10.4 Opinion, Argument & Explanatory Writing
Key Takeaways
Introduce the issue, state a position and connect logically ordered reasons to it.
Use relevant evidence for a claim. Address a serious alternative fairly and show what the evidence can support.
Match the evidence to the discipline. Separate what a source records from what the writer infers.
Group explanatory details or order procedure steps. Use definitions, headings and labeled tables where they clarify meaning.
End with a conclusion that follows from what the draft established.
10.4 Opinion, Argument & Explanatory Writing
Quick Answer: An opinion piece states a position and links it to reasons. An argument also shows how evidence supports a precise claim and addresses serious alternatives. An explanatory piece helps readers understand a topic or process through relevant facts, definitions, examples and a clear order. Revise to serve the purpose of the draft before polishing individual sentences.
Write an Opinion With Reasons
Introduce the choice or issue so the reader knows what is being decided. State your position directly. Give reasons that bear on the decision, and use details to show why they matter. Because links a reason to a position. For example introduces a specific instance. Close by returning to the decision supported by those reasons.
Practice decision: A volunteer program needs an indoor meeting spot. In the materials for this exercise, Room A is beside the entrance and seats 16. Room B is on the second floor and seats 28. Twelve volunteers are expected.
I recommend Room A for the next volunteer meeting. It has enough seats for all twelve volunteers. It is also next to the entrance, so it will be easy to direct new visitors there. Room A meets the needs of this meeting.
The first sentence names the decision and states the opinion. The seating count and location support separate reasons. The final sentence returns to the choice. “Room A has blue walls” may be true in another prompt, but it does not address space or access. “Room A will always be the best” would exceed the facts about this meeting.
Develop an Argument Readers Can Test
A claim is the position you want readers to accept. A reason explains why they should accept it. Evidence gives readers something to examine. A counterclaim is a competing position. Introduce the positions clearly and organize the reasons and evidence around the audience’s decision. Support the competing position fairly before explaining why your claim still follows, or how it should be qualified.
Suppose the volunteer coordinator has two more records for the room decision: the registration list shows 12 sign-ups and an earlier open event drew 24. The exercise stipulates that Room A seats 16 and Room B seats 28. A colleague argues for Room B because it could accommodate unexpected guests. That reason is relevant. The earlier record shows that one event drew a larger group. It does not establish that a planned meeting with a sign-in list will have the same turnout.
Worked argument revision
Reserve Room A and ask the desk to hold Room B until the registration deadline. Room A seats the 12 registered volunteers and is next to the entrance. Reserving Room B in advance would provide more space. The previous open event drew 24 people, but it did not use the same registration procedure. Use the current count for the initial booking. Move to Room B if 17 to 28 people register. If more than 28 register, arrange a larger space.
In the practice material, both rooms are available and the desk can hold Room B through the registration deadline. The revised claim is specific and conditional. But signals a limitation on the comparison. The larger room’s advantage gets a fair hearing. The final step follows from the capacity evidence and anticipates late registrations. If the exercise did not establish that Room B can be held, the writer should ask about availability or state the recommendation as conditional on it. A good conclusion does not promise more than the evidence or arrangements support.
Make the Evidence Appropriate to the Subject
In a history argument, identify what each record can show and who produced it. Suppose a fictional archive contains an April meeting record approving a Saturday class and three dated sign-in sheets from May. The meeting record supports “the committee approved the class in April.” The sign-in sheets support “sessions took place on those three dates.” Neither by itself establishes why everyone attended. If a later memoir claims people mainly came for the schedule, that recollection can add a perspective. Its author may have known some attendees, but one recollection cannot establish everyone’s motive. An evidence-based argument can say attendance followed the approval while leaving the cause open.
In reports about a technical process, a controlled comparison or a dated measurement often answers a more precise question than an opinion. Identify who collected the evidence and what they measured. Explain the relationship between the evidence and the claim in the same paragraph or section.
Explain a Process or Result
Start by telling the reader what the explanation covers. Group related information and use headings or a table when readers need to locate steps or compare results. Define terms a newcomer may not know. In a procedure, give the necessary materials, actions and order. In a test report, distinguish the setup, what happened and what the observations permit you to conclude.
Practice records: A mock office tested two ways to find cards. Each participant looked for ten listed names in a shuffled set and ten in an alphabetized set of the same size. Two participants used the shuffled set first. Two used the alphabetized set first. The practice log reports four completed attempts per arrangement. The time listed is the mean time to find all ten names for that arrangement.
| Card arrangement | Completed attempts | Mean search time |
|---|---|---|
| Shuffled | 4 | 92 seconds |
| Alphabetized | 4 | 56 seconds |
Vague draft: “We tried two systems. The organized one was better and everyone should change.”
Explanatory revision
The office compared search times for shuffled and alphabetized cards. Each of four participants found ten listed names in each arrangement. The order varied across participants. The mean search time was 92 seconds for shuffled cards and 56 seconds for alphabetized cards. In this trial the difference was 36 seconds. The small trial describes these participants and this task. It does not establish the time saved in a larger office or include the time needed to sort the cards.
The introduction identifies what was measured. The middle gives repeatable details and uses the same unit for both conditions. The final sentences explain the difference and the limits of the report. “The organized one was better” was too vague. Its recommendation also changed the purpose from explaining the results to advocating a decision. A reader who needs to repeat the activity would need the actual list of names and the timing method as well.
Revise One Purpose at a Time
First decide whether the reader needs a recommendation or an explanation. For an argument, underline the claim and link each reason to evidence of the right kind. Check that competing views receive fair treatment and that the conclusion follows. For an explanation, test the sequence or grouping from the reader’s point of view. Add a missing definition, step, relevant fact or label as needed. Remove material that does not advance that purpose. Then check sentence boundaries, tone and exact word choice.
A workshop expects 18 participants and needs the room closest to the entrance that can seat them. North seats 14 and adjoins the entrance. West seats 22 and is the next closest. East seats 35 and is farthest away. Which opinion sentence gives a reason grounded in the facts?
We should choose North because it is closest and comfortably seats everyone.
We should choose West because it fits 18 participants and is the nearest room that can seat them.
We should choose East because it is closest to the entrance.
We should choose West because it seats more people than East.
A group wants to expand a room to seat children and adults. One contact estimates 40 additional guests at a special event. One year of attendance logs shows regular events rarely exceeded the current capacity. Which response to a proposal for permanent expansion fairly addresses the evidence?
The contact’s estimate proves every future event will exceed the room’s capacity.
The logs prove no special event will exceed capacity.
A special event may need extra space. Since regular events rarely exceeded the room’s capacity, a larger temporary venue may meet that need while the group gathers more evidence.
Ignore the estimate because projections can never inform a real decision.
In a fictional archive, a signed May 4 order schedules a workshop for June 2. A letter dated June 3 says the writer attended and describes the opening lesson. What is the strongest conclusion supported by these two records?
The order documents the scheduled date, and the letter supports that a workshop took place.
The workshop drew everyone who was invited.
The workshop was the town’s first and best-attended class.
The order alone establishes exactly what happened during the lesson.
A report needs a heading above a description of how staff compared two sorting methods before presenting the measured times. Which heading best previews that section?
Why Everyone Should Use the New Method
The Results and Their Long-Term Effects
Other Topics of Interest
How We Compared the Two Sorting Methods
A practice test records mean lookup times of 72 seconds with one layout and 60 seconds with another for the same six participants. Which closing sentence explains this result without overstating it?
The difference proves the new layout will always save exactly 12 seconds.
In this test, mean lookup time was 12 seconds shorter with the second layout. More trials would help establish whether the difference persists.
The second layout should be mandatory at every office regardless of cost.
The test found times of 72 and 60 seconds, which are equivalent after rounding.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.
You've completed this section
Continue exploring other exams