3.1 Semantic Analogies & Basic Relationship Types
Key Takeaways
A verbal analogy asks for the relationship that best fits both word pairs.
A bridge sentence states a specific link such as “is a tool used by.”
Keep the direction of an ordered relationship the same in each pair.
A constituent can be removable and still form part of a whole.
3.1 Semantic Analogies & Basic Relationship Types
The historical CFAT practice booklet includes a verbal analogy based on contrasting meanings. To solve an analogy, name the relationship in the first pair so that you can test the second. The practice examples below also use links between tools and their users, parts and wholes, and actions and outcomes.
Two ways to write an analogy
A practice analogy can be written in either of these forms:
- Proportional Pair Notation:
WORD1 : WORD2 :: WORD3 : [?](read as: WORD1 is to WORD2 as WORD3 is to blank) - Sentence Stem Notation:
WORD1 is to WORD2 as WORD3 is to [?]
The two layouts ask the same question. Look for a relation that connects both pairs in the same direction. For example, a tool can be linked to the person who uses it. Two terms from the same field may describe a different relationship altogether. Before choosing, state the connection in a sentence.
The Bridge Sentence Technique
A bridge sentence names how the two terms relate. Make it specific enough to distinguish alternatives, while keeping it general enough to apply to a new pair.
Weak vs. Precise Bridges
A vague bridge sentence allows multiple incorrect distractors to pass through, whereas a more precise bridge helps identify the best fit:
- Prompt Pair:
HAMMER : CARPENTER - Weak Bridge: A hammer and a carpenter have to do with construction work.
- Why it fails: Answer choices like
PAINTBRUSH : WALLorWRENCH : PLUMBINGalso "have to do with work," causing confusion.
- Why it fails: Answer choices like
- Precise Bridge: A hammer is a tool used by a carpenter.
- Testing Options with the Rule of Substitution:
- Is a paintbrush a tool utilized by a wall? No.
- A wrench is a tool. Plumbing names a type of work, while the bridge asks for the person.
- A scalpel is a tool used by a surgeon. It fits the tool-to-worker relationship.
- Testing Options with the Rule of Substitution:
The Rule of Substitution
Keep the meaning and direction of the relationship fixed. Ordinary grammatical changes such as choosing “a” or “an” are fine. If you have to switch the subject and object or change the connection itself, the option fits a different relationship.
Foundational Relationship Taxonomy
Practise these kinds of relationships. Multiple connections can exist between two words, so check which one the answer choices preserve most closely:
| Relationship Category | Definition | Canonical Prompt () | Target Completion () | Precise Bridge Sentence Formula |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Part to Whole | Term A is a constituent of entity B, even if it can be removed. | Spoke : Wheel | Stanza : Poem | "A spoke is one of the parts that make up a spoked wheel." |
| Item to Category (Class) | Term A is a specific subordinate member belonging to broader genus B. | Copper : Metal | Hawk : Raptor | "Copper is a specific material classified under the general category of metals." |
| Tool to Worker (User) | Term A is a specialized instrument operated by professional B. | Scalpel : Surgeon | Trowel : Mason | "A scalpel is a specialized handheld instrument manipulated by a surgeon." |
| Tool to Object Acted Upon | Term A is an implement designed to alter, process, cut, or shape material B. | Saw : Wood | Chisel : Stone | "A saw is a tool that can cut wood." |
| Process to Result | A change leads to a named outcome. | Melting : Liquid | Freezing : Solid | "Melting changes a solid into a liquid." |
Directionality: The Non-Negotiable Constraint
Directionality is the absolute order of terms within an analogy. An analogy pair is a directed relationship vector (). The relationship must flow in the identical direction for both pairs.
Prompt Pair: [ TOOL ] ---------> [ WORKER ]
(Scalpel) (Surgeon)
Correct: [ TOOL ] ---------> [ WORKER ] (Valid Direction)
(Trowel) (Mason)
Distractor: [ WORKER ] ---------> [ TOOL ] (REVERSED DIRECTION - TRAP)
(Carpenter) (Hammer)
If the prompt pair establishes Tool : Worker, a choice that gives Worker : Tool is completely invalid, even if the two words share a real-world craft connection. When formulating your bridge, always track which term comes first:
- If reading left to right (), test every option left to right ().
- If you accidentally construct your bridge right to left (), you must consistently test every option right to left ().
- Name the role that comes first so you can check the order consistently.
Step-by-Step Worked Examples
Worked Example 1: Standard Proportional Form
Prompt: CHISEL : SCULPTOR ::
- Step 1: Formulate the bridge sentence.
- "A chisel is a handheld manual tool used by a sculptor to shape artwork." (Relationship: Tool to Worker).
- Step 2: Scan and test each option against the bridge.
- Option 1:
Trowel : Mason— "A trowel is a handheld manual tool used by a mason to lay brickwork." (Fits the exact grammatical and functional structure). - Option 2:
Painter : Brush— "A painter is a worker who uses a brush." (Inverts the directionality: Worker to Tool. Reject). - Option 3:
Chisel : Marble— "A chisel is used on marble." (Relationship: Tool to Object Acted Upon. Reject). - Option 4:
Lumber : Carpenter— "Lumber is raw material used by a carpenter." (Relationship: Material to Worker. Reject).
- Option 1:
- Conclusion:
Trowel : Masonis the only option preserving both relationship type and directionality.
Worked Example 2: Sentence Completion Form
Prompt: Stanza is to Poem as Chapter is to [?].
- Step 1: Formulate the bridge sentence.
- "A stanza is one of the units that can make up a poem." (Relationship: Part to Whole).
- Step 2: Apply the template to the target term.
- "A chapter is one of the units that can make up a [?]."
- Step 3: Evaluate prospective completions.
- Sentence: A sentence is a smaller sub-unit of a chapter, which would create a Whole to Part relationship. Reject.
- Author: An author is the creator, not the structural whole. Reject.
- Book: A book can be divided directly into chapters, just as a poem can be divided into stanzas.
- Library: A library is a collection of complete books, skipping a structural tier. Reject.
- Conclusion:
Bookcompletes the proportion cleanly.
Apply the same relation in both pairs
- Start with a short bridge. “Is an example of” describes classification, while “is part of” describes membership in a larger object or work.
- Compare term order. In a directional relation the same role must come first in both pairs. Some relationships, such as opposition, can be reversed without ending the opposition. More precise descriptions can still impose an order, such as scarcity followed by abundance.
- Read the chosen answer as a complete pair. Make sure it preserves the relationship that the other choices change. Grammatical roles can help you rule out choices, but a shared part of speech is only one clue.
In a pair such as scarce : plentiful, supply another pair that increases the amount from the first term to the second, such as sparse : abundant. Abundant : sparse names an opposition too, but the order of the change differs.
Which word pair best completes the analogy? BRUSH : PAINTER ::
Chisel : Sculptor
Author : Typewriter
Wrench : Pipe
Canvas : Easel
Which word pair best completes the analogy? STANZA : POEM ::
Novel : Chapter
Episode : Series
Lyric : Songwriter
Novel : Author
Which word pair best completes the analogy? MELTING : LIQUID ::
Ice : Cold
Friction : Lubricant
Freezing : Solid
Fuel : Engine
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.