State Examinations, Complaints, and Records

Key Takeaways

  • A routine examination and a complaint investigation can each call for records and interviews under applicable authority.

  • Preserve and produce requested material through the designated process. Establish the retention clock for each category of record.

  • A license action, civil penalty and corrective order have distinct purposes. Apply the enacted state's authority to the facts.

Last updated: November 2026

Identify the purpose and scope of the request

The government may examine a licensee's practices from a sample of files or investigate a complaint about a particular transaction. Under Regulation H, a state supervisory authority must have the means to examine relevant data, summon people who have records, require production and take testimony. It must examine or investigate licensees in a systematic manner, either on a schedule or based on risk factors. This authority operates independently of annual renewal. The original CSBS/AARMR template includes expanded examination and interview language for states needing additional statutory authority. Use the actual state's law to determine how that authority applies.

A records request can include information maintained by a vendor or another custodian. For example, a state examiner reviewing a broker's disclosures may request copies of the delivered documents, the delivery evidence, communications about changed terms and the company procedures the originator relied on. Identify each requested category and locate any related records in the ordinary systems used for the loan. If the examination includes an interview, answer questions from the actual file and personal knowledge. Refer technical or legal questions to the appropriate company representative when needed. A summary of the company's policy does not establish whether staff followed it in the file under review.

Respond to a complaint with original evidence

Imagine a borrower claims they were charged for an appraisal before receiving the Loan Estimate. The company should preserve the initial application timestamps, the estimate and its delivery and receipt evidence, the recorded intent to proceed, payment authorization, invoice and any communications about the appraisal. Check when the consumer was required to supply a payment method or incurred the charge. That timing can matter even when the amount posted to the card later. Gather the materials and reconcile dates before responding. If the first review finds a potential violation, escalate it and document the correction or other disposition through established procedures.

Provide the requested records to the regulator using the specified channel and meet the applicable deadline. Keep a record of which files you produced and identify genuine gaps or discrepancies. If a third party holds a requested record, promptly follow up through the company and explain the status as appropriate. Preserve the source materials and any later correction. Recreating a backdated email or changing the original application would destroy the chronology needed to evaluate the complaint. If you need to explain a missing confirmation, preserve the underlying record and date any explanation when you actually create it. The model expressly prohibits knowing concealment or destruction of records subject to examination. State rules can carry similar prohibitions and their own sanctions.

Use the clock tied to the record

Map the actor, record, authority and start date before deciding when records can be discarded. For example, Florida § 494.0016 generally requires a licensee to preserve covered books and records for at least three years after original entry. That includes such records as borrower-signed closing statements and receipts for expenses paid by the licensee on the borrower's behalf. Covered Florida advertising samples have a separately specified two-year clock after publication or broadcast. Regulation Z generally requires a covered creditor to retain each required completed Closing Disclosure and related documents for five years from consummation. A file can contain records subject to more than one requirement. If an active investigation or preservation obligation applies, address that duty before disposal even when an ordinary retention period has run.

Distinguish correction from discipline

The state can have authority to order a person to stop a violation, suspend or terminate a license, refuse renewal or impose a civil money penalty in an appropriate case. Regulation H sets a minimum range of powers. The model and enacted laws specify different procedures and penalty amounts. An assessment can give you a model-law scenario or a named state's statute. Check that source before choosing the remedy or deciding whether several omissions constitute separate violations. Where an overcharge is established, a refund can address the monetary error and documented changes in controls can address recurrence. Corrective action does not itself decide whether the regulator will take formal action. The licensee should be able to show what was changed and when.

Official Sources

Test Your Knowledge

A state examiner asks for the original documents and timestamps for a complaint about an early appraisal charge. Which response best supports the inquiry?

A

Send only the company's generic fee policy.

B

Ask the borrower to recreate a dated consent email.

C

Preserve and provide the requested file, receipt and payment authorization evidence through the examiner's process.

D

Send only the date the card charge settled.

Test Your Knowledge

A state authorizes an examiner to inspect a mortgage licensee's file and summon a relevant custodian. The exam happens months before renewal. Which statement fits Regulation H?

A

A state supervisory authority needs these powers independently of the renewal calendar.

B

Only the NMLS registry can obtain information before renewal.

C

An examiner may review only files voluntarily identified by a licensee.

D

A renewal filed on time suspends examination powers.

Test Your Knowledge

A creditor in a covered transaction has a completed Closing Disclosure and the related documents. What does Regulation Z generally require of the creditor?

A

Keep them for two years from publication.

B

Keep them for three years from the first application item.

C

Keep only the note and discard the disclosures after funding.

D

Keep the completed disclosures and related documents for five years from consummation.

Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.