10.2 The Policy Appraisal Process, Salvage Rights, and Subrogation Recovery
Key Takeaways
Appraisal determines value or amount under the policy. In Georgia, a dispute about which damage was caused by wind can require a separate coverage determination.
Georgia’s prescribed Standard Fire Policy sets 20 days for notice of appraiser selection, 15 days for umpire agreement and an itemized written award by any two filed with the insurer.
Check the issued form for appraisal procedures, appointment deadlines and how the parties share costs.
Document the agreed value of owner-retained salvage and apply Georgia’s salvage definition and titling procedures.
Check the policy and benefit type to allocate third-party recoveries. Section 33-24-56.1 addresses medical and disability reimbursement, and Woodcraft addresses contractual commercial property subrogation.
10.2 The Policy Appraisal Process, Salvage Rights, and Subrogation Recovery
An adjuster may have to price disputed covered damage, handle damaged property after payment and pursue funds from a responsible third party. The issued contract and Georgia law govern each of these tasks.
Appraisal of Covered Loss
An appraisal clause supplies a process for determining value or the amount of loss under the policy. In McGowan v. Progressive, the Georgia Supreme Court distinguished an appraisal of a totaled vehicle’s actual cash value from broader disputes about legal liability. In Lam v. Allstate, the Georgia Court of Appeals treated the parties’ disagreement over how much of a roof the wind had damaged as a coverage issue beyond appraisal, even though the insurer conceded covered damage to some shingles.
Worked decision. Both parties agree that wind damaged the same 140 square feet of roofing and agree which components need replacement. They use the same covered scope, but disagree on labor rates and material prices. The resulting dollar dispute fits an applicable appraisal clause. If the parties instead disagree about whether deterioration or wind caused damage to an additional section, address the disputed coverage separately. The policy limit, deductible and coverage terms still govern any payment based on the award.
Five Steps in Georgia’s Prescribed Standard Fire Policy
| Step | Rule 120-2-19-.01, lines 123–140 |
|---|---|
| Demand | Either party may demand appraisal in writing if they cannot agree on the actual value or amount of loss. |
| Appraisers | Each party selects a competent, disinterested appraiser and notifies the other within 20 days of the demand. Check independence and disclose potential conflicts. |
| Umpire | The appraisers select a competent, disinterested umpire. If they cannot agree for 15 days, either party may ask a judge of a court of record in the state where the property is located to select the umpire. |
| Valuation | Appraisers state actual cash value and loss separately for each item and send only their differences to the umpire. |
| Award and expenses | An itemized written award by any two, filed with the insurer, determines actual cash value and loss. Each party pays its own appraiser and shares the appraisal and umpire expenses equally. |
Check the issued edition. ISO CP 00 10 10 12 and ISO PP 00 01 01 05 use an any-two award and equally shared common expenses. Those editions use their own selection provisions, which lack the Standard Fire form’s 20-day appraiser and 15-day umpire windows. The commercial property form permits either party to request judicial selection if the appraisers cannot agree. The auto form directs the appraisers to select an umpire. Examine the policy to determine how the award and any applicable legal challenge affect the claim.
A court can resolve policy interpretation and liability. O.C.G.A. § 9-9-2(c)(3) excludes insurance contracts from the Georgia Arbitration Code and preserves arbitration provisions in contracts between insurance companies. Continental v. Equity and McKnight v. Chicago Title explain the Georgia rule and its operation under federal law. If an insurer asks another insurer to arbitrate a recovery dispute, first identify their agreement and the rules it incorporates.
Salvage and Total-Loss Settlement
Salvage is residual property with value after a loss. An actual total loss can result when property is destroyed or beyond restoration. A repairable vehicle may be an economic total loss when repair is uneconomical. Comparing repair cost with the net cost of a total-loss settlement is one way to evaluate the economics. For example, with a pre-loss value of $18,000 and salvage value of $3,200, replacing the loss at pre-loss value and realizing the residual would cost $14,800 before other costs, taxes, fees or deductible. Compare that with a supported estimate of the full covered repair scope. An initial estimate can omit concealed damage, so identify any expected supplements before relying on the comparison. Review the contract and applicable total-loss and title rules separately.
In a Georgia first-party personal private passenger auto claim within Rule 120-2-52, an insurer that determines a total loss under an ACV or replacement policy can elect the applicable cash-equivalent settlement or replacement procedures. The rule describes comparable vehicles and applicable transfer expenses. The ISO PP 00 01 01 05 Payment of Loss provision permits the insurer to keep all or part of damaged property at an agreed or appraised value. Document who retains the property and follow Georgia title procedures.
| Georgia title question | What to check |
|---|---|
| Does the vehicle fall within the salvage definition? | O.C.G.A. § 40-3-2(11) includes a vehicle that needs two or more major component parts to return to operable condition and an unrepaired vehicle for which an insurer paid a total-loss claim. Check the statute’s exceptions, including qualifying recovered theft and solely cosmetic damage from causes other than fire or flood. |
| Who retains the vehicle? | O.C.G.A. § 40-3-36 addresses title handling for insurer-acquired and owner-retained salvage. In an owner-retained claim, the insurer, owner and any lienholder follow the applicable submission procedure. |
| Can the vehicle be driven immediately? | A salvage vehicle cannot be operated on Georgia roads. Rebuilding and return to the road trigger separate inspection and title procedures. |
Owner-retained example. The insurer determines a total loss of a Georgia-titled vehicle with structural damage. The agreed cash value, including any applicable taxes and fees for this example, is $18,000. The collision deductible is $500. The insured elects to keep the vehicle at an agreed $3,200 salvage value. Pay $18,000 − $500 − $3,200 = $14,300 and handle the salvage title in the owner’s name under the applicable procedure.
Subrogation and Reimbursement
In a paid property claim, subrogation can give the insurer the right to recover from the person responsible for the loss to the extent of its payment. Establish legal responsibility, keep evidence of the loss and payment, and review the transfer-of-rights terms and any waiver before pursuing recovery. For example, ISO CP 00 90 07 88 Commercial Property Conditions permit certain written waivers before a loss and allow some post-loss waivers for specified relationships. Resolve any deductible component separately based on the applicable terms, who owns the claim for the deductible and the allocation of the actual recovery.
Georgia uses different recovery rules for different benefits.
| Setting | How to analyze recovery |
|---|---|
| Commercial property insurance | In Woodcraft v. Georgia Casualty, the Georgia Supreme Court allowed the insurer to exercise the express subrogation rights in that policy without proving full compensation of the insured as a prerequisite. Check the contract and facts. |
| Medical expense or disability benefits in a personal injury recovery | Under O.C.G.A. § 33-24-56.1, the benefit provider generally seeks eligible reimbursement from the injured person’s recovery. Subsection (e) bars direct subrogation against the responsible person for those benefits. |
| Uninsured motorist benefits | O.C.G.A. § 33-7-11(f) addresses the paying UM insurer’s rights against the responsible person. Read that provision and the release or settlement before allocating recoveries. |
| Georgia workers’ compensation benefits | O.C.G.A. § 34-9-11.1 governs the statutory lien and full-compensation requirement and limits the benefits that can be recovered. |
For § 33-24-56.1 reimbursement, identify the amount allocated to the relevant medical or disability damages in the settlement or judgment. Check whether the third-party recovery exceeds the other economic and noneconomic losses and reduce a permitted claim by the applicable pro rata attorney fees and litigation expenses. If the court determines that the settlement does not fully and completely compensate the injured party, no reimbursement is due. Check the notice and itemization rules in subsections (g)–(i). The reimbursement and direct subrogation restrictions depend on the law governing the benefit plan.
Worked reimbursement. A Georgia-regulated plan paid $40,000 toward an injury. The injured person has $60,000 in other economic and noneconomic losses. A third-party recovery of $50,000 falls $10,000 short of those other losses alone. If the court determines the settlement does not fully compensate the injured person, the plan receives no reimbursement under § 33-24-56.1.
A Georgia homeowner and insurer agree that the same roof area sustained covered wind damage and agree on the necessary repairs and their quantities. The insurer values the work at $14,000 and the homeowner at $18,000 because they use different labor rates and material prices. Which issue can appraisal decide under the policy’s appraisal clause?
Whether the wind damaged a different section of the roof that the insurer considers deteriorated.
Whether a separate exclusion bars the homeowner from enforcing the policy.
The dollar amount of the repairs within the agreed covered scope.
Whether the insurer breached its duty to handle the claim in good faith.
Under Georgia’s prescribed Standard Fire Policy, the two appraisers submit their itemized differences to the umpire. The umpire and the insured’s appraiser agree and sign an itemized written award that is then filed with the insurer. What does the filing establish under the form?
It fixes actual cash value and the amount of loss because two participants agreed and the award was filed.
It starts a 20-day period in which the other appraiser must also sign.
It leaves the umpire free to issue a new award without either appraiser’s concurrence.
It authorizes the insurer to use the award only after certification by the Insurance Commissioner.
A Georgia-regulated medical benefit provider paid $25,000 for an injury. The injured person incurred $45,000 in other economic and noneconomic losses. A third-party settlement pays $35,000, and a Georgia court determines that it does not fully compensate the injured person. What may the provider recover under O.C.G.A. § 33-24-56.1?
$25,000 from the at-fault person under direct subrogation.
$25,000 from the injured person because the settlement covers more than the plan paid.
$10,000 by treating the shortfall in other losses as the benefit provider’s share.
$0 in reimbursement on the court’s finding, and no direct subrogation for those medical benefits.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.