20-2 Extra Expense, Contingent Business Income, and Rental Value Coverages
Key Takeaways
Choose one CP 00 50 06 95 percentage using the full covered restoration period. Compare that ceiling with eligible Extra Expense.
CP 15 08 and CP 15 09 10 12 use four dependent roles and both have a miscellaneous-locations grant. The two forms use different limits for that grant.
CP 15 45 09 17 uses the interruption of the scheduled utility service to start any Business Income wait. It has its own resumption endpoint.
Rental Value uses net rental income, applicable fair rental value and continuing normal expenses. CP 00 60 06 95 requires lease cancellation from covered physical damage and protects only eligible scheduled interests.
20-2 Extra Expense, Contingent Business Income, and Rental Value Coverages
A printing company that rents temporary presses, a shop that loses traffic after an anchor-store fire, and a tenant that loses a favorable lease can all suffer financial loss. Identify the loss being insured, the damaged property, and the relationship between that damage and the loss before estimating the payment.
Extra Expense in CP 00 30 and CP 00 50
Under CP 00 30 10 12 and standalone CP 00 50 06 95, Extra Expense generally measures necessary incremental expenses during the covered period of restoration that the insured would have avoided in the absence of covered physical loss or damage. Examples include paying for temporary production space, leased equipment and emergency subcontracting. Compare invoices with ordinary operating expenses, account for salvage value on qualifying temporary purchases, and identify other insurance that pays the expense. Review whether the business could resume all or part of operations sooner.
For the regular described-premises claim, the Extra Expense period starts at the qualifying physical loss or damage. The base CP 00 30 Business Income period starts 72 hours after that loss. Under CP 00 32 10 12, the separate expenses-to-reduce-loss provision pays expenses incurred to reduce covered Business Income loss up to the reduction. Under the combined CP 00 30, qualifying ordinary relocation and operating expenses can respond even when the insured saves less Business Income than it spends. Apply the form's special savings condition to property repair or replacement costs and, under CP 00 50, to replacement or restoration of lost information on damaged valuable papers. The standalone form measures whether those costs reduce loss otherwise payable under that form.
Standalone CP 00 50 limits on loss payment
CP 00 50 06 95 has no coinsurance condition. Determine the full covered restoration period. It ends at the earlier of reasonably prompt repair, rebuilding or replacement with comparable quality, or resumption at a new permanent location. Policy expiration does not shorten that period. Select one percentage from the declarations for the whole covered period, then compare the resulting ceiling with eligible expenses.
| Covered restoration period | Declared percentage in this example | Total cap on a $100,000 limit |
|---|---|---|
| 30 days or less | 40% | $40,000 |
| More than 30 through 60 days | 80% | $80,000 |
| More than 60 days | 100% | $100,000 |
Worked adjustment. An Augusta printer has a $150,000 limit with those percentages. A covered burst pipe results in a 28-day covered restoration period and $72,000 of eligible incremental subcontracting and temporary press costs. The first percentage applies to the whole loss. The ceiling is $60,000 and $12,000 exceeds it. If the covered restoration period were 45 days and eligible expenses totaled $110,000, the ceiling would be $120,000 and the payment $110,000. Both examples assume any other applicable adjustments have already been made.
Business Income from dependent properties
CP 15 08 10 12 (Broad) and CP 15 09 10 12 (Limited) address actual Business Income loss when a necessary suspension follows covered physical loss or damage at a qualifying dependent premises. The restoration clock for these Business Income endorsements starts 72 hours after the qualifying damage there and ends when that property should be restored with reasonable speed and similar quality, subject to form provisions. Electronic-data-only loss at a scheduled location or covered secondary location fails the relevant physical damage provision. Four positions in the business relationship matter:
- Contributing. A foundry supplies parts for the insured assembly plant. Water, power, wastewater removal and communications, including Internet or electronic network access, are excluded from the definition of contributing services in these forms.
- Recipient. A wholesale buyer accepts the finished goods of the insured producer.
- Manufacturing. A contract mill manufactures goods for delivery to the insured's customers under a contract of sale.
- Leader. An anchor department store attracts shoppers to neighboring insured stores.
| Limit to check | CP 15 08 10 12 Broad | CP 15 09 10 12 Limited |
|---|---|---|
| Scheduled dependent premises | Applies the underlying Business Income provisions and applicable limit separately to each scheduled dependent property | Has scheduled dependent-property limits separate from the Business Income limit for damage at the insured's own premises |
| Miscellaneous premises | Up to 0.03% of the Business Income limit per day of suspension from one eligible location, within the Business Income limit | Up to 0.03% of the sum of scheduled limits per day of suspension from one eligible location, within those limits |
| Secondary supply or recipient property | Follow the scheduled election and the interruption through its scheduled primary dependency. The applicable Business Income limit controls | Follow the scheduled election and relationship. The limit for the corresponding scheduled contributing or recipient property controls |
A road, bridge, tunnel, waterway, airfield, pipeline or similar structure is outside the miscellaneous-locations grant. For an otherwise eligible loss at an undamaged Georgia insured location, document the role of the damaged business, the insured's applicable Causes of Loss form, the schedule, the interruption and the actual lost income. If a scheduled foundry has a covered fire, document the parts it supplied and whether substitute deliveries let the insured limit the suspension. If the foundry's damage resulted from a peril outside the insured's coverage, the scheduling alone cannot establish the claim.
Utility services and the coverage clock
In CP 15 45 09 17, the insured's operations at the described premises must be suspended because its utility service was interrupted. The interruption must result from qualifying direct physical loss or damage to the utility property indicated in the schedule. The four available categories are water supply, wastewater removal, communication supply and power supply. For communication and power, check the schedule for inclusion of overhead transmission lines. Wastewater coverage excludes interruption from a water or sewage discharge due to heavy rain or flooding.
The scheduled Business Income waiting period, if any, runs from the interruption of service, and covered Extra Expense can begin then. The endorsement ends when operations fully resume by any means or reasonably could fully resume after service is restored, whichever comes first. This endorsement supplies that time measure in place of the underlying period-of-restoration definition. If the insured seeks payment for the damaged property itself, check the separately scheduled direct-damage endorsement CP 04 17 10 12, applicable cause, property and limits.
Rental Value under CP 00 30 and CP 00 32
The declarations can select Business Income including Rental Value, Business Income excluding Rental Value, or Rental Value only. Under these 10 12 editions, Rental Value includes expected net rental income from the described premises as furnished and equipped by the insured, including fair rental value for any portion the insured occupies. Include continuing normal operating expenses, such as payroll and tenant charges that would otherwise be the insured's obligations. Build the calculation from leases, rent rolls and evidence of continuing expenses.
If a covered fire renders part of a Savannah center untenantable, assess Rental Value from the regular Business Income start after 72 hours through the covered restoration period. For a payable underlying Rental Value loss, the Extended Business Income provision can begin when actual repairs are complete and tenantability returns. It can continue through the earlier of reasonably restoring the prior rental-income level through occupancy or 60 days after it began under the base terms. Loss caused by unfavorable business conditions in the affected area is outside this extension.
Leasehold Interest under CP 00 60 06 95
The grant requires actual cancellation of the lease because of covered direct physical loss or damage at the premises in the declarations. Confirm the lease's casualty clause and actual cancellation, then identify which interests are scheduled:
- Tenants' Lease Interest. The monthly rental value less actual monthly rent, including specified rent charges, is Gross Leasehold Interest. Multiply it by the attached factor for the remaining term at the scheduled rate to get Net Leasehold Interest.
- Bonus Payments and Prepaid Rent. Use the unrefunded, unamortized eligible amount. A qualifying cash bonus to acquire the lease excludes rent and security. Advance rent excludes the customary rent due at the beginning of the rental period.
- Improvements and Betterments. Use qualifying unamortized payments for tenant-funded fixtures or alterations the tenant cannot legally remove, to the extent the value is unrecoverable under other insurance.
The net interests decrease monthly. For a bonus, betterment or prepaid rent, divide the original qualifying expense by the months remaining at the time of expenditure. Multiply that monthly amount by the months remaining at the loss. If the original lease is cancelled and the landlord offers continued use under a new lease or arrangement, check the lower rent-difference ceiling for Tenants' Lease Interest and the actual-loss ceiling for the other components. A disruption during a lease that stays in force fails the cancellation trigger.
Worked adjustment. A Midtown Atlanta dental practice loses its lease after a covered building fire. Assume the insured satisfies the form's conditions and the schedule includes both interests. The all-in contract rent was $4,000 monthly, the market rental value is $6,500, and 20 months remain. At the scheduled 10% rate the attached factor is 18.419. The $2,500 monthly Gross Leasehold Interest yields $46,047.50 of Net Leasehold Interest. Separately, the tenant prepaid $12,000 of qualifying rent when 30 months remained. The monthly amortization is $400, leaving $8,000 unrefunded at cancellation. With no replacement lease or other adjustment, the total is $54,047.50.
A Macon printer has CP 00 50 06 95 with a $200,000 limit and 40% / 80% / 100% percentages. A covered fire results in a 25-day covered restoration period and $95,000 in eligible temporary rent, overtime and subcontracting. Assume no other adjustment. How much is payable?
$95,000, because all necessary expenses incurred to continue operations are paid up to the $200,000 policy limit.
$72,000, because Extra Expense coverage is always subject to an 80% coinsurance formula.
$80,000, because the Period of Restoration lasted 30 days or less, capping payment at 40% of the $200,000 limit.
$0, because Extra Expense claims are subject to a mandatory 72-hour waiting period and must reduce Business Income loss.
A Marietta shoe store schedules a mall anchor department store in its CP 15 08 10 12 endorsement. A covered fire destroys the anchor, causing a necessary slowdown at the undamaged shoe store. The anchor normally draws shoppers to neighboring shops. Which role applies to the anchor?
Leader Location
Contributing Location
Recipient Location
Manufacturing Location
A Savannah software firm leased a suite at an all-in rent of $3,200 monthly. Thirty months remain, and the current rental value is $5,000 a month. Covered direct physical damage at that location causes its landlord to cancel the lease under the casualty clause. Which form provides coverage, when scheduled, for the discounted value of the lost favorable rent?
Utility Services — Time Element (CP 15 45)
Business Income Without Extra Expense (CP 00 32)
Rental Value Coverage under CP 00 30
Leasehold Interest Coverage Form (CP 00 60)
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.