19-2 Garagekeepers Insurance: Legal Liability, Direct Primary, and Direct Excess
Key Takeaways
Confirm the customer auto, garage operation, scheduled location and cause of loss.
Georgia’s bailment and diligence rules inform legal liability. Apply the policy’s defense and damage terms separately.
Direct excess retains legal liability and adds coverage over other collectible insurance. Direct primary applies regardless of legal liability.
Match the deductible to the coverage and peril. Comprehensive hail and Comprehensive vandalism have different deductible treatment in CA 99 37 10 01.
Determine the maximum by loss and scheduled location, accounting for the endorsement’s deductible terms.
Garagekeepers Insurance: Legal Liability, Direct Primary, and Direct Excess
A repair shop can face a claim for damage to a vehicle it accepted for service. Start by identifying the garage operation, the vehicle and equipment, where the loss occurred and how it happened. Under ISO CA 99 37 10 01, the named insured selects coverages and limits for scheduled locations. A claim for liability to another driver or damage to the shop’s own property needs a different coverage review.
Bailment and the shop’s duty
Under O.C.G.A. §§ 44-12-40, 44-12-43 and 44-12-77, accepting custody for repair or storage can create a bailment. The customer is the bailor and the shop is the bailee. A garage storing a customer’s vehicle owes ordinary care for safekeeping and return. Check who controlled the vehicle and retained its keys. Once the bailor proves the bailment and loss, § 44-12-44 places the burden of showing proper diligence on the bailee. In Scott v. Purser Truck Sales, the evidence supported application of that rule to the vehicle left for repairs. A storm alone neither establishes nor eliminates the shop’s liability. Investigate what warnings and protective measures were reasonably available.
Covered autos and causes of loss
CA 99 37 10 01 applies to the customer’s auto or equipment left in the insured’s care while attending, servicing, repairing, parking or storing it in garage operations, subject to the scheduled location, coverage and policy terms. Use the actual customer auto and operation definitions. For example, damage on the lift can involve a customer auto in service. Investigate whether a road-test loss arose while attending or servicing it under the actual endorsement. The customer’s loose personal items generally require a separate coverage inquiry. The dated endorsement expressly excludes faulty work, defective parts or materials, and theft or conversion caused in the specified ways by the insured, its employees or shareholders.
| Purchased coverage at the location | Cause under CA 99 37 10 01 | Example to investigate |
|---|---|---|
| Comprehensive | Causes other than the customer auto’s collision or overturn, subject to exclusions | Hail dents a vehicle awaiting repair. |
| Specified Causes of Loss | Fire, lightning, explosion, theft, mischief or vandalism | A fire damages a customer truck left for service. |
| Collision | Collision with another object or overturn | An employee driving the customer’s pickup strikes a bay pillar. |
The standalone Business Auto form’s Specified Causes list is different. Verify the applicable peril list before applying a direct or legal-liability option.
Which party’s insurance responds?
- Legal liability: Pays covered damages the insured legally owes for the customer-auto loss. A technician who strikes a pillar can expose the shop to liability. A severe storm on a secured lot can leave the shop without legal liability if it met its duties. For suits seeking covered damages, check the defense grant, supplementary payments and exhaustion terms.
- Direct excess: Retains legal liability and adds a direct grant for covered loss above any other collectible insurance. Check coverage available to the owner or the insured. If the shop exercised ordinary care, there may still be a direct payment. Determine what the owner’s policy pays and apply the endorsement’s own deductible and location limit. Preserve potential recovery rights and evaluate any claim against the shop separately.
- Direct primary: Makes the scheduled coverage primary for covered loss regardless of the insured’s legal liability. Check who remains responsible for the shop’s deductible, whether any balance is payable elsewhere and whether the repair bill exceeds the location limit.
Suppose qualifying hail damage totals $6,000, another policy pays $5,500, the shop is free of fault and the location’s Comprehensive limit is sufficient. In the dated base wording, hail does not trigger the scheduled Comprehensive deductible. The direct excess grant could pay the covered $500 remainder. If no other insurance pays on the same facts, the full covered $6,000 remains to evaluate under the grant. If the schedule or another endorsement modifies the deductible, rerun the calculation with the actual terms.
Apply the correct deductible and location limit
For CA 99 37 10 01, the scheduled Comprehensive deductible applies per customer auto for theft, mischief or vandalism, subject to a scheduled maximum for all such loss in one event. The Specified Causes deductible applies to its covered perils, subject to its scheduled event maximum. Collision uses the deductible for each customer’s auto. Compare the exact declaration schedule and endorsements. The form can allow the insurer to advance some or all of a deductible in settlement and recover that amount from the insured.
Worked Georgia claim file
A Savannah collision center schedules Direct Primary Comprehensive with a $500 per-auto deductible and a $2,500 event maximum for applicable losses. It also schedules a $500 per-auto Collision deductible. Both limits are sufficient for the two separate events below.
- Vandalism: One incident damages 20 customer autos at $4,000 each. The covered loss is 20 × $4,000 = $80,000. The uncapped deductible is 20 × $500 = $10,000. The event maximum lowers it to $2,500. The adjusted loss is $77,500.
- Collision: An employee driving a customer vehicle strikes a bay pillar. Treat the $3,000 direct damage to that covered vehicle as one covered Collision loss. The adjusted loss is $3,000 − $500 = $2,500. Apply a separate deductible for each qualifying customer auto if more than one has covered Collision damage.
Test the location limit
The scheduled limit is per loss at the specified location under this specimen. Counting five damaged customer autos does not multiply it fivefold. A covered fire at a location scheduled for $150,000 with $360,000 in eligible damage is limited to $150,000 before the applicable deductible treatment. The endorsement subtracts applicable deductibles from its scheduled maximum. Capacity at another scheduled location supplies no extra payment at this location under the base form. Check the actual declarations before estimating a multi-car loss.
Under CA 99 37 10 01 Legal Liability with Comprehensive selected, an Atlanta shop holds a car for repair. An unexpected hailstorm causes $4,800 in damage. The evidence establishes that the shop exercised ordinary care and bears no legal liability. What does the shop’s Garagekeepers insurance pay?
$4,300 after a shop deductible
$0 because the insured owes no damages
$500 toward the customer’s deductible
$4,800 because hail can be a Comprehensive peril
CA 99 37 10 01 Direct Primary has a $250 per-auto Comprehensive deductible with a $2,000 maximum per event and a $500 per-auto Collision deductible. One vandalism event causes covered damage to 12 customer autos with $3,000 damage each. In an unrelated covered Collision loss, one customer car driven by a shop worker strikes a pillar and sustains $2,500 damage. All limits are sufficient. What total deductible applies to the two losses?
$3,500
$2,000
$3,000
$2,500
A tree limb falls on a customer’s pickup while it is at a scheduled repair location with unmodified CA 99 37 10 01 Direct Excess Comprehensive. The shop has no legal liability. The covered loss is $4,200 and the customer’s insurer pays $3,200. The scheduled limit is sufficient and there is no other insurance. How much does the garagekeepers insurer pay under the direct grant?
$1,000, the covered balance after other collectible insurance
$3,700 as primary before the customer’s insurer
$0 because the shop is free of fault
$2,100 as a one-half share
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.