3.4 Evaluating Arguments, Claims & Comparing Multiple Texts
Key Takeaways
A claim states a point, a reason explains it, and evidence supplies details to support the reason.
Check the relevance, sufficiency, accuracy and credibility of evidence for the particular claim.
Compare what prose and graphics each tell you. Keep your conclusion within their shared scope.
When comparing sources, identify whether they complement one another or disagree on facts, interpretation or purpose.
Evaluating Arguments, Claims & Comparing Multiple Texts
The TABE Reading blueprints include Integration of Knowledge and Ideas at Levels E through A. Practice identifying which reason supports a specific point, deciding whether a claim has enough support, and combining information from different texts or formats.
Identify the claim, reasons and evidence
A claim is what a writer wants readers to accept. A reason explains why the writer thinks it is true or worth doing. Evidence supplies details that support a reason. In a longer argument, a writer may also address an alternative view or objection, which is a counterclaim. A response can rebut the objection, acknowledge a limitation or narrow the original proposal.
Consider a fictional workplace proposal. The writer recommends keeping the training desk open later on Thursdays. The reason is that some people cannot arrive before it closes. The writer cites appointment requests showing that twelve people asked for a later time in the past month. A colleague objects that staffing every evening would cost too much. The writer proposes trying one evening a week for a month and monitoring demand and cost. The evidence supports a limited trial more directly than a permanent expansion to every evening.
When evaluating a text, match each piece of evidence to the claim it actually supports. A writer can make a reasonable short argument without presenting a counterclaim. When the writer does answer one, read the answer to see whether it meets the objection.
Evaluating Evidence: The RSAC Framework
Not all printed evidence is equally convincing. When evaluating an author's argument on the TABE, apply the RSAC framework to determine whether the evidence is sound:
1. Relevance
Does the evidence have a direct, logical bearing on the specific claim being made? Irrelevant evidence introduces tangents, emotional appeals, or unrelated facts that distract from the core thesis.
- Flawed Example: Arguing that a manufacturing plant produces high-quality engines by citing the fact that the plant cafeteria serves organic food.
2. Sufficiency
Has the author provided enough evidence of adequate scope to substantiate the claim, or is the conclusion resting on a solitary example or narrow circumstance?
- Flawed Example: Claiming that a regional job training program has failed completely because one graduate struggled to find immediate employment.
3. Accuracy
Is the information factual, verifiable, up to date, and presented without distortion? Watch for misleading percentages that conceal minuscule baseline sample sizes.
- Flawed Example: Proclaiming a "100% surge in customer dissatisfaction" when recorded complaints increased from 1 to 2 in a pool of 10,000 customers. The complaint count did double, but complaints do not measure everyone’s satisfaction.
4. Credibility
Did the source have relevant knowledge or a way to observe the events? Check its method, possible interests and any independent confirmation. A conflict is a reason for closer scrutiny.
- Flawed Example: Citing a study funded exclusively by a sugar-sweetened beverage conglomerate to prove that soda consumption has no link to dental decay.
| Evidence Type | Primary Strength | Common Vulnerability | Evaluation Standard on TABE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Empirical Statistics | Quantifiable, objective, measurable | Misleading baselines, correlation vs. causation | Verify sample size and context |
| Expert Testimony | High authority from specialized training | Potential bias, out-of-field commentary | Check relevant professional credentials |
| Case Studies | In-depth operational context | May not be generalizable to broader industry | Assess whether situation is representative |
| Anecdotal Accounts | Human interest, relatable, illustrative | Statistically unrepresentative, easily cherry-picked | Distinguish evidence about one case from evidence for a general claim |
Recognize common errors in reasoning
A fallacy is an error in reasoning. Explain the specific gap between a claim and its support. A conclusion may still be true even when the writer gives a poor reason for believing it:
- Hasty Generalization: Drawing a sweeping conclusion about an entire group, process, or system based on an inadequate, unrepresentative sample size (e.g., "I spoke to two solar technicians who disliked the new inverter model; clearly, the entire solar industry has rejected this technology.").
- Ad Hominem (Personal Attack): Attacking the personal character, background, or perceived motives of an opponent rather than addressing the substance of their argument (e.g., "We should disregard the safety inspector's report regarding toxic air levels because she was once disciplined for being late to work.").
- False Dilemma (False Dichotomy / Either-Or): Presenting a complex, multifaceted situation as if only two extreme, mutually exclusive options exist, ignoring viable middle grounds (e.g., "Either we completely eliminate all zoning restrictions tonight, or our town will suffer total economic collapse by winter.").
- Slippery Slope: Claiming without evidentiary proof that an initial, relatively modest step will inevitably trigger a catastrophic chain of events (e.g., "If we permit warehouse workers to take five-minute hydration breaks during heatwaves, productivity will evaporate, shipments will cease, and the corporation will go bankrupt.").
- Post Hoc Ergo Propter Hoc (False Cause): Confusing chronological sequence with causal connection; asserting that because Event B occurred after Event A, Event A must have caused Event B (e.g., "The city installed LED streetlights in March, and local vehicle accidents increased in April; therefore, LED streetlights cause traffic crashes.").
- Bandwagon Appeal (Ad Populum): Arguing that an idea, policy, or practice must be correct simply because it is popular or widely practiced (e.g., "Every major retailer is automating customer service chat, so our healthcare clinic must eliminate telephone receptionists immediately.").
Integrating Visual and Quantitative Data with Text
A passage can accompany a chart, map, diagram or table. At Levels E through A, the DRC blueprints include using information from other formats or sources. Read each visual alongside the relevant words:
- Read the Graphical Elements First: Examine the title, axes labels, unit measurements (e.g., thousands of dollars, metric tons, percentages), and the legend/key.
- Identify Extremes and Outliers: Pinpoint the highest value, lowest value, sharpest turning point, or plateau.
- Cross-Reference Against Written Claims: Determine whether the author's prose accurately reflects the graphic's data. Common discrepancy patterns include:
- Overstatement: The text claims a "skyrocketing increase," but the chart shows a modest 1.2% rise.
- Correlation vs. Causation: The chart shows two variables rising together (e.g., ice cream sales and sunburns), but the author improperly asserts that one caused the other.
- Unjustified Extrapolation: The chart displays data from 2018 to 2022, but the author claims the trend will continue uninterrupted through 2035.
Synthesizing Multiple Texts on the Same Subject
When evaluating two passages presenting contrasting views on the same topic:
- Do not look merely for who "won" the debate. Instead, analyze how each author built their case.
- Examine Underlying Assumptions: Two authors can look at the exact same statistical data and arrive at opposite policy recommendations because they hold different core priorities (e.g., prioritizing immediate fiscal conservation vs. long-term public health infrastructure).
- Check for Complementary Information: Sometimes two texts do not directly contradict each other; instead, Passage 1 explores technical feasibility while Passage 2 examines economic funding. Synthesizing requires integrating both dimensions to form a comprehensive understanding.
Worked example: pair a report with a visual
In a fictional training center, the coordinator added one evening section in April. The report says the March and April figures count completed registrations across all sections. The chart below shows 36 in March and 48 in April.
The report lets you interpret what each bar counts. The chart adds quantities: registrations increased by 12. Neither source shows how many of the 48 registered for the evening section. The fact that the overall count increased after the addition supports a time sequence. To credit the new time for the entire difference, you would need evidence such as enrollment by section and information about what else changed between the months.
Suppose a second source, the course schedule, says the evening section met on Thursdays. The schedule can answer when the section met. The chart cannot. When working with several sources, start with the question, find each part of the answer where it is documented, and check that you are combining the same dates or groups.
Level A: analyze foundational U.S. documents
The Level A Reading blueprint includes analyzing foundational documents for themes, purposes and rhetorical features. Compare the Declaration of Independence and the Preamble to the Constitution.
| Text | Purpose and shared theme | Rhetorical feature to trace |
|---|---|---|
| Declaration of Independence | Justifies the colonies’ separation. It links legitimate government to the consent of the governed and the protection of rights. | It establishes principles about government, then presents grievances to support its case. That order helps readers connect reasons to the decision to separate. |
| Preamble to the Constitution | Announces the establishment of the Constitution and explains goals for the new framework. Its goals include justice and preserving liberty. | “We the People” names the collective speaker. The series of purpose phrases connects that voice to the act of establishing the Constitution. |
Both texts discuss liberty and the source or purpose of public authority. Look at what each text is doing with those ideas. The Declaration gives reasons for separation. The Preamble sets out purposes for establishing a framework of government.
Apply the same comparison to the Bill of Rights and Lincoln’s Second Inaugural Address. For example, the First Amendment states limits on what Congress may do with respect to religion, speech, the press, assembly and petition. Lincoln’s closing uses parallel phrases to urge reconciliation as the Civil War neared its end. The role of a legal limit in an amendment differs from the role of an appeal to an audience in a speech. When a question names a particular excerpt, ground your answer in that excerpt. DRC Level A Reading blueprint
Read this fictional proposal. “One learner told me the weekend course helped her finish the program. Her experience proves that adding weekend classes will make every learner graduate.” Which evaluation is best supported?
No learner could ever benefit from a weekend class.
One successful case is relevant, but it cannot support a conclusion about every learner.
The statement attacks the learner’s character.
The statement is sound because it uses a first-person account.
Read this fictional statement. “Either we buy the costly scheduling system this month, or nobody will ever be able to register.” What is the clearest flaw in its reasoning?
It relies on population averages.
It criticizes a staff member’s character.
It presents two outcomes as the only possibilities without considering alternatives.
It relies on the scheduling system’s popularity.
A fictional service report says the new Saturday window will be busiest before noon. Use the report and these counts:
| Window | Appointments completed |
|---|---|
| 8 a.m. to noon | 18 |
| Noon to 4 p.m. | 29 |
What does comparing the report and the table show?
The service processed 29 appointments before noon.
The early window was busiest, as predicted.
Changing the length of the window caused a difference in appointments.
The actual count is higher after noon, contrary to the report’s prediction.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.