2.2 Drawing Inferences & Citing Textual Evidence
Key Takeaways
A supported inference connects a stated clue to a conclusion the passage leaves implicit.
Distinguish what the passage reports from what you infer or what an author merely predicts.
In an evidence-based selected-response pair, check that the selected evidence supports the specific first answer.
Use several details when the conclusion depends on their combination. Keep conclusions within the scope of the evidence.
Read what the passage states and what it supports
An explicit detail is stated in the passage. An inference is a conclusion a reader draws by connecting one or more clues. A good inference can be the best-supported explanation even when the passage leaves open other possibilities. A guess fills a gap without adequate support. The wording of a question matters: according to the notice calls for what it says, while what does this suggest? asks how to interpret it.
| Task | What to look for | Example question |
|---|---|---|
| Retrieve a detail | A sentence, list or label that answers the question directly | When does registration close? |
| Draw an inference | Clues that fit together and support an unstated conclusion | Why might the organizer have added a second meeting time? |
| Cite evidence | The words that support the exact answer | Which sentence best supports the conclusion about meeting times? |
Work through a fictional notice
Last month the center offered one registration session during working hours. Several people said they wanted to enroll but could not attend at that time. Next month the center will hold a morning session and another session after 6 p.m. Both sessions will have the same number of places.
What the notice states: Next month there will be two sessions, including one after 6 p.m. Both will have the same number of places. You can point to the last two sentences.
What the notice supports: The new schedule appears intended to give people who work during the day a chance to register. The complaints about missing the earlier session and the addition of a later session support this inference together. The notice leaves open other reasons, and it gives no outcome because the sessions have yet to happen. “Everyone who wants to enroll will get a place” would go beyond the evidence.
When a question asks why, check whether the passage explicitly gives a reason. In this example, the organizer gives no stated motive. The clues make one motive reasonable. In another passage, a sentence starting “We added a session because...” might give the reason outright. The same question word can call for either kind of reading.
Select evidence that supports the exact inference
DRC's TABE 13 & 14 sample items include pairs where an answer to one question is supported by evidence selected in the next. Some pairs ask for a main idea, while others ask for another interpretation. Follow the directions in front of you. Practice connecting both answers even when the two prompts appear separately. DRC Reading sample items by level
- Read the first question and identify the relationship it asks about. A conclusion about why someone acted needs evidence of motive or a link between a problem and a response.
- Make a tentative answer in your own words. Check it against the whole relevant part of the passage.
- Read the evidence choices in context. A quote that uses the same vocabulary can still support a different conclusion.
- Check that the two answers work together. If none of the choices supports your proposed answer, reconsider it using the passage.
Worked pair from a fictional story
Rina had signed up to read the opening announcement. When the microphone stopped working, she could hear people in the back rows asking what the speaker had said. She took a copy of the announcement to the back of the room and read it aloud there before returning to her seat.
First question: What most likely motivated Rina to move? She wanted the people in the back rows to hear the announcement. The event that helps explain her choice is that they could not follow what was said.
Evidence question: Which detail best supports your answer? The people in the back rows asked what the speaker had said. Her original signup explains why she had the announcement, but it does little to explain the change in where she read it. Her return to her seat describes what happened after she helped. The audience’s questions supply the strongest clue about her immediate motive.
A longer inference can depend on several clues. If asked how the broken microphone changed Rina's plan, use both the equipment failure and her decision to read at the back. Together the clues explain the change better than either clue alone.
Check how far the evidence goes
In a fictional class survey, most students who borrowed a practice booklet completed the first lesson. This establishes what was reported about those borrowers. The number does not show that borrowing a booklet caused anyone to finish. Students already planning to finish may have been more likely to borrow one.
Words such as reports, suggests and expects help identify how the writer frames a statement. Check what was actually counted, seen or recorded. If a text states only that a manager expects attendance to rise, report the expectation as an expectation. If the author presents observations from one class, a conclusion about every class requires more evidence.
Check whether a proposed inference answers the exact question, rests on a clue and stays within the group, period and event described. Cite the line or lines that do the work. Adult Education College and Career Readiness Standards, Reading Anchor 1
Read this fictional staff memo.
The repair service switched to online booking. Staff spent less time answering routine calls, but customers often needed help completing the new form. Rather than cut staff hours, the service assigned two former phone schedulers to help customers use the form.
What can you reasonably infer about the switch to online booking at this service?
The service cut all reception shifts.
The switch changed some staff duties without cutting hours at the time described.
The form was easier for every customer to use.
The service stopped taking bookings altogether.
Read this fictional staff memo.
The repair service switched to online booking. Staff spent less time answering routine calls, but customers often needed help completing the new form. Rather than cut staff hours, the service assigned two former phone schedulers to help customers use the form.
Which sentence most directly supports the inference that some staff duties changed without cutting hours?
Rather than cut staff hours, the service assigned two former phone schedulers to help customers use the form.
The repair service switched to online booking.
Staff spent less time answering routine calls, but customers often needed help completing the new form.
All employees wanted to learn the new form.
Read this fictional library update.
The library put a returns bin beside the entrance on Monday. On Tuesday, 46 books were returned, compared with 29 on the previous Tuesday. The librarian said she would collect several more weeks of data before drawing a conclusion.
Which statement is directly supported by the update?
The returns bin caused the increase.
Returns will rise every Tuesday.
The new bin drew 46 different visitors.
More books were returned on the second Tuesday than on the first.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.