5.3 Visual Analogies, Letter Rules and Pattern Completion
Key Takeaways
In a shape analogy, identify the rule and apply it to the next figure using the same orientation or marked reference.
Count a target position once when it has a qualifying immediate neighbour on either side.
Exclusive OR retains a feature present in exactly one input and removes features present in both.
Use completed rows or columns to check the rules the grid actually supplies.
Visual Pattern Completion & Matrix Sequence Reasoning
Apply a visual rule to a new shape
The historical CFAT practice booklet includes visual analogies and a letter adjacency count under Problem Solving. Infer a rule from the first pair and then apply it to the second. A rule can leave the size and positions of shape features intact while changing the orientation, or it can keep only a specified part of a divided shape.
Worked visual analogy. A square is divided by its diagonal from upper left to lower right. The image retains just the triangle on the upper-right side of the diagonal in its original orientation. Apply the same rule to a wider rectangle with its diagonal drawn from upper left to lower right. The image should contain the upper-left, upper-right and lower-right vertices, connected by the top edge, right edge and diagonal. The lower-left part shares the same diagonal, but it is on the other side. An uncut rectangle keeps both parts and fails the rule.
Use a labeled corner or edge to name the retained part. If instead the operation turns a shape, track two features through that turn before applying it to the next shape.
Count positions that meet a letter rule
A quick way to count an adjacency is to mark every target letter, then check its two immediate neighbours. For example, in the string B A B A C A B, count each A with B immediately before or after it. Keep the count by target position:
| Target A position | Immediate neighbours | Count it? |
|---|---|---|
| 2 | B and B | Yes, once |
| 4 | B and C | Yes, once |
| 6 | C and B | Yes, once |
The answer is three positions. Counting each adjacent pair of letters instead would give four pairs because the first A has neighbours on both sides. The wording tells you whether to count targets or pairs. For a target at the first or last position, check the one neighbour it has. Skip spaces only if the problem tells you how separators should be treated.
Extend the method to practice grids
A supplemental practice grid can ask for a missing arrangement based on a row rule, a column rule or both. Start with a completed example and check whether it predicts other completed examples before applying it to a blank cell. Some grids ask you to count symbols. Others ask you to combine features or move them around a frame.
Rules you can test
The following rules give you testable possibilities for a practice grid.
1. Arithmetic & Quantitative Progression
This rule governs the count, size, or numerical properties of elements across a sequence:
- Linear Increment / Decrement: Elements increase or decrease by a fixed constant (e.g., a central shape gains one side per step: Triangle [3] Square [4] Pentagon [5]).
- Row / Column Addition: The number of lines or symbols in Cell 1 plus Cell 2 equals the count in Cell 3 ().
- Constant Aggregate Sum: Every row or column maintains an identical total sum of components (e.g., each horizontal row contains exactly six black dots distributed across its three cells).
2. Progressive Angular Rotation
Elements rotate about a central origin or an eccentric pivot point by a consistent angular increment:
- Angular Step Values: Common increments are (one-eighth turn), (quarter turn), or (half turn / inversion).
- Directionality: Clockwise (CW) vs. Counter-Clockwise (CCW).
- Dual Component Rotation: One practice rule might specify that an outer container rotates clockwise by while an internal pointer rotates counter-clockwise by .
3. Color, Texture & Shading Alternation
Shading rules govern the fill patterns of geometric components:
- Cyclic Shading States: Components advance through a repeating three-phase cycle across cells: .
- Polarity Inversion (Negative Toggle): In successive steps, the foreground element and background field invert their shading values (e.g., black square with white circle white square with black circle).
- Permutation Distribution: In a grid, each row and each column contains exactly one white, one striped, and one solid black version of a shape, regardless of order.
4. Superposition and Boolean logic
Superposition problems present multi-line diagrams that merge or interact across cells. In this type of row, the first two cells each show a set of distinct segments in common positions. The third cell combines those sets according to the given or inferred rule:
- Boolean XOR (Exclusive OR / Cancellation): Lines or elements present in exactly one of the first two cells are retained in the third cell; any lines present in both cells overlap, cancel out, and completely disappear. Segments that cross but are not the same feature do not cancel.
- Boolean AND (Intersection): Only lines or symbols that appear in both Cell 1 and Cell 2 survive into Cell 3. All non-overlapping elements are eliminated.
- Boolean OR (Union / Simple Overlay): All elements from Cell 1 and Cell 2 are merged directly into Cell 3 with zero cancellations.
5. Spatial Movement & Geometric Translation
Elements navigate around a bounding container according to strict spatial trajectories:
- Perimeter Stepping: A dot or minor shape moves along the four edges or eight perimeter points (corners and midpoints) of an outer square, advancing 1, 2, or 3 positions per step.
- Diagonal Traversal: An element moves from corner to corner through the center point.
- Axis Reflection (Mirroring): The entire figure reflects across a horizontal, vertical or diagonal mirror line.
Transformation Rules Summary Table
| Transformation Rule | Operational Mechanic | Visual Clues / Triggers | Fast Verification Check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arithmetic Progression | Addition, subtraction, or constant totals of lines/shapes | Numbers of sides, dots, or crossbars change steadily | Count components in Cell 1, 2, and 3; check if or if . |
| Progressive Rotation | Consistent angular shifts around a pivot | Pointing elements, clock hands, off-center vertices | Track a single pointer tip: determine if it rotates , , or CW/CCW. |
| Shading Cycle | Predictable alternation between fill patterns | Shapes remain identical in geometry but change color | Track state transitions: check if White Striped Black or if each row has 1 of each fill. |
| Boolean XOR (Cancellation) | Identical overlapping lines eliminate each other | Line figures in Cell 3 have fewer lines than Cell 1 + Cell 2 | Identify lines present in both Cell 1 and Cell 2; verify that they vanish in Cell 3. |
| Spatial Translation | Tokens walking along perimeter, corners, or axes | Minor dots, stars, or tick marks shifting position | Number perimeter positions 1 to 8; verify whether token advances by , or steps. |
Check a proposed rule against the available rows
When a grid provides completed rows, use them to test whether a candidate rule gives the observed result. In a problem that also specifies a down-column relation, verify that condition separately. A row rule need not apply down the columns. In every case use only the relationships given or supported by the examples.
For a complicated drawing, isolate one feature at a time. Check whether the quantity, placement or orientation changed. Use all relevant features before selecting the best option.
Worked Step-by-Step Example
Problem Representation ( Grid)
Consider a matrix containing line segments inside a bounding square:
- Row 1:
- Cell (1,1): A vertical centerline and a horizontal crossbar (a complete '+' cross).
- Cell (1,2): A vertical centerline and a diagonal line from bottom-left to top-right.
- Cell (1,3): A horizontal crossbar and a diagonal line from bottom-left to top-right (no vertical centerline).
- Row 2:
- Cell (2,1): Only the bottom and left edges of the bounding square.
- Cell (2,2): Only the bottom and right edges of the bounding square.
- Cell (2,3): A left edge and a right edge (the bottom edge is absent).
- Row 3:
- Cell (3,1): An 'X' cross (two diagonal lines intersecting in the center) plus a top horizontal bar.
- Cell (3,2): The identical 'X' cross plus a bottom horizontal bar.
- Cell (3,3): [ ? ]
Step-by-Step Analytical Walkthrough
- Identify the Horizontal Rule (Row 1):
- In Cell (1,1) and Cell (1,2), the vertical centerline appears in both cells. In Cell (1,3), the vertical line is absent.
- The horizontal crossbar appears only in Cell (1,1) present in Cell (1,3).
- The diagonal slash appears only in Cell (1,2) present in Cell (1,3).
- Hypothesis: Boolean XOR (cancellation of overlapping segments).
- Verify on Row 2:
- The bottom edge appears in both (2,1) and (2,2) it cancels out and is absent in (2,3).
- The left edge appears only in (2,1) and the right edge appears only in (2,2) both are retained in (2,3).
- Conclusion: XOR explains this second completed row as well. Check whether it distinguishes the options in the target row.
- Apply to Target Cell (Row 3, Cell 3):
- Input 1 [Cell (3,1)]: 'X' cross + top horizontal bar.
- Input 2 [Cell (3,2)]: 'X' cross + bottom horizontal bar.
- The 'X' cross (both diagonal lines) appears in both input cells cancels out completely.
- The top horizontal bar appears only in Cell (3,1) retained.
- The bottom horizontal bar appears only in Cell (3,2) retained.
- Predicted Target Figure: Exactly two parallel horizontal lines (one at the top, one at the bottom), with no diagonal lines.
- Evaluate Options:
- Candidate with 'X' cross and parallel bars: Reject (failed to cancel overlapping 'X').
- Candidate with single top bar: Reject (omitted bottom bar).
- Candidate with two parallel horizontal bars (top and bottom): Correct Solution.
Select the result that matches the whole rule
Choose the option that matches each feature required by the pattern. In the line example, checking only that the X vanishes is insufficient. Both the top line and the bottom line must survive. In a letter question, verify that you counted target positions rather than neighbour pairs. These checks apply the same habit: identify the unit being transformed or counted before deciding.
In a 3×3 practice matrix problem, the first cell of a row contains a vertical line and a horizontal crossbar. The second cell contains the identical vertical line and a diagonal slash. The third cell contains only the horizontal crossbar and the diagonal slash. Which Boolean operational rule governs this row?
Boolean AND logic, retaining only elements present in both input cells
Boolean OR logic, combining every element from both input cells into the output cell
Boolean XOR (Exclusive OR) logic, retaining elements found in exactly one cell while eliminating identical overlapping elements
Progressive 90-degree counter-clockwise rotation of all component line segments
Across a practice row, the arrow goes from north to east to south. At the same time its fill goes from white to striped to solid black. Which repeating rule fits these illustrated steps?
45-degree counter-clockwise rotation with random color distribution
180-degree inversion while maintaining a constant white interior
90-degree counter-clockwise rotation with a two-state white-to-black toggle
90-degree clockwise rotation paired with a three-phase cycle of White to Striped to Solid Black
Two complete rows of a practice grid fit the same proposed rule. The problem gives no conditions for the columns. What is the next step?
Apply the row rule to the incomplete row and check the output against the choices
Reject the row rule unless the same rule always works down the columns
Assume every missing cell is blank
Use only the closest-looking answer choice
In a visual analogy, a square with a diagonal from lower left to upper right becomes just the triangle containing the upper-left corner, without turning it. A wide rectangle has the same diagonal orientation. Which part should remain?
The triangle below and to the right of the diagonal
Both triangles of the rectangle
The triangle with the top edge, left edge and diagonal
Only the diagonal segment
In the sequence T A T A N A R A T, how many A positions have T immediately before or after them? The spaces only separate letters.
Two
Three
Four
Five
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.