7.1 Control Valve Body Types, Trim & Fail-Safe Positions
Key Takeaways
Valve body style identifies the flow path and motion. The specific trim establishes capacity, characteristic and much of the shutoff performance.
Packing seals around the stem or shaft. Choose a packing system using the manufacturer’s pressure-temperature envelope and the project emissions specification.
Seat leakage is measured under the specified class test. A closed-travel indication provides evidence of movement.
Read body and port sizes separately. Match the asset and serial number to the pressure rating and trim on the approved data sheet.
Predict the assembled valve response to the specified loss of loading air, supply air or electrical signal.
Control Valve Bodies, Trim, Packing and Fail Positions
A control valve changes the flow path in response to an actuator. Identify whether the valve must modulate, switch between ports, or provide specified shutoff. Read the valve marks and the trim data together. Different trims in the same body can have different capacity, flow direction and shutoff performance.
Identify the body and the moving parts
| Construction | How it works | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Single-port globe | A sliding stem positions a plug against one seat. | Trim and seat materials, permitted flow direction, required thrust and shutoff. |
| Double-port globe | Two plugs on one stem can reduce net pressure force by acting in opposing directions. | Specified seating performance under the test conditions, since both seats must close. |
| Cage-guided globe | A cage guides the plug and can contain shaped ports that determine the flow characteristic. | Correct orientation, travel, cage and seal. A balanced plug can reduce unbalanced thrust. |
| Three-way globe | Three connections let the valve combine streams or divert flow along alternate paths. | Port identification and the approved mixing or diverting configuration. |
| Angle body | The inlet-to-outlet path changes direction at the body. | Direction, outlet arrangement, and suitability for erosion or flashing service as applicable. |
| Segmented ball | A shaped ball segment rotates to change the opening. | Profile, seal, materials, solids passage, minimum controllable flow and required shutoff. |
| Eccentric plug | An offset plug rotates away from the seat as it opens. | Seat, trim material and flow passage suited to the fluid and debris. |
| Butterfly | A disk rotates in the flow. Offset designs change the relationship between disk and seat motion. | Disk and seal, installed clearances, seating torque and pressure-temperature rating. |
In a globe valve, the moving closure is the plug and the seat ring provides the closing surface. The trim includes the pieces used to control flow and shutoff, such as the plug, stem, seat and cage or guide when present. Use the manufacturer's parts drawing when ordering, since a service assembly can include additional pieces. The bonnet closes the body opening and accommodates the stem seal. A balanced plug uses passages and a seal arrangement to reduce the net force from differential pressure. Remaining force, seating load and friction still matter.
For example, Fisher's easy-e ET is a cage-guided control valve with a balanced plug. A Fisher YD can serve converging or diverging duty in the specified construction. The Vee-Ball product bulletin describes a segmented V-notch and shearing action useful for some fibrous slurries. That product principle helps narrow the candidates. Check the actual particle, wear, flow, seat and material requirements before selecting a trim.
Separate seat leakage from stem leakage
Seat leakage passes through a valve commanded closed. ANSI/FCI 70-2-2021 specifies control valve seat leakage testing. IEC 60534-4:2021 specifies inspection and routine tests under its own requirements. Use the governing document and class named by the project.
| ANSI/FCI class | Basis of the limit |
|---|---|
| I | No defined test under the applicable supplier-user agreement. |
| II, III and IV | 0.5%, 0.1% and 0.01%, respectively, of rated capacity under the prescribed test conditions. |
| V | Water leakage related to port diameter and the applied pressure differential. |
| VI | Air or nitrogen leakage limit keyed to nominal port diameter in the prescribed test. |
If the rated test capacity used for a Class IV comparison is 100 US gal/min, the limit is US gal/min, about 38 mL/min. Class VI is a finite allowance, for example 0.15 mL/min for a nominal 1-inch port under the specified conditions. The test pressure is limited by the rated differential and the class procedure. Confirm the medium, test pressure, actuator closing load and measuring method. A closed-travel indication gives neither seat leakage nor a basis for using a control valve as a personnel isolation device.
Stem leakage passes along the stem or shaft to the surroundings. The packing and gland make the dynamic seal. PTFE and graphite are both used in control-valve packing systems, with different friction and service properties. Check the product pressure-temperature envelope and emissions requirement for the complete seal assembly. For example, Fisher's ET bulletin lists distinct ENVIRO-SEAL PTFE and graphite ULF limits under its stated emissions and application conditions. Disc springs in a specified live-loaded assembly maintain packing load as the rings consolidate. Use the specified stack and setting. Excess friction can make valve travel stick.
An extension bonnet separates the packing from the body to manage temperature. A finned bonnet can dissipate heat where the design provides for it. A bellows seal supplies an additional stem sealing barrier. Fisher's bellows bonnet has a defined service envelope and a purge or monitoring connection. Use the model's ratings and maintenance instructions.
Read the markings and verify fail response
The Fisher sample EWT-C assembly drawing gives a useful nameplate example. Its body plate identifies NPS 16 and a 12-inch port, along with the pressure rating, trim fields and serial number. Body size and port size describe different dimensions. A class marking refers to an applicable pressure-temperature rating, which depends on material and the governing standard. Match the asset tag and serial to the approved valve data sheet. Verify body and end style, trim, flow direction, pressure-temperature limits and shutoff against the product documentation.
Specify the failure event. Loss of actuator loading pressure, loss of air supply, and loss of electrical power or command can produce different responses. A positioner, trip valve, solenoid or reserve supply can alter what the actuator sees.
| Assembled valve behavior | Meaning for the stated condition |
|---|---|
| Fail closed | The closure member travels to its closed position. Verify the required leakage performance separately. |
| Fail open | The closure member travels to its open position. Actual flow also depends on the process and supply. |
| Hold last position | The system is arranged to retain its position after the specified failure. Verify holding performance and duration. |
With a Fisher 657, pressure pushes the stem down and the spring returns it up when loading is lost. On a push-down-to-close body that return opens the valve. On a push-down-to-open body it closes it. The Fisher 667 moves in the opposite direction at loading and return. A Fisher 377 supply-pressure trip valve can be piped to move an actuator up, move it down or lock in position. A positioner's electrical failure response depends on its relay and available air. The DVC6200 SIS single-acting direct and reverse relays illustrate this distinction. Verify the approved response for the actual service and failure event.
A globe valve needs replacement stem packing for a steam service that has a specified pressure, temperature and emissions target. What should the technician confirm before selecting the packing?
The control valve seat leakage class, because it also specifies leakage around the stem.
The approved packing assembly for this valve, including its pressure-temperature and emissions envelope and the specified loading hardware.
The body flange rating alone, because packing uses the same pressure and temperature limits.
The stem diameter alone, because it determines the available packing materials and their ratings.
An approved design requires a reactor cooling valve to open when loading air to its spring-return actuator is lost. Assume the coolant supply remains available and the actuator chamber vents in this test. Which assembly meets the specified motion?
An air-to-open valve whose spring travels toward closed.
An actuator and trip valve piped to hold the last position.
An air-to-close valve whose spring drives the closure member fully open.
A valve whose actuator travel stops at midstroke on loss of loading pressure.
A technician is comparing trims for modulating a fibrous pulp slurry. Which candidate should be evaluated first when the product bulletin identifies shearing at the ball-to-seal interface and lists this type of service?
A segmented V-notch ball trim with the documented shearing design.
A globe trim chosen solely by its Class VI seat leakage rating.
A concentric butterfly trim selected solely by equal line size.
A double-port globe trim selected solely by its reduced net pressure thrust.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.