5.1 Automatic Process Control and Loop Dynamics
Key Takeaways
Separate the controller output command from the variable physically manipulated in the process.
With SP held fixed, trace measured PV to controller output, final-element travel and process response to choose negative feedback.
An on/off controller can retain its previous state between two configured switch thresholds. A modulating controller can request intermediate output.
For a first-order-plus-delay model, measure the time constant from response onset to the 63.2% point.
A self-regulating process settles at a new value. An integrating tank ramps while a fixed net inflow or outflow persists.
Fundamentals of Automatic Process Control and Loop Dynamics
A feedback loop responds to the measured result of a control action. The setpoint (SP) is the desired value. The process variable (PV) is the value supplied to the controller by the measuring system. Use consistent units when comparing the two. The controller output (CO) is a command to the final element. The manipulated variable is the change the final element makes to the process, such as the steam flow adjusted by a valve. A change in steam header pressure can disturb that flow even when the command stays fixed.
SP and measured PV → Controller → command → Final element → manipulated flow
↑ ↓
Sensor ← physical PV ← Process ← disturbances
An open-loop action sets an output without correcting it from the result. A heat exchanger with a fixed steam-valve command can drift when the feed flow changes. In closed loop, a temperature transmitter feeds the measurement back to a controller, which adjusts steam in response. A single change can move through several physical and signal stages before the controller detects its effect.
Select feedback action from the installed signal path
Use for the mathematical examples in this chapter. At fixed SP, a rising PV decreases this error. The installed controller may instead use , an action switch, or another sign convention. For example, the Rockwell Logix PID lets the user select the error expression. Use the manual for the specific instruction and verify the actual output direction.
In the physical convention used here, a direct-acting controller increases its output as measured PV rises at fixed SP. A reverse-acting controller decreases its output. A corrective output tends to oppose the initial change in PV. Correct polarity is essential for negative feedback. Loop stability also depends on process dynamics, tuning and limits.
| Flow path in normal operation | If measured PV rises | Required controller action in this convention |
|---|---|---|
| Higher output opens a steam valve and adds heat | Reduce output to reduce heating | Reverse |
| Higher output opens a coolant valve and removes heat | Raise output to increase cooling | Direct |
| Higher output closes a coolant valve | Reduce output to increase cooling | Reverse |
| Higher output opens the outlet of a level-controlled vessel | Raise output to increase discharge | Direct |
| Higher output opens the inlet of a level-controlled vessel | Reduce output to decrease incoming flow | Reverse |
| Higher output opens a vessel's gas outlet and lowers pressure | Raise output to release more gas | Direct |
The air-to-open or air-to-close label describes the actuator pressure-to-travel relationship of an assembled valve. Trace controller output through any I/P converter, positioner or signal reversal to the installed travel and resulting process change. Separately consult the drawing and approved functional test for the position reached on a specified loss of signal, air or power.
On/off and modulating controllers
An on/off controller commands two states. An intentional differential between switch points keeps it from changing state repeatedly due to small fluctuations. In an Omron heating example, the heater switches off at 100 °C and turns on again when temperature falls to 99.2 °C. The switch differential is 0.8 °C. At 99.6 °C it retains its prior state. This is a configured switching behavior. Mechanical lost motion or sticking in a modulating valve is a different effect.
A modulating controller can request intermediate outputs. The Fisher 2500 pneumatic level controller couples a displacer and torque tube to a flapper and nozzle. As the flapper approaches the nozzle, nozzle pressure rises. A relay uses the resulting pressure change to regulate its supply and exhaust. Output pressure feeds back through the proportional valve to a Bourdon tube. The 2500S differential-gap variant switches between full output and exhaust. An electronic controller uses an input interface and configured algorithm to calculate the command, then drives the specified output, such as an analog current or a relay. Check input scale, action, output type and local/remote mode before assuming the controller is responding incorrectly.
Read a process step response
For a stable, self-regulating process that settles after a small step with other inputs steady, the steady-state gain is . A 10-percentage-point change in output that raises the PV by 15 points of transmitter span gives . If PV is in engineering units, the gain carries those units per output unit. A changed operating point may give a different gain.
A first-order plus dead time model approximates some such responses. The delay runs from the step to the modeled onset. Fluid traveling 60 ft at 6 ft/s takes 10 s to arrive, one possible contribution. A thermowell often adds lag. Instrument filtering, valve movement and measurement resolution also affect the response you can observe. After the delay the first-order fraction of the total change at time is , where is measured from the output step.
| Time after the delay | Fraction of total change |
|---|---|
| One time constant | 63.2% |
| Two | 86.5% |
| Three | 95.0% |
| Five | 99.3% |
At s and s, the approximate 95% time is s from the step. Larger delay relative to response speed can limit achievable feedback performance. The model must fit the measured response closely enough for the intended use.
Ramping and settling indicate different dynamics
A gravity-drained vessel can settle at a higher level after an inflow step because the higher head drives more outflow. With a constant-density liquid, constant tank area , and pumped outflow fixed, the balance is . A sustained imbalance changes level at a constant rate while those conditions hold. For and net inflow of , level rises . Use that ramp to identify integrating behavior in the observed region. A short ramp alone may also be part of a slower response that eventually settles. An unstable process may depart from its operating point on its own and requires a suitable approved analysis method.
A cooling loop is tested with its setpoint fixed. An increase in controller output has been verified to open the installed cooling valve, and more cooling lowers the measured temperature. Under the convention that direct action increases output when PV rises, what action provides negative feedback?
Reverse, since more cooling lowers temperature.
Direct, since higher temperature calls for an increase in cooling command.
Direct only if valve travel is held at 50 percent.
Reverse because the controller uses a temperature input.
A recorded heat-exchanger step response follows a first-order-plus-delay model. At t = 0 the output steps upward. Temperature stays at 100 °C for 15 s, reaches 163.2 °C at t = 75 s and approaches 200 °C. What are the delay, time constant and approximate time from the step to reach 95% of the change?
15 s delay, 75 s time constant, 240 s from the step
0 s delay, 60 s time constant, 180 s from the step
15 s delay, 15 s time constant, 60 s from the step
15 s delay, 60 s time constant, 195 s from the step
In two approved step tests, the first PV settles to a new steady value at constant output. In the second, a fixed net inflow to a constant-area tank produces a steady 1.5 input-span points per minute rise until the test ends. Which models describe the observed responses?
First self-regulating, second integrating.
First integrating, second self-regulating.
Both integrating because output is fixed.
Both self-regulating because the starting PV was stable.
An on/off heater switches off on a rise to 60 °C and switches on again on a fall to 58 °C. Starting with heating on at 57 °C, the temperature rises to 59 °C. What output is commanded?
Off, because temperature is above the lower switching point.
Half of the heating output.
On, because the upper switching point has not been reached.
Off, because a rising temperature reverses the action.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.