17-3 Ocean Marine Insurance: Hull, Cargo, and Freight Coverages
Key Takeaways
Confirm the edition of the collision clause before calculating the insured share and its cap.
Read when the cargo transit attaches and the first applicable ending event under its actual clause.
CFR and CIF can transfer risk at shipment despite the seller paying carriage to destination. Under CIF the seller also procures the required insurance.
A freight claim depends on compensation at risk under the carriage contract. Apply warranty and machinery terms under the applicable law and form.
Ocean Marine Insurance: Hull, Cargo, and Freight Coverages
After a collision on the Savannah River, the damaged ship, its cargo and a lost shipping fee can involve different insured interests. Before calculating a settlement, identify the claim and read the vessel or shipment schedule, insuring clauses, navigation limits, and applicable law.
| Insured interest | Policy question |
|---|---|
| Hull and machinery | Does the vessel suffer damage from an insured cause? Is separate liability covered by the collision clause? |
| Cargo | Was the damaged property an insured shipment, in covered transit, when the damage occurred? |
| Freight | Was a shipping fee still at risk under the contract of carriage? |
| Protection and Indemnity | Does the actual policy or club entry cover this liability of the vessel owner or operator? |
Hull insurance and running down
The American Institute Hull Clauses of September 29, 2009 describe the insured vessel by its hull, machinery, equipment and other stated interests. The form separately states agreed value and amount insured. A time policy applies during a stated term and within its navigation terms. A voyage policy covers a stated voyage. Check whether a deviation, lay-up, period change or other event triggers a clause in the issued policy.
A hull policy's Running Down or Collision Liability clause can indemnify qualifying amounts owed for collision with another vessel. The Institute Time Clauses—Hulls 1/10/83, an English-law specimen, cover three-fourths of specified collision liability, subject to the applicable cap of three-fourths of the insured vessel value for any one collision. Its collision-liability clause excludes bodily injury and damage to fixed property such as a pier. The American Institute Hull Clauses of September 29, 2009 use the insurers' subscriptions relative to agreed value and can insure the full qualifying share when fully subscribed, subject to their own cap and other terms. Inspect both the hull and any P&I wording before deciding how a particular collision is shared.
Worked application. A fully subscribed policy expressly uses the 1983 Institute Time Clauses, with a $20 million insured value and no adjustment besides the clause. The vessel owner pays $4 million in qualifying liability for damage to the other vessel and its cargo. The clause responds for $3 million, within its $15 million cap. A separate pier-damage claimant or injured worker requires a different liability inquiry.
Cargo and the length of transit
Open cargo coverage lets a regular exporter or importer insure eligible shipments through agreed reporting terms. A single-voyage policy addresses a particular shipment. Use the actual contract for the attachment point, termination conditions and any rerouting or delay.
Under Institute Cargo Clauses (A) 1/1/09, clause 8 starts coverage when the cargo is first moved in the stated warehouse or storage place for immediate loading and commencement of transit. It continues in the ordinary course until the first listed ending event. These include completion of unloading at the final named warehouse, completion of unloading at another warehouse selected for non-transit storage or allocation, electing to use a vehicle or container for non-transit storage, and 60 days after completion of discharge from the overseas vessel at the final discharge port. For example, unloading at the named final Atlanta warehouse 12 days after discharge can terminate the regular transit coverage on day 12. Check any separate continuation terms for a carriage contract terminated short of destination.
International trade terms
Under ICC Incoterms 2020, if incorporated into the sales contract, risk generally passes when the goods are on board at shipment for FOB (Free on Board), CFR (Cost and Freight), and CIF (Cost Insurance and Freight). These rules allocate performance, costs and risk between buyer and seller. They do not determine ownership or insurer liability.
- FOB. The buyer normally arranges main carriage. The seller loads or procures goods already delivered aboard the vessel.
- CFR. The seller arranges and pays carriage to the named destination port and has no obligation to the buyer under this rule to buy insurance.
- CIF. The seller also obtains insurance for the buyer's risk. Unless agreed otherwise or the trade custom differs, CIF A5 requires coverage equivalent to Institute Cargo Clauses (C), with insurance of at least 110% of the contract price. This is an insurance procurement obligation under the sales contract. The insurance form determines settlement value.
Freight insurance
Freight means the carrier's compensation for carriage in this context. Read when it is earned, when it is payable and who bears the risk if carried goods are lost. If the contract makes freight payable only on safe arrival, a sinking that prevents delivery can cause a loss to the carrier's insured freight interest. Where the carrier has already earned nonrefundable freight, it has no loss of that amount simply because the shipment fails to arrive. A cargo policy can include freight in its insured value when its valuation clause and the insured's interest support it.
Perils, machinery clauses and warranties
Read the policy's own grant before labeling damage a peril of the seas. For example, a vessel can suffer hull damage from a covered grounding, while gradual corrosion requires separate attention to the exclusions. Named peril hull provisions can also list fire, jettison and barratry separately. Cargo Clauses (A) start with a broad risk-of-loss grant and have exclusions for matters such as delay, inherent vice, defined packing failures, war and strikes. War and strikes coverage use their own grants when purchased.
The American Institute's Inchmaree Clause (65-C) illustrates additions for boiler bursts, shaft breaks, latent defects and specified negligence of the vessel's crew or pilots, subject to its due diligence proviso. Its treatment of a defective part differs from resulting damage. The 2009 American Institute Hull Clauses also state covered machinery perils and exclude repair or replacement of the defective part under the stated provision. A chief engineer's error that bursts a boiler and damages an adjacent engine room calls for examining that grant and the due diligence proviso.
Express terms may impose navigation, use and lay-up restrictions. For an asserted seaworthiness condition or deviation, identify the specific contract and governing law. A deviation does not mechanically terminate all coverage. For example, Cargo Clauses (A) 1/1/09 contain a qualified continuation during deviation and a distinct seaworthiness/unfitness exclusion tied to specified knowledge. Wilburn Boat examined the role of state law absent a controlling federal maritime rule for the policy warranties at issue. Great Lakes Insurance v. Raiders Retreat held that marine insurance choice-of-law provisions are presumptively enforceable under federal maritime law, subject to narrow exceptions.
An insured vessel with a $20 million insured value uses the unamended Institute Time Clauses—Hulls 1/10/83. It pays $4 million of qualifying third-party vessel and cargo damage after a collision, plus separate $600,000 pier damage and $300,000 crew injury. Assume full subscription and no other adjustment. What does the three-fourths collision clause pay?
$4,900,000 including pier and crew claims
$4,000,000 for the other ship and its cargo
$3,000,000 for the qualifying other-ship and cargo damage
$0 because a cargo insurer alone can cover collision liability
A Georgia exporter sells poultry CFR Rotterdam, Incoterms 2020, without contrary terms. The goods are placed aboard, and the vessel later sinks mid-voyage. Which party bears the risk of loss at sea under this sales rule?
The buyer because the goods were already on board at the port of shipment
The seller because it paid freight to Rotterdam
The vessel owner's freight insurer automatically
The marine hull underwriter under a mandatory collision clause
A chief engineer's error causes a boiler to burst and damages the adjoining engine room. Which hull clause specifically addresses these causes, subject to the actual form's provisos and exclusions?
Warehouse-to-Warehouse Transit
Inchmaree
Free of Capture and Seizure
A navigation-limit warranty
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.