17-2 Commercial Inland Marine: Builders' Risk, Contractors' Equipment, Motor Truck Cargo, and Bailees
Key Takeaways
Verify the actual schedule, territory and acquisitions provisions for contractors’ equipment.
Carmack starts with the shipper’s prima facie case. A carrier asserting one of the recognized causes must also establish freedom from negligence.
BMC-32 addresses applicable household goods cargo liability. Direct customer-goods coverage and bailee liability use different triggers.
Check the actual start and end of installation and builders’ risk coverage. For goods sold, separate transit risk allocation from title and insurance.
Commercial Inland Marine: Builders' Risk, Contractors' Equipment, Motor Truck Cargo, and Bailees
Identify the property or financial interest, who held the goods at loss, and which contract addresses the loss. Personal property of others may have its own declared limit under CP 00 10 10 12. Its separate off-premises extension generally excludes property in or on a vehicle. Check both the principal grant and any extension before moving to a floater.
Contractors' Equipment
A Contractors' Equipment floater can insure excavators, lifts, generators and other machinery used across job sites. Check which owned or borrowed items the form covers, whether coverage is scheduled or blanket, permitted location and transit, exclusions, limits and valuation. For a stolen skid steer, compare the product identification number to the schedule, document the place and time of theft, confirm the applicable site conditions and give police the identifying details.
Under the Selective CM 70 97 03 12 specimen, the temporary newly acquired extension can cover qualifying property up to 90 days, ending earlier if the policy ends. The limit is the lesser of 25% of the declared total limit or $250,000. For a $600,000 declared limit, the extension ceiling is $150,000. Check acquisition, reporting and premium conditions and any scheduled limit. This is one policy's calculation. Other forms can change it. Evaluate any coinsurance requirement or temporary equipment-rental grant separately from the equipment loss.
Property in transit and motor carrier liability
| Coverage | Basis of claim |
|---|---|
| Transit property or owner's cargo | A qualifying physical loss under the insured's property grant, regardless of whether the carrier was negligent. Check insured goods, transit start and end, means of transport, route, limits and exclusions. |
| Motor carrier cargo legal liability | The carrier's covered legal liability for damage to goods of others in its care under applicable law and contract. Check both the bill of lading and insurer's liability grant. |
An annual transit contract can insure qualifying shipments during its term, subject to declared classes, means of carriage and reporting. Trip transit addresses a particular shipment and itinerary. One insured might arrange trip coverage when moving a single medical imaging machine from Columbus to Savannah. Record handling at intermediate terminals and obtain the signed delivery receipt.
Carmack Amendment
49 U.S.C. § 14706 governs covered interstate motor carrier and freight-forwarder carriage. A shipper ordinarily makes a prima facie case with evidence of delivery to the carrier in good condition, arrival damaged or non-delivery, and the amount of the actual loss. The receiving carrier's failure to issue a bill of lading does not eliminate liability under the statute. Once that case is established, Missouri Pacific Railroad v. Elmore & Stahl places the burden on the carrier to show freedom from negligence and a cause within the recognized defenses:
- Act of God
- Public enemy
- Act of the shipper
- Public authority
- Inherent vice or nature of the goods
For example, the carrier asserting the shipper packed the goods improperly must prove the defense and its own due care. Under § 14706(c)(1), a permitted non-household-goods limitation depends on a reasonable value under the circumstances established by the shipper's written or electronic declaration or written agreement. Household goods have separate protections and released-rate requirements under § 14706(f). Keep the evidence of any qualifying agreement.
BMC-32 household goods cargo endorsement
Current federal cargo financial security for covered interstate household goods motor carriers is $5,000 for loss carried on any one vehicle and $10,000 for aggregate losses at any one time and place. The BMC-32 endorsement is part of the insurance route for a covered household goods motor carrier under 49 CFR §§ 387.303(c) and 387.313. The FMCSA separately identifies certificates and surety options. Do not assign the household goods cargo-security requirements to every general freight hauler.
BMC-32 protects the shipper or consignee where the carrier is legally liable for the stated transportation loss. As to an eligible claimant and within the required limits, underlying policy terms and violations cannot defeat the endorsement's payment obligation. The insurer can seek reimbursement from its insured for payments due solely because of the endorsement. Apply any remaining contractual insurance and valid valuation provisions separately.
Customers' goods in a bailee's care
Georgia defines a bailment as delivery of goods for a purpose under a contract to return or handle them as the contract directs. Under O.C.G.A. § 44-12-43, the degree of care depends on the nature of the bailment. The usual exchange for paid dry cleaning is for mutual benefit, calling for ordinary care. Checkout records, garment tags and receipts establish custody, identity and condition.
A direct bailees customers form can pay for eligible physical loss to customers' goods without establishing bailee negligence. For example, ISO IH 00 85 09 09 grants direct coverage on qualifying property in the insured's care, custody or control, subject to the declared coverage and exclusions. A legal liability form requires the bailee to be legally liable for the loss. A standard occurrence CGL specimen CG 00 01 04 13 has a property-damage exclusion for personal property in the insured's care, custody or control. Read the actual CGL wording, any exception, and the specific bailee coverage.
Installation and builders' risk
Building coverage under the CP 00 20 10 12 specimen identifies the building under construction, foundations, eligible fixtures and materials intended for the project and eligible temporary structures if no other insurance covers them. Its base location language and additional coverages determine whether off-site property qualifies. Its termination condition uses the first specified event, such as expiration, purchaser acceptance, end of the insured's interest or specified time after completion, occupancy or intended use. An endorsement can change dates or locations.
An installation floater can cover the contractor's material that is to become a permanent part of a specified project. The Merchants IH 00 73 product schedule illustrates separate amounts for the jobsite, temporary storage and transit. In an Augusta switchgear loss, determine if the unit was at a designated temporary storage location, in transit, installed or accepted at the time of loss. If multiple policies actually cover it, compare their valuation and other-insurance clauses before allocating the loss. Avoid assuming all builders' risk policies exclude transit.
F.O.B. and the interest in a shipment
Under Georgia's UCC, O.C.G.A. §§ 11-2-319 and 11-2-509 govern shipment and destination terms by default when Georgia law controls and no contrary agreement or breach changes the result. Title is a separate issue under § 11-2-401. Identify the parties' economic interests, actual contract, shipping terms and insurance at the time of loss.
- F.O.B. shipping point. Risk generally passes to the buyer when the goods are duly delivered to the carrier.
- F.O.B. destination. When the contract requires delivery to the named destination and the goods are duly tendered there while in carrier possession, risk then passes to the buyer.
- Worked application. A Georgia seller ships $90,000 in valves F.O.B. destination under a Georgia-law contract. A mid-route truck fire occurs before tender. The seller still bears the risk under the contract. Assess the seller's transit coverage and any carrier recovery separately.
Financial and document losses
CM 00 66 06 95 addresses covered damage to receivables records that interferes with collection. It can pay eligible uncollectible balances, loan interest, extra collection costs and reasonable record restoration costs. Check the form's distinct exclusions and the actual limitations on the causes involved. CM 00 67 01 13 applies to qualifying valuable papers and records. Unscheduled items generally use the least of actual cash value, reasonable restoration cost and substantially identical replacement under CM 00 01 09 04. Apply the scheduled valuation to specifically declared and described items. Section 20-4 works through the collection and valuation calculations.
A shipper makes its prima facie Carmack case for damage during interstate motor carriage. The carrier claims shipper packing alone caused the damage. What is the carrier's burden?
Show only that the driver denies fault
Prove freedom from negligence and that the damage was caused by the shipper’s act
Prove the goods moved under a bill of lading, regardless of cause
Apply a deductible from the shipper's own property policy
A Georgia-law contract ships $90,000 of industrial valves F.O.B. destination. There is no contrary agreement or breach. A carrier’s truck catches fire during transit before the agreed destination tender. Who bears the risk of loss under the sales terms?
The buyer because the goods left origin
The driver personally under the sales contract
Both seller and buyer under a 50/50 negligence split
The seller because due tender at the specified destination has not occurred
A dry cleaner's direct bailees customers form covers physical fire loss to garments at the shop, including the garments held there on customer tickets. A covered fire destroys the garments. Assume there is no relevant limitation other than the applicable limit and deductible. How does the direct property grant apply?
It can pay for eligible covered damage without proof the cleaner was negligent
It requires a court to find the cleaner negligent
It pays under the CGL medical payments limit
It applies only to the cleaner’s equipment
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.