9.2 Work-Rate Calculations & Shared Labor Problems
Key Takeaways
At constant productivity, . Choose a unit of work that describes the whole job.
If a worker takes hours for the whole job at a steady pace, the rate is jobs per hour.
If both independent rates stay positive and constant, two contributors working throughout one job take hours.
Calculate each phase at its own rate when contributors join or leave.
For positive whole-number completion times expressed in the same unit, use a common multiple as the total work to make individual rates integers.
Work-Rate Calculations & Shared Labor Problems
The Work-Rate Foundation: Work = Rate × Time
At a constant productivity rate, the amount of completed work is rate multiplied by working time:
In this equation:
- represents the total quantity of work accomplished (such as erecting a field antenna, digging an anti-tank trench, or loading pallets).
- represents the rate of productivity (work completed per unit of time, such as jobs per hour).
- represents the duration of time spent working.
You can count the entire task as one job. If a worker takes hours to complete it alone at a steady rate, that rate is:
For example, if a mechanic can overhaul a diesel generator in 5 hours, the mechanic's rate is of the job per hour. If an engineer section digs a trench in 8 hours, their rate is of the trench per hour.
Cooperative Labor: The "Product over Sum" Shortcut
If two workers complete separate parts at the same positive constant rates as when alone, add the rates:
To find the time required for both workers to finish the single job together (), take the reciprocal of their combined rate:
Taking the reciprocal gives the two-worker formula:
Step-by-Step Application
Suppose specialist A takes 4 hours for a fleet inspection and specialist B takes 6 hours for the same fleet. They inspect different vehicles in the same fleet at their usual steady rates. How long do they take together in this model?
- Compute the product of their individual times: .
- Compute the sum of their individual times: .
- Divide the product by the sum: .
- Convert the decimal hour into minutes: .
- Final result: 2 hours and 24 minutes.
The Benchmark Sanity Check
With both workers contributing their usual positive rate throughout, the team finishes faster than either worker alone: The 2 hours and 24 minutes in the example is below 4 hours, as expected. When workers use the same limited equipment or one must wait for the other, their solo rates may no longer add.
Three or More Workers: The LCM Unit Method
With three contributors working throughout at unchanged, independent rates, add all three:
If the completion times are positive integers in the same time unit, a common multiple makes the rates whole numbers. The least common multiple keeps the numbers smaller:
- Identify the LCM: Find the lowest common multiple of the individual completion times. Define this value as the total "units of work" required to complete the job.
- Determine Individual Unit Rates: Divide the total units by each worker's individual time to obtain their integer rate in units per hour.
- Sum the Unit Rates: Add the individual rates together to find the team's combined hourly output.
- Calculate Total Time: Divide total work units by the combined hourly rate.
Worked Military Engineering Example
Three teams work on separate parts of a berm. Their rates stay constant and they do not duplicate work:
- Team 1 takes 6 hours alone.
- Team 2 takes 8 hours alone.
- Team 3 takes 12 hours alone.
Step 1: Choose the LCM of 6, 8, and 12. The LCM is 24. Let the entire berm project equal 24 units of work.
Step 2: Calculate individual hourly rates:
- Team 1 rate: .
- Team 2 rate: .
- Team 3 rate: .
Step 3: Combine hourly rates:
Step 4: Determine total time:
Filling and Draining a Tank
For a tank, use a constant inlet rate and a constant outlet rate, such as controlled flows from pumps. Set the full tank volume to one unit.
- Inlet pipes perform positive work: They add fluid to the tank ().
- Drainage pipes perform negative work: They remove fluid from the tank ().
When an inlet pipe and a drain valve operate simultaneously, the Net Rate is:
If the net rate is positive, the time required to fill the tank from empty is:
Vital Condition: For the tank to fill, the filling rate must exceed the drainage rate (), which means . If the net rate is zero or negative, an initially empty tank cannot reach full in this model. If the tank starts partially full and the net rate is positive, divide its remaining capacity by that rate.
Sequential and Staggered Work Sequences
When a worker joins or leaves partway through a job, compute the work in each time interval at that interval’s rate.
The Sequential Accounting Equation
If A works alone for while the job is still unfinished, then A and B finish together at unchanged rates over time , the completed fractions sum to one:
Worked Logistics Depot Example
A senior logistics technician can catalog a shipping container in 10 hours. An apprentice technician can catalog the container in 15 hours. The senior technician works alone for 4 hours. The apprentice then joins, and they catalogue separate items at their usual steady rates until the job is done. How many hours did the apprentice work?
- Senior technician's initial output: In 4 hours at a rate of per hour, the senior technician completes of the container.
- Remaining work: of the container remains.
- Combined productivity rate: container per hour.
- Time worked together ():
- Convert decimal: . The apprentice worked for 3 hours and 36 minutes.
Work-Rate Problem Types Summary
| Problem Type | Standard Setup | Calculation Shortcut | Primary Error to Avoid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Two Workers (Joint) | Rates , | Averaging times together () | |
| Three+ Workers | Rates | Common multiples for whole-number times | Adding complex fractions with large denominators |
| Inlet / Drain Tank | Tank starts empty, constant flows with | Subtract the drain rate | |
| Sequential Staggered | Phase 1 + Phase 2 | Solve remaining work fraction: | Applying combined rate to the entire job |
Checks to Use During Practice
- With two independent positive rates and no pauses, the combined time is less than the shorter solo time. If solo times are 6 and 8 hours, a joint time of 7 hours would violate that check.
- When only part of the job remains, divide the remaining work by the new rate.
- To report hours and minutes, multiply only the fractional part of the hour by 60. For example, 3.5 hours is 3 hours 30 minutes.
Two teams assemble different sections of one bridge. At their steady rates, Team A could assemble the whole bridge in 6 hours and Team B in 3 hours. They start together and their rates add. How long does the complete bridge take?
4 hours 30 minutes
3 hours
2 hours 15 minutes
2 hours
An inlet pump would fill an empty tank in 4 hours. An outlet pump would drain the full tank in 6 hours. Both pumps maintain their stated flow rates as the tank fills and the tank is initially empty. How long does it take to fill with both pumps running?
12 hours
10 hours
8 hours
24 hours
A crew can finish a batch of orders in 8 hours at its usual steady rate. After it works for 1 hour, a second crew joins and processes separate orders at its usual rate, enough to finish the whole batch in 12 hours alone. How many additional hours does the combined crew need?
3 hours 12 minutes
4 hours 12 minutes
4 hours 48 minutes
5 hours 36 minutes
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.