1.3 Methods of Handling Risk and the Law of Large Numbers
Key Takeaways
Sharing pools costs, transfer shifts defined costs, avoidance stops an exposure, retention keeps costs and reduction limits frequency or severity.
A single arrangement can combine methods. Check whether a contractual transfer is enforceable and what it actually shifts.
Under the stated independence and common-probability assumptions, the sample frequency becomes more stable as the number of exposures increases.
Large expected counts do not guarantee specific outcomes, particularly where a common event creates correlated losses.
Separate a case estimate, total unpaid loss reserves and claim expenses, and identify whether the reported ratio includes those expenses.
1.3 Methods of Handling Risk and the Law of Large Numbers
Risk management can change how likely a loss is, how severe it is or who bears its cost. Identify the exposure precisely. Several methods can operate on the same exposure, such as using sprinklers to limit fire damage, retaining a deductible and buying insurance for covered losses above it.
| Method | How it works | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Sharing | Spread qualifying costs across participants in a pool | A reciprocal exchange pools selected exposures under its subscriber arrangements. |
| Transfer | Put defined costs on another party through insurance or an enforceable agreement | An insurer assumes a covered loss within the policy terms. A subcontract may transfer specified costs by a valid indemnity clause. Georgia § 13-8-2(b) limits certain construction agreements purporting to transfer liability for the indemnitee's sole negligence and contains its own exceptions. |
| Avoidance | Stop or decline the particular exposure-producing activity | Decide against building a pool and avoid the planned pool's operation exposure. |
| Retention | Bear part or all of the cost internally, by choice or because it is uninsured | A business selects a deductible or an applicable self-insured retention. Read the exact attachment, defense and payment terms. |
| Reduction | Lower likelihood, severity or both | A fleet uses safety training to reduce crashes; automatic sprinklers can limit fire spread and damage. |
The initials STARR can help recall the categories. Classify a decision by its operation. When a business bears the first $5,000 of a covered property loss under a deductible, that amount is retained. The remaining eligible covered amount can be transferred subject to contract terms. A captive can finance a group's risks without automatically eliminating the group's underlying economic retention. Sharing is compatible with transfer when a pool spreads costs assumed under an insurance contract.
The Law of Large Numbers applies to an average
Let each independent, similarly distributed exposure have a Bernoulli indicator of whether it incurred a fire loss with probability . For identical independent risks, the expected count is . The average indicator is the observed share with fire losses, with variance . As increases, that share concentrates around under these assumptions. A sample mean of independent identically distributed dollar losses with finite variance likewise concentrates around its expected dollar cost per unit. Keep the count, probability and average cost in their own units.
At an assumed 0.2% probability and 500,000 exposures, the expected count is 1,000. Comparing the frequency and unit count does not tell us which locations will sustain losses or how severe an individual loss will be. A storm can damage many properties at once. Shared causes make the independence calculation inappropriate without adjustment. Evaluate catastrophe aggregation, changes in risk mix and the evidence underlying frequency and severity before using the pooled data for prospective costs. If 1,100 fires actually occur in that pool, the observed rate is 0.22%. The observed rate is 0.02 percentage points higher than the assumed 0.2% rate. One period of experience can reflect random variation. Before updating the assumption, compare the exposure mix, any shared event and other credible experience.
Reserves and claim-cost measures
A case estimate represents expected unpaid amounts on a reported claim under the insurer's reserving practice. Update it with coverage, repair, liability and expense developments. Insurers also estimate costs not reflected in individual case estimates, such as incurred-but-not-reported amounts and appropriate claim adjustment expenses. Distinguish the company's total unpaid claims estimate from a single case, and specify what expense the reserve includes before combining figures.
Consider $25 million of earned premium, $13.5 million in calendar-period paid losses, beginning unpaid loss reserves of $4 million and ending unpaid loss reserves of $5.5 million. Assume those balances are complete loss reserves on a consistent basis, with no other adjustments. Incurred losses equal $13.5 million plus the $1.5 million net reserve increase, or $15 million. The loss-only ratio is $15 million divided by $25 million, or 60%. Add $2 million of incurred loss adjustment expense (LAE) to measure losses and LAE against earned premium. The result is $17 million divided by $25 million, or 68%. The two measures answer different questions. Use comparable earned premium, losses and expense periods and a consistent gross or net basis. In reviewing reserves, document what changed and why. A reserve estimate does not itself establish what the policy will pay.
A Georgia developer and contractor execute a valid agreement shifting specified costs of the contractor's own negligence to the contractor. What is the developer using for those costs?
Retention
Avoidance
Reduction
Contractual transfer
Assume independent exposures each with the same fire-loss probability. What happens as the number of such exposures grows?
A large pool prevents fires.
The observed proportion with fire losses concentrates around the common probability.
The expected count stays constant as exposures increase.
Unpaid reserves become unnecessary.
An insurer reports $10 million earned premium, $5.2 million paid losses and an $800,000 increase in complete unpaid loss reserves on the same basis. Incurred loss adjustment expense is $1 million. What are the loss-only and loss-plus-expense ratios, respectively?
52% and 60%.
60% and 60%.
60% and 70%.
70% and 80%.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.