22-2 Employee Theft, Forgery or Alteration, Computer Fraud, & Funds Transfer Fraud
Key Takeaways
Use independent evidence of employee theft before relying on an inventory computation to support the claimed amount.
Apply the ERISA amount to the individual handler and plan, with the applicable ceiling and first-dollar requirement.
Identify the instrument and issuer before using the forgery grant.
In the 06 22 edition, distinguish the two A.6 branches from A.7 and verify the latter’s required authentication efforts.
Employee Theft, Forgery, and Transfer Fraud
Identify the edition and verify the selected grants and limits. The examples use ISO CR 00 23 06 22 unless specified. Its A.1 has three fidelity grants, A.2 separates negotiable instruments from payment cards, A.6 combines two kinds of transfer fraud, A.7 covers fraudulent impersonation on specified facts, and A.8 addresses money orders and counterfeit money.
Fidelity and inventory proof
A.1.a Employee Theft covers direct loss of or damage to money, securities or other property from employee theft, including forgery for this agreement. The employee need not be identified and can act alone or in collusion. Match employee status to the form. For example, the ordinary employee must be in service, directly compensated and subject to the insured's control. The definition also addresses eligible temporary workers, other defined categories, and limited time after termination. Earlier forms that use a dishonest-act or intent test need their own analysis. This grant requires the defined theft, not a general failure to perform a duty.
A.1.b covers the specified fraud or dishonesty against property belonging to an ERISA plan by a plan official or the insured sole proprietor under the stated terms. A.1.c addresses a client's loss due to theft by an identified employee. Neither a client's entire loss nor every mistake by a plan official is automatically a payable theft.
Under D.2.a, an inventory or profit-and-loss computation alone cannot prove employee theft. If a retailer finds $45,000 missing on a count, the inventory discrepancy does not establish a covered loss. If records and witnesses independently establish covered employee theft, inventory records and a physical count may support the amount. Examine departures from expected stock without presuming who caused them. Check whether a separate government faithful-performance endorsement pays for a different breach of duty.
ERISA § 412, 29 U.S.C. § 1112, generally requires bonding for each nonexempt person handling plan funds or property. The required amount generally starts at 10% of what that person handled in the preceding year, with a $1,000 floor and a $500,000 usual federal ceiling per plan for that person. The ceiling is $1 million for a plan holding employer securities or a pooled employer plan. The mandatory layer protects the plan from the first dollar. A bond can cover several people, but test each person's required amount. The 06 22 crime form has its own ERISA condition for qualifying amounts, payment between plans and no deductible for covered A.1.b loss. Obtain the actual bond and endorsements before determining compliance.
A blanket employee theft limit per occurrence can apply once to a collusive theft. A named-person, position or per-employee form can operate differently. For three employees involved in one covered $60,000 loss, the blanket $25,000 occurrence limit caps payment at $25,000 if the net loss exceeds that limit. A scheduled form needs its own persons, scope and limit wording.
Forgery and counterfeit receipts
A.2.a covers eligible negotiable instruments drawn by or on the insured or made by its agent, including instruments purporting to meet those requirements. A forged signature on a check purporting to be drawn by the insured can qualify. An incoming customer check drawn on the customer's own account generally does not meet the grant. The defined forgery focuses on signing another name with intent to deceive. A.2.b separately addresses written instruments relating to qualifying business payment cards, subject to the policy and card issuer's requirements. Under A.2.a, written insurer consent to defend a suit for refusing payment on a covered forged or altered instrument can make qualifying defense expenses payable in addition to the limit. Check the specified proof and no-deductible condition for legal expenses.
A.8 addresses good-faith acceptance in exchange for merchandise, money or services of qualifying money orders not paid on presentation, or counterfeit money acquired in the regular course of business. It uses the defined term counterfeit money. An ordinary unpaid check or bookkeeping shortage meets a different fact pattern.
Follow the fraudulent instruction
| Cause in the 06 22 form | Potential grant and evidence |
|---|---|
| Intruder changes data in a defined computer system and causes an unauthorized transfer to an account outside the insured's control | A.6.a. Verify the actual data entry or change, causal chain and authorization, including the authorized-access exclusion. |
| A financial institution debits the insured's transfer account on a fraudulent instruction ostensibly issued by the insured | A.6.b. Identify the imposter, bank's reliance and lack of the insured's knowledge or consent. |
| Insured employee acts in good faith on an imposter's purported instruction from an authorized person, client or vendor | A.7. Determine which impersonation branch applies and confirm the defined parties, payment destination and applicable verification. Document reasonable non-email verification efforts contemporaneously before transferring property as required by E.2.e. |
An authorized employee deceived into sending a wire presents different facts from an imposter instructing the bank or a hacker changing the insured's data. Do not carry the 11 15 numbering into the 06 22 policy. In CR 00 23 11 15, A.6 and A.7 were separate Computer Fraud and Funds Transfer Fraud grants; compare their exact wording and applicable decisions rather than assuming the later Fraudulent Impersonation grant is present. For a coverage decision, save the original instructions and their authentication records and identify who actually sent the payment order.
A distributor’s inventory calculation shows $64,000 missing. There is no independent evidence of employee theft. Which conclusion follows under CR 00 23 06 22 A.1.a and D.2.a?
Pay the shortage as a presumption of employee theft.
Pay half because other causes remain possible.
The inventory computation alone does not establish a payable employee theft loss.
Use A.3 for disappearance of the laptops.
A clinic buys A.6 and A.7 in CR 00 23 06 22. Its employee wires money outside the clinic’s control in good faith after an imposter claims to be an authorized manager without that manager’s knowledge or consent. The employee makes a reasonable effort to authenticate the instruction by calling a different authorized employee and records the result before the transfer. The bank receives the instruction from the clinic employee. Which grant most directly fits, subject to all remaining terms?
A.7 Fraudulent Impersonation
A.6.b because the money moved out of a transfer account
A.6.a because any email is fraudulent computer entry
A.2.a because any impersonation is negotiable-instrument forgery
A nonexempt official handled $8 million in the preceding year for one ERISA plan that holds employer securities. Assuming the usual statutory formula, what minimum amount is required for this official?
$250,000
$500,000
$800,000
$1,000,000
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.