Loan Originator Pay and Steering
Key Takeaways
Review each pay factor for a transaction term or a proxy. A consistent percentage of principal with a fixed floor or cap can qualify.
Trace the source of compensation before deciding whether paying the broker and its individual originator is allowed.
A higher-paying loan recommendation calls for a consumer-interest analysis. The steering safe harbor has specific option and creditor requirements.
Identify the transaction and the pay recipient
The compensation and steering rules in Regulation Z § 1026.36(d) and (e) apply to covered closed-end consumer credit secured by a dwelling. The dwelling need not be the consumer's principal home. Home equity lines of credit and transactions secured by a consumer's interest in certain timeshare plans are outside these provisions. The loan originator can be an individual or a loan originator organization. Think separately about the organization that receives a payment and the person who worked on the loan.
Compensation can include a salary, commission or a financial incentive. Test the factor that determines the amount. Paying based on the loan's interest rate, a prepayment clause or product features rewards the originator for particular contractual rights or obligations. A compensation plan that pays more for a 7% note than for an otherwise identical 6.5% note bases compensation on a loan term. A consumer's preference for the 7% transaction does not cure the pay plan.
Test a factor and calculate permitted percentage pay
A proxy requires two findings. The factor must consistently vary with a transaction term over a significant number of transactions, and the originator must have the ability to change the factor directly or indirectly during origination. Suppose a creditor normally keeps short-term loans in portfolio and sells otherwise similar longer-term loans, and pays an originator more for deals kept in portfolio. If the originator can affect the result by influencing the loan term, the portfolio pay factor can be a proxy. Gather facts about both correlation and control before deciding that an operational label is permissible.
The loan amount is treated separately. A fixed percentage of the amount of credit extended may be used with a fixed minimum or maximum dollar amount. Consider a plan paying 1% of principal, with a $1,000 minimum and $2,500 maximum, applied consistently:
| Principal | Percentage amount | Pay after the fixed boundaries |
|---|---|---|
| $80,000 | $800 | $1,000 |
| $200,000 | $2,000 | $2,000 |
| $300,000 | $3,000 | $2,500 |
The same stated percentage operates throughout. An increasing or decreasing commission percentage based on loan size does not fit the fixed-percentage allowance. Neither does a stated percentage supplemented by a bonus triggered by a higher borrower rate.
Follow the funds
When the consumer directly pays compensation to a loan originator, another person generally cannot pay loan originator compensation for the same transaction. That includes a lender paying the consumer's broker on top of the broker fee. Payment to a broker out of the consumer's loan proceeds is treated as direct consumer payment. The official interpretation also looks through a noncreditor's payment from consumer funds or on the consumer's behalf under an agreement with the consumer. Read the actual source and role of each payment.
A consumer-paid loan originator organization may compensate its individual originator under the regulatory exception, subject to the term/proxy restrictions. The borrower can therefore pay the brokerage and the brokerage can pay the employee for the origination. In contrast, it would create prohibited dual compensation if the brokerage also received originator compensation from the creditor on that same consumer-paid deal. A separate fee the consumer pays to the creditor for its own services and a creditor credit applied to other costs require their own analysis. Determine who is compensating the originator before classifying those entries.
Evaluate a recommendation
Steering occurs when the originator advises or otherwise influences a consumer to consummate a transaction on particular terms because the originator will receive greater compensation from that creditor than in other transactions the originator offered or could have offered, unless the transaction is in the consumer's interest. Ask what the consumer can qualify for, how fees and terms fit stated needs and how any greater compensation influenced the recommendation. For example, a borrower expecting to move in three years may prefer a higher rate with materially lower upfront costs. Document the cost comparison and expected holding period along with features that can change the result.
The rule provides an optional safe harbor. For each type of transaction the consumer expresses interest in, review offers from a significant number of creditors with which the originator regularly does business, ordinarily at least three or all if fewer than three. Present qualifying choices representing the lowest interest rate, the lowest total dollar amount of discount points and origination points or fees (use the lowest rate in a tie), and the lowest rate without the features listed in the rule. For a forward mortgage those features include negative amortization, prepayment penalties, interest-only payments, a balloon in the first seven years, a demand feature, shared equity and shared appreciation. The rule lists a separate group of features for reverse mortgages. One offer can satisfy more than one category. Have a good-faith belief the consumer likely qualifies. If displaying more than three offers for a type, highlight the qualifying choices. An originator also can evaluate consumer interest on the facts when the safe harbor does not apply.
Official Sources
Two loans have the same principal and differ in rate. A compensation plan pays the originator a higher fee when the consumer chooses the higher rate. Which conclusion follows?
The plan is permissible if the fee is disclosed.
The plan is permissible if principal remains fixed.
The plan bases pay on a term of the transaction.
The higher fee is permissible as long as the creditor pays it.
A consumer pays a brokerage directly. The brokerage pays its own employee a compliant fixed commission for originating the loan. The creditor proposes a separate commission to the brokerage for the same file. Which payments may remain?
The consumer-to-broker payment and the brokerage-to-employee compensation.
The consumer-to-broker payment and the creditor's commission to the brokerage.
Only the employee's compensation paid directly by the creditor.
All three payments if the consumer signs an authorization.
A compliant plan pays a uniform 1% of principal with a fixed $1,000 floor and fixed $2,500 cap. How much does it pay on a $285,000 loan?
$1,000.
$2,500.
$2,850.
$3,850.
A broker regularly does business with five creditors and wants to rely on the § 1026.36(e) steering safe harbor. Which offer review fits that objective?
Use the two highest-paying creditors if the consumer can qualify.
Pick any three offers with the same rate from one creditor.
Obtain one low-rate offer and disclose the broker's pay.
Obtain and review options from at least three of the five and present the specified categories for which the borrower likely qualifies.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.