12-1 Georgia Unfair Claims Settlement Practices and Bad Faith Penalties (O.C.G.A. § 33-4-6)

Key Takeaways

  • Sections 33-6-33 and 33-6-34 permit administrative enforcement of listed practices committed flagrantly and in conscious disregard of the law, or often enough to show a general business practice. Section 33-6-37 creates no private cause of action for a violation.

  • The general statute calls for reasonably prompt acknowledgment and provides 15 calendar days to supply necessary claim forms after a request. Rule 120-2-52 supplies separate deadlines for first-party private passenger auto property damage.

  • Under § 33-4-6 the bad-faith penalty is capped at the greater of half the insurer’s liability for the covered loss and $5,000, with reasonable attorney’s fees considered separately.

  • Under Holt and Hughes, a valid within-limits settlement offer can trigger a liability insurer’s duty to settle. A proven negligent or bad-faith failure to settle can result in liability for an excess judgment. Current Georgia motor vehicle injury settlement law sets additional requirements.

Last updated: November 2026

12-1 Georgia Unfair Claims Settlement Practices and Bad Faith Penalties (O.C.G.A. § 33-4-6)

A Georgia adjuster may face three separate questions in one file. Did the insurer follow claims handling requirements? Does an insured have a statutory remedy for bad-faith refusal to pay their own claim? Did the liability insurer fail to protect its insured from an excess judgment? Each question uses a different standard.

Unfair claims settlement practices

O.C.G.A. §§ 33-6-33 and 33-6-34 apply to insurers transacting business in Georgia. A listed act is improper when done flagrantly and in conscious disregard of Title 33 or its implementing rules, or often enough to show that it is a general business practice. A single flagrant act can satisfy the first standard. Section 33-6-37 gives no private cause of action for violation of this article. The Commissioner enforces it through the administrative process.

Claim issueO.C.G.A. § 33-6-34What to check
Coverage and correspondence(1) and (2)Avoid knowingly misstating relevant facts or coverage. Acknowledge pertinent claim communications with reasonable promptness.
Investigation(3), (6) and (9)Maintain prompt investigation and settlement procedures, investigate reasonably before refusing payment, and avoid duplicative proof-of-loss verifications that unreasonably delay the claim. Policy-authorized sworn statements remain available.
Settlement and payment(4), (5), (8), (13) and (14)Attempt prompt, fair settlement when liability becomes reasonably clear. Avoid offers so low that insureds or beneficiaries have to sue for substantially greater amounts. On the insured's written request, identify the coverage under which each claim payment is made. A first-party payment may be described as final if it pays the policy limit or reflects an agreed compromise on coverage and amount. A partial check may not purport to release all liability.
Coverage position and reasons(7) and (10)On the insured's written request, affirm or deny within a reasonable time after completing the investigation. Promptly give a reasonable, accurate explanation when requested in writing for a denial or compromise offer. Claim denials under (10) must be written.
Claim forms and repairs(11) and (12)Provide required claim forms with instructions within 15 calendar days of a request. Apply reasonable workmanlike repair standards when the insurer owns the repairer.

Separate first-party auto deadlines

Rule 120-2-52 expressly addresses first-party property damage under personal private passenger motor vehicle policies. The rule has separate dates tied to separate actions. The clock for acknowledging notice starts when the insurer receives the claim notification, including notice to the insurer's agent. Acknowledgment is due within 15 days unless payment is made within that period. Applicable proof-of-loss forms are also due within 15 days of notification under the rule. Sending the forms counts as acknowledgment.

For a motor vehicle claim, the rule gives 15 days from receipt of completed proof of loss to affirm or deny. When proof of loss is not required, conduct the necessary coverage investigation within 30 days of claim notification. If more time is needed under Rule 120-2-52-.03(5), notify the claimant within five business days after the applicable period, give the reason and estimate the additional time. The rule limits the total time to accept or deny to 60 days from notification unless the file shows that necessary requested information remains outstanding. Tender payment within 10 days after coverage is confirmed and the full claim amount is determined and undisputed.

On an exam, read what started the clock. A claimant's request for forms triggers the statute's 15-calendar-day rule. Notice of a first-party private passenger auto claim can separately trigger the regulatory acknowledgment requirement. A later statutory demand for payment under § 33-4-6 starts a different 60-day period.

First-party bad faith under O.C.G.A. § 33-4-6

Start with a covered loss and a demand by the policyholder when payment is due. The demand must give the insurer notice of the specific refusal and potential bad-faith claim. No particular words are prescribed. A dated written demand helps establish when the insurer received it. Filing an insurance claim or submitting proof of loss does not by itself establish a statutory demand. Allow 60 days after a sufficient demand before suing for the statutory remedy.

Bad faith means a frivolous or unfounded refusal to pay. A genuine, reasonable dispute over facts or coverage can defeat a bad-faith claim even when the policyholder prevails on the contract. A refusal without a reasonable basis can support a penalty when the remaining statutory requirements are met. Payment after the 60-day period does not end an otherwise valid bad-faith action. Section 33-4-6(b) also requires sending the Commissioner a copy of the demand and complaint, ordinarily within 20 days of filing.

The maximum penalty is the greater of half the insurer's liability for the covered loss and $5,000. The trier of fact can award a lesser penalty. Keep the underlying loss and reasonable attorney's fees separate in the calculation.

Insurer's liability for the lossHalf the liabilityMaximum penalty before fees
$4,000$2,000$5,000
$8,000$4,000$5,000
$10,000$5,000$5,000
$40,000$20,000$20,000
$150,000$75,000$75,000

If the proven covered liability is $40,000 and the factfinder awards the maximum penalty, the covered loss and penalty total $60,000 before reasonable attorney's fees. This calculation answers a different question from when a payment is due under the policy.

Third-party liability and offers to settle within limits

In Southern General Insurance Co. v. Holt, the Georgia Supreme Court addressed a liability insurer's duty to give the insured's interests equal consideration in deciding whether to settle. First Acceptance Insurance Co. of Georgia v. Hughes clarified that the duty to settle arises when the injured party presents a valid offer within the insured's policy limits. Whether an insurer acted as an ordinarily prudent insurer depends on the actual offer, facts bearing on liability and damages, and circumstances surrounding the response. If a negligent or bad-faith failure to settle causes an excess judgment, the insured may recover resulting excess liability.

For a current, attorney-assisted motor vehicle personal injury or death offer during the statutory period before the applicable answers or default, apply § 9-11-67.1 as amended by SB 83. Check the stated payment amount, the parties and claims to be released, the type and content of the release, and the deadlines. Acceptance gets at least 30 days from receipt and delivery of payment at least 40. The statute also addresses the sworn coverage disclosure if required, supporting records, delivery method and response address. Release terms can be full or limited. Subsection (i) provides a defense to an alleged failure to settle when the recipient meets its response, disclosure and payment conditions, subject to its limits for later offers. The statute excludes product liability offers.

For example, a single pedestrian's damages exceed a $25,000 per-person limit. Assume a valid offer within the limit, no statutory protection for the insurer's response, and a proven negligent failure to settle that caused a $200,000 judgment. The insurer's policy obligation is $25,000 and the excess attributable to the proven failure is $175,000. The fact that an initial demand was rejected would by itself establish neither that failure nor the excess liability.

Sources: Georgia unfair claims statute · Georgia first-party auto claim rule · Georgia bad-faith statute · BayRock v. Chicago Title · Holt · Hughes · SB 83 as enacted

Test Your Knowledge

A covered Georgia kitchen fire produces $6,000 in insurer liability. The policyholder makes a sufficient demand under § 33-4-6 after payment became due. The insurer fails to pay within 60 days. If the jury finds bad faith, what is the maximum penalty before reasonable attorney’s fees?

A

$3,000, exactly half the covered loss

B

$5,000, because that exceeds half the covered loss

C

$6,000, a penalty equal to the full loss

D

$10,000, an administrative fine

Test Your Knowledge

Under the Georgia Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act (O.C.G.A. § 33-6-30 through § 33-6-34), what legal threshold must generally be met for an insurer's prohibited claim handling behavior to constitute an actionable violation enforced by the Georgia Insurance Commissioner?

A

The claimant must prove the insurer acted with criminal malice and caused catastrophic financial bankruptcy to the policyholder.

B

The claimant must demonstrate that at least three independent insurance adjusters committed identical clerical errors within a 30-day period.

C

The practice must be committed with such frequency as to indicate a general business practice, or committed flagrantly and in conscious disregard of the law.

D

The practice must result in a civil lawsuit that reaches a final jury verdict in the Georgia Court of Appeals.

Test Your Knowledge

A Georgia pedestrian receives a $200,000 judgment against a driver whose policy has a $25,000 per-person bodily injury limit. The pedestrian had made a valid $25,000 offer to settle the claim within the policy limit. Assume a factfinder separately finds that the insurer negligently failed to settle and caused the excess judgment, with no statutory protection or offset. How much of the judgment exceeds the policy obligation?

A

$175,000, the judgment less the per-person limit

B

$25,000, the per-person limit itself

C

$200,000, the entire judgment before subtracting policy coverage

D

$150,000, after subtracting the $50,000 per-accident limit

Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.