17-4 Ocean Marine: Protection and Indemnity (P&I), General Average, and Particular Average
Key Takeaways
P&I can address marine liability, including liabilities left outside a hull collision clause, under the vessel’s actual policy or club entry.
Jones Act seaman status depends on vessel work and a substantial vessel connection. Federal Longshore coverage uses its own work and site tests.
Under incorporated York-Antwerp Rules, a qualifying common-safety measure can lead to contribution based on adjusted values.
Particular Average damage is assessed under the applicable cargo or hull terms and any rights against responsible parties.
Apply the issued constructive total loss test and separate Sue and Labor calculation, including eligible costs and applicable limits.
Ocean Marine: Protection and Indemnity (P&I), General Average, and Particular Average
A single grounding can lead to an insured hull loss, liability for a damaged dock, and a contribution claim for a deliberate cargo sacrifice. Establish which party claims, what interest suffered the loss and which policy or voyage terms apply.
Protection and Indemnity
A shipowner or vessel operator can insure specified legal liabilities through P&I under a club entry or commercial marine contract. Review the insured vessel, member or assured, interests, limits, deductibles and exclusions. The American Club's Class I, Rule 2 illustrates separate coverages:
- Vessel collision. The club's section 3 provides one-fourth or a different agreed portion for specified liabilities insofar as hull does not cover them. It treats specified categories, including personal injury, separately and limits qualifying excess claims under its own terms.
- Docks and fixed or floating objects. Check section 5 for qualifying liability for damage to property such as a pier, bridge or buoy.
- Wreck and pollution. Check coverage for legally imposed wreck marking or removal and defined pollution liabilities and expenses. For example, 33 U.S.C. § 409 imposes marking and removal duties when specified craft sink in a navigable channel. Separately check applicable oil-discharge liability under 33 U.S.C. § 2702.
- Cargo and people. Check the club's cargo provisions for the owner's liability as carrier, and its separate crew and other-person provisions. For a cargo claim subject to the Carriage of Goods by Sea Act, examine the bill of lading, any eligible defense or limit, and the carrier's statutory duties including due diligence to make the vessel seaworthy.
Maritime workers
| Issue | Jones Act | Longshore and Harbor Workers' Compensation Act |
|---|---|---|
| Worker | Under Chandris v. Latsis, the duties contribute to the mission or function of a vessel. The connection to a vessel in navigation or an identifiable fleet must be substantial in duration and nature. | Employee must have covered maritime employment and injury at a qualifying site, subject to statutory exceptions. A master or member of a vessel's crew is excluded. |
| Remedy | Under 46 U.S.C. § 30104, a qualifying injured seaman can sue the employer for negligence. Separately evaluate maintenance and cure or unseaworthiness under general maritime law. | The federal compensation program pays eligible benefits without requiring employer negligence. Section 905(b) can permit a separate vessel-negligence claim. Check its limitations. |
| Coverage file | Read the vessel's P&I or applicable maritime employers liability terms. | Examine the employer's federal compensation security, such as Workers' Compensation with a USL&H endorsement, and any vessel's separate liability policy. |
At Savannah, a terminal operator's employee who loads vessels on a qualifying adjoining pier may meet the federal compensation tests. A regular engineering deckhand whose duties are a substantial part of the tug's operations can be a Jones Act seaman even when an injury occurs on a moored tug. Determine the work, vessel relationship and applicable law, then test the claim against the insurance.
General Average and Particular Average
Determine the rule edition incorporated by the voyage contract. Under the York-Antwerp Rules 2016, General Average generally starts with a reasonable, extraordinary sacrifice or expense intentionally incurred for the common safety of property exposed to common peril. Apply the numbered rules and Rule Paramount. Rule I addresses jettison of cargo carried according to recognized trade custom. Apply the valuation rules and establish the interests that contribute. A share can include an amount made good for sacrificed property under Rule XVII. A guarantee or deposit supplies security and does not fix the merits or the amount due.
Worked allocation
A ship carrying cargo stowed according to recognized trade custom grounds outside Brunswick. The master reasonably jettisons machinery to save ship and cargo, and the adventure reaches safety. Assume the voyage incorporates the 2016 Rules and the General Average adjuster determines a $500,000 allowable sacrifice, with no other adjustments. Values are stipulated after applying Rule XVII, including the amount made good for the sacrifice.
| Interest | Adjusted contributory value | Assessment at 5% |
|---|---|---|
| Ship | $6,000,000 | $300,000 |
| All cargo including the made-good amount | $3,500,000 | $175,000 |
| Freight at risk | $500,000 | $25,000 |
| Total | $10,000,000 | $500,000 |
The rate is $500,000 divided by $10 million. A cargo owner with $500,000 of contributory value is assessed $25,000. If it is the sacrificed owner and its allowable credit is $500,000, the example's net allocation is $475,000. Each affected party then checks its own insurance for any contribution or sacrifice recovery.
Accidental partial damage to an individual insured interest, such as stormwater damage to one shipper's textile cargo, is a Particular Average loss if it falls within that loss category. There is no shared General Average contribution for that individual loss. Check its cargo terms and any rights against the carrier separately.
Cargo clauses for partial damage
American Institute cargo clauses illustrate how a Free of Particular Average (FPA) restriction changes eligibility. Compare the American Conditions clause, which links partial damage to specified major events, with the English Conditions clause, which uses the occurrence of stated events and the other clause conditions. A With Average clause can cover qualifying partial damage subject to a stated percentage threshold and the exceptions in that form. If the percentage is a franchise, a covered loss meeting it can be payable in full subject to other adjustments. A deductible instead reduces the payment. Institute Cargo Clauses (A) 1/1/09 provide broad physical loss coverage subject to their exclusions and separate terms for General Average and salvage. Check the actual coverage, including the clause and the cause, when valuing any allowance or total loss.
Hull total loss and Sue and Labor
An actual total loss can result when a vessel is destroyed or irretrievably lost. For a constructive total loss, first apply the issued standard. Under the September 29, 2009 American Institute Hull Clauses, the eligible cost of recovery and repair from the same accident or sequence must exceed the agreed value. The clause excludes damaged or breakup value from that calculation and has separate treatment for qualifying costs before tender of abandonment. A $1 million agreed value and $1.1 million of qualifying costs from one accident satisfy the cost threshold. Check governing notice and abandonment requirements. Efforts by either side to preserve or recover the vessel are not themselves acceptance of abandonment under the clause.
Sue and Labor can cover defined reasonable expenses for protecting or recovering the insured vessel even when attempts fail. Under the 2009 named clauses, calculation differs with or without an admitted total loss. For an admitted total loss, determine the excess of qualifying expense over any proceeds or value recovered, then apply the proportion of amount insured to the greater of agreed or pre-accident sound value and the stated cap. For a partial loss, compare the policy's separate proportions, including its salved-property calculation. Check which costs concern the vessel and its own loss. Common-safety costs and vessel charges can require separate analysis under the General Average and Sue and Labor clauses.
A bill of lading incorporates the York-Antwerp Rules 2016. The master reasonably jettisons steel carried according to recognized trade custom to save a vessel and cargo in common peril. The adjuster allows $400,000 and determines adjusted contributory values of $5 million ship, $2.6 million cargo (including the amount made good), and $400,000 freight at risk. How is the allowance allocated?
Particular Average borne exclusively by the steel owner
Three-fourths of the allowance is paid by the hull collision cover
It is payable under federal Longshore compensation
General Average at 5%: ship $250,000, cargo $130,000 and freight $20,000
A terminal’s longshore crane operator is injured while loading ships on an adjoining Savannah pier. On a different job a regular engineering deckhand whose work operates a tug in navigation slips on an oily ladder aboard it. Neither meets a statutory exclusion other than the crew exclusion for federal Longshore compensation. Which federal legal paths should the adjuster check?
Only state workers’ compensation for both
Longshore compensation for the terminal worker and Jones Act negligence for the deckhand if employer negligence caused the injury
Jones Act for the crane operator and Longshore compensation for the regular deckhand
Hull machinery insurance for both workers
A vessel insured under the September 29, 2009 American Institute Hull Clauses is an admitted total loss. The sum insured, agreed value and pre-accident sound value are each $500,000. Before the loss became final, the owner incurred $75,000 of qualifying reasonable Sue and Labor expenses to preserve the vessel. No proceeds or value were recovered, and no other adjustment applies. What is the total payable?
$425,000
$500,000
$575,000
$0 because the mitigation attempt failed
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.