1.1 Risk Concepts, Pure vs. Speculative Risk, and Elements of Insurable Risk
Key Takeaways
A pure risk can result in loss or no loss. A speculative risk may also produce a gain.
A profit-seeking business can have a separate pure property or liability risk. The issued coverage grant defines the insured event.
Fortuity, measurability, estimable costs, manageable aggregation and the economics of the transfer inform underwriting and pricing.
An exposure base measures the risks used for pricing, such as a stated unit of insured value or payroll.
Adverse selection concerns who seeks coverage and at what terms. Examine the lost property, cause and applicable contract to decide a claim.
1.1 Risk Concepts, Pure vs. Speculative Risk, and Elements of Insurable Risk
Insurance addresses uncertainty about the financial consequences of loss. A building's fire exposure depends on what might happen, what can be damaged and how severe the loss might be. A policy defines the circumstances in which the insurer bears part of that consequence. The adjuster investigates a loss under those terms and applicable law. Underwriting and actuarial pricing consider the class and pool of risks.
Pure and speculative risk
| Type | Possible outcomes | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Pure risk | Loss or no loss | Damage to a building from fire or a vehicle from collision, or legal liability if a visitor is injured |
| Speculative risk | Gain, loss or no change | Buying stock or acquiring real estate in anticipation of rising market prices |
Ordinary property and casualty coverage addresses specified loss exposures, such as physical damage to a restaurant. The fact that the restaurant is a profit-seeking venture does not make its property exposure speculative. The profit or loss on the investment itself presents a different exposure. Check the actual insuring agreement when a product covers a selected economic risk. For example, federally authorized crop coverage can insure qualifying revenue loss under its production and price provisions. An insured revenue change there is evaluated under the crop contract. It does not imply a building policy covers a fall in market price. For property indemnity, compare the insurance interest, applicable measure and enforceable limit in 2-1.
Characteristics that make a risk suitable for insurance
These are practical underwriting considerations, and each individual claim still turns on the issued contract.
| Consideration | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Fortuity | A chance fire can arise unexpectedly. Verify intentional-loss wording and applicable law if the person seeking coverage is alleged to have caused it deliberately. |
| Defined, measurable loss | Evidence of covered property, dates, cause and amount helps the insurer determine its obligations. Repair estimates, receipts and policy valuation provide a measure. |
| Estimable frequency and severity | Past data and exposure information can help estimate expected costs; thin data may require credible alternative data or models and adds uncertainty. |
| Manageable aggregation | A common catastrophe may affect many insured properties at once. An insurer must evaluate correlated losses, capacity and other financing, including limits and reinsurance. |
| Meaningful financial exposure | A significant potential loss can justify transferring some of it, while a deductible retains smaller amounts. |
| Feasible premium | The price must support the cost of the risk transfer, and the buyer weighs the benefits of coverage against that price and the amount they can retain. |
One kind of exposure measure is the value insured. At a stipulated rate per $100 of insured value, a $500,000 building represents 5,000 units of that measure. A casualty rating plan can use different units, such as payroll, sales or vehicles measured over time. Read the actual schedule. An exposure unit is the base used to describe or price the risk, while an insured limit caps payment under the policy. It is also distinct from the number of losses that actually occur. If the insurer writes ten such buildings for the same interval, the pool has 50,000 units on this stipulated basis. A single covered fire would still be one loss occurrence on the stated facts. The exposure count helps describe what was at risk during the interval, while the claim count describes what happened.
Adverse selection and claim evaluation
Adverse selection describes higher-risk people seeking greater coverage than lower-risk people in circumstances where the available terms do not adequately distinguish their risk. If properties with substantial flood exposure are disproportionately likely to buy identical flood coverage at the same price as lower-risk properties, the pool can have a higher expected claim cost than the price assumes. The purchasing decision is different from a change in care after a policy is bought. A high-risk customer can have a legitimate claim and is entitled to the promised coverage when its terms are satisfied.
Note
After a Savannah rental fire, the adjuster documents the time using the dispatch record, obtains reliable cause evidence, scopes the damage and retrieves the issued policy. Disconnected utilities and a prolonged absence prompt an inquiry into occupancy and the application date. If the insurer questions an application answer, use Georgia's statutory test in 3-2. For a policy vacancy condition, use its exact text and effective period. Suspected accelerant residue warrants competent origin-and-cause investigation and preservation of evidence. Establish what happened and who is responsible before drawing a conclusion about intent or the insured's claim.
A prospective purchaser seeks to insure the downside of a stock position under ordinary building property insurance. That purchaser also owns a warehouse with an independent fire exposure. How do the two exposures differ?
Both are speculative merely because the purchaser seeks profit.
The investment has possible gain, loss or no change; the warehouse fire exposure involves loss or no loss.
The investment is pure because it has a quoted price, and the warehouse fire exposure includes a gain.
The property policy's warehouse limit automatically insures both.
The insured sole owner deliberately sets fire to their warehouse to collect policy proceeds. Which risk characteristic does the staged loss primarily defeat?
Ability to calculate the warehouse's rebuilding cost.
Ability to group construction types for rating.
Fortuity from the standpoint of the person who deliberately caused the loss.
Ability to establish when the fire occurred.
Which facts best illustrate adverse selection in a flood insurance pool?
At the same terms, properties with materially higher known flood risk disproportionately seek more coverage than those with lower risk.
An adjuster independently values a roof without knowing its premium.
An insured stops securing a door after buying coverage, expecting the insurer to pay.
A deductible reduces the covered amount paid on a hail loss.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.