9.3 Loss Valuation Methods: ACV, Replacement Cost, Depreciation, and Repair Estimating

Key Takeaways

  • Identify the contract’s valuation provision and substantiate condition, scope and pricing before using a depreciation estimate.

  • The HO 00 03 05 11 building provision uses an 80% test, specific caps and a small-loss exception to the repair prerequisite.

  • Calculate a supplement from the final amount payable after applicable adjustments, less the prior payment.

  • Evaluate contractor coordination and supporting costs from the actual scope of the repair.

  • For Georgia first-party auto claims, apply the policy repair standard and Georgia’s separate estimate and nonoriginal aftermarket parts rules.

Last updated: November 2026

9.3 Loss Valuation Methods: ACV, Replacement Cost, Depreciation, and Repair Estimating

Establish the settlement measure

A repair estimate prices a defined scope. The applicable contract tells the adjuster how to turn that scope and other evidence into a claim payment. Begin by identifying the property, the covered damage and the loss settlement option in the issued form. Replacement cost generally concerns the current cost to replace or repair with the quality and use the contract specifies. Actual cash value (ACV) reflects value at the time of loss under the applicable policy and law. Current replacement cost less supported depreciation can be an appropriate estimate where the contract and facts support it. Confirm the loss measure before using the calculation.

InputEvidence to collect
Covered scope and replacement costMeasurements, photographs, material specifications, bids, quantities and current local labor or unit costs.
DepreciationAge, useful life, upkeep, prior condition, use and deterioration, together with any applicable policy definition.
Market evidenceComparable sales, expert opinions or other reliable evidence that fits the property and the form's valuation basis.
Final paymentApplicable limit and deductible, any replacement-cost conditions, substantiated expenditures, and earlier payments.

Age and useful life. For an illustrative straight-line estimate, a component eight years into a 20-year useful life has an age-based depreciation indication of 40%. If the supported replacement estimate is $20,000 and this indication is appropriate, the indicated depreciation is $8,000 and the estimated ACV is $12,000. Evaluate actual condition before relying on the indication. For example, renovations, heavy use or prior deterioration may make evidence of remaining useful life more informative than installation date alone.

Other evidence of value. Where the valuation measure allows it, consider relevant market and condition evidence with age and original or replacement prices. In Braner v. Southern Trust, the Georgia Supreme Court addressed proof of ACV for common household goods destroyed by fire. Testimony as to original price or replacement cost and approximate acquisition date was enough for a jury to determine those values. Its holding concerns that evidentiary setting. It does not prescribe a depreciation schedule.

Initial ACV and the replacement cost supplement

HO 00 03 05 11 Section I D has separate rules for buildings and other property. For a building insured to at least 80% of its full replacement cost immediately before loss, subject to the policy's calculation terms, the replacement cost amount is based on the least of the applicable insurance limit, the cost of like-kind-and-quality replacement for like use, and the necessary amount actually spent. Below the 80% threshold, compare ACV of the damaged part with the form's proportional repair or replacement measure, subject to the applicable limit and the form's other terms. Calculate the 80% test using the property's qualifying pre-loss replacement value and the form's specified exclusions.

For this HO edition, actual repair or replacement generally precedes settlement above ACV. Its small-loss rule allows payment on a replacement cost basis without that prerequisite when the qualifying cost is both below 5% of applicable building insurance and below $2,500. The insured who initially claims on an ACV basis can seek additional replacement cost under the form by giving notice of intent within 180 days after the loss. That notice requirement and the need to document completed work are distinct. Commercial CP 00 10 10 12 has its own optional replacement cost terms, including its own 180-day notice provision when the insured initially elects ACV.

Worked roof example

A covered storm damages a roof insured under HO 00 03 05 11. Stipulate adequate insurance, a $24,000 reasonable like-kind replacement estimate, supported depreciation of 25% and a $1,500 deductible. The loss is outside the small-loss exception. The insured gives timely notice of intent and satisfies the form's conditions. Assume that all covered repair expenses shown below qualify and no other dollar adjustment applies.

StepCalculationPayment effect
Estimate ACV$24,000 − $6,000 supported depreciation = $18,000ACV before deductible
Calculate initial payable$18,000 − $1,500 = $16,500Initial payment under these facts
Full $24,000 qualifying repair$24,000 − $1,500 = $22,500Total payable; $6,000 supplement after the earlier payment
$21,000 qualifying repair$21,000 − $1,500 = $19,500Total payable; $3,000 supplement after the earlier payment
No completed repairReplacement cost condition remains unsatisfiedIn this large-loss example the insurer has paid $16,500 on ACV

For a supplement, first calculate final contract liability with the applicable limit and deductible. Subtract the amount already paid. This keeps the same deductible from being charged twice and distinguishes the depreciation estimate from the amount due on the actual file.

Other valuation provisions

  • Stated amount: ISO CA 99 28 provides a commercial auto example. The scheduled figure is one ceiling in a comparison with ACV and cost to repair or replace with like kind and quality. If those numbers are $45,000, $39,000 and $50,000, respectively, the relevant ceiling is $39,000 before the applicable deductible.
  • Guaranteed value and commercial agreed value: An example of actual collector-vehicle wording is AC 106 04 21, which pays the scheduled Guaranteed Value for a covered total or constructive total loss of the scheduled auto. Conversely, CP 00 10 10 12's Agreed Value option suspends the Coinsurance Additional Condition while in effect and can impose its own limit-to-agreed-value proportion. Its label alone does not establish a guaranteed payout.
  • Functional building valuation: CP 04 38 10 12 uses the cost of a functionally equivalent replacement in its qualifying repair or replacement branch. A plaster wall may be replaced with suitable modern materials if they perform the equivalent function under the form. Check the scheduled limit, actual work and the form's alternate valuation branch.

Build a defensible repair estimate

Separate covered repairs, deterioration, upgrades and additional damage discovered during disassembly. Record labor quantities, customary material quality, protective measures, disposal, and any needed contractors and permits. An estimating database supplies a pricing reference. When bids or dated local data differ, document the scope or rate difference and reconcile it with the terms and available evidence.

General contractor overhead can include costs of operating the business, and profit is a separate component of the contractor's charge. Evaluate the need for project-level coordination from the facts. A structural repair may need shoring, inspection and carefully sequenced wall, electrical and finish work. A simple independent repair may require no separate general contractor. Document the coordination needed, the estimate basis, costs already included in unit prices and the applicable loss settlement terms. A number of trades or a percentage is insufficient by itself.

Georgia first-party collision estimates

Check PP 00 01 01 05 Part D or the applicable policy's exact text. The cited form compares ACV with the amount needed to repair or replace using like kind and quality, and applies its physical-condition, depreciation and betterment provisions. Georgia Rules 120-2-52-.03 through .05 separately address choice of repair facility, estimates and nonoriginal aftermarket crash parts. For a qualifying higher written estimate for necessary repairs, .04 calls for review and response within 15 days and specifies the repair-shop or payment-difference alternatives. The rule also limits certain prior-condition and missing-parts deductions. Section .05 prohibits requiring nonoriginal aftermarket crash parts and sets conditions governing their use in determining the repair cost.

New OEM, nonoriginal aftermarket, recycled OEM and remanufactured identify different sources or processes. Like kind and quality is the standard used to test a proposed part. Check fit, quality, safety, function and appearance, including any corrosion or prior damage on a recycled part. Model year or mileage can be relevant evidence and alone does not decide the quality question. Document when a part is unavailable and what is required for a safe and conforming repair. A repair estimate also does not determine residual loss of market value. Consider the claim and policy wording under Georgia's Mabry auto decision and Royal Capital's application to building insurance.

Test Your Knowledge

Adequately insured under HO 00 03 05 11 with no conflicting endorsement, a dwelling sustains covered hail damage with a like-kind roof replacement estimate of $30,000. Stipulate supported depreciation of 40%, a $1,000 deductible, timely notice of intent and compliance with the form’s conditions. What are the initial and additional payments when the policyholder completes qualifying replacement for $30,000?

A

Initial ACV payment of $18,000; recoverable depreciation release of $12,000.

B

Initial ACV payment of $30,000; no recoverable depreciation holdback applies.

C

Initial ACV payment of $17,000; recoverable depreciation release of $12,000.

D

Initial ACV payment of $11,000; recoverable depreciation release of $18,000.

Test Your Knowledge

Structural repairs after a covered loss need temporary shoring, a staged inspection and carefully sequenced electrical and wall work. What is the strongest basis for including general contractor overhead and profit in the estimate?

A

The calculation always includes a fixed allowance for every claim

B

An insured’s decision to complete the work personally requires the allowance

C

The number of trades fixes the percentage of both overhead and profit

D

The covered repair reasonably requires project-level coordination, with the proposed costs supported by the scope and pricing evidence

Test Your Knowledge

A Georgia first-party collision estimate proposes a recycled original-manufacturer panel for a five-year-old car. How should the adjuster evaluate it under a like-kind-and-quality repair provision?

A

Reject any recycled part because Georgia law requires only new OEM parts

B

Check the part’s documented condition, fit, safety, function and appearance against the preaccident repair standard

C

Treat any panel from a vehicle of the same age as automatically equivalent

D

Approve it only if the owner assumes all future mechanical liability

Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.