absent. How much is available for the upgrades?
$30,000, because CP 00 10 automatically pays 5% of the Building Limit.
$10,000, because CP 00 10 caps its built-in Increased Cost of Construction Additional Coverage at the lesser of $10,000 or 5% of the Building Limit.
$42,000, because Replacement Cost policies must always bring damaged buildings up to current municipal codes.
$0, because unendorsed CP 00 10 contains no built-in coverage whatsoever for increased construction costs.
A restaurant has Coverage C of $150,000 under CP 04 05 10 12. Covered storm damage triggers a law in force at loss that requires demolition and a new sprinkler system if rebuilt. The insured sells the cleared site without repairing or replacing the building. How much is payable for increased construction cost under Coverage C?
$150,000, because Coverage C is an Agreed Value payment once the building permit is denied.
The estimated cost of the sprinkler system on an Actual Cash Value basis.
$0, because the building was never repaired or replaced.
50% of the estimated sprinkler upgrade cost as a compromise settlement.
A commercial landlord has CP 00 30 10 12 with Rental Value coverage and CP 04 05 10 12 for the scheduled building. After a covered fire, a building ordinance in force at loss requires demolition of undamaged walls and adds four months to the necessary reconstruction period. What separate function can CP 15 31 10 12 provide if attached and its conditions are met?
It can include qualifying increased time required by the ordinance in the period of restoration.
CP 15 31 eliminates the 72-hour waiting period for Business Income whenever a building inspector condemns a structure.
CP 15 31 converts Coverage A from inside the Building Limit into an additional limit on top of the policy.
Without CP 15 31, CP 04 05 Coverage B cannot pay for clearing debris of undamaged structural walls.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.