Predatory Lending Risks and Loan Steering
Key Takeaways
Use the borrower's circumstances and likely eligibility when comparing payment, rate, settlement cost and long-term risk.
A compensation difference makes the reason for directing the consumer to a transaction significant under the covered steering rule.
Apply the conditions for the optional safe harbor separately from the substantive prohibition.
Start with what the consumer can and wants to do
A borrower may need lower cash at closing, stable payments, a certain term or time to sell a prior home. Compare available products at comparable loan amounts and realistic qualification assumptions. Show how a lender credit, financed charge, adjustable rate, interest-only period or other applicable feature changes cost or risk. Identify qualified alternatives before recommending a product. A lower initial payment may be appropriate for a specific need. Explain the factors that could raise it, increase the balance or result in a large payment later.
Predatory lending describes harmful practices that exploit the consumer or the terms of credit. When an exam problem uses that term, identify the actual facts and potentially applicable law. Examples include repeated refinancing that generates fees without a documented consumer purpose, concealing how long a low payment lasts or pressuring a borrower to accept an unaffordable credit obligation. Check ability-to-repay for covered loans, the high-cost loan rules where applicable and consumer protection rules on actual statements and conduct. Identify the triggering terms and evidence before deciding how the rule applies. A product's high price alone does not establish every legal element.
Analyze the direction and the compensation
In a transaction within § 1026.36(e), a loan originator cannot direct or steer the consumer to consummate a transaction because the originator will receive more compensation from the creditor than in other transactions the originator offered or could have offered, unless the consummated transaction is in the consumer's interest. The rule and commentary focus on advice or influence and alternatives for which the consumer likely qualifies. The commentary explains how the rule applies when the consumer actually consummates. Review compensation design independently under § 1026.36(d).
Suppose an interested and likely eligible borrower seeks a 30-year fixed loan and can pay $2,000 toward costs. For the same amount, assume one lender offers 6.25% with $2,000 in total points and origination fees. Another offers 6.60% with $2,000 in those same categories. All other material features and costs are identical. The second creditor pays the broker more. Directing the borrower to the second loan because of that compensation, then closing it, raises the steering issue on these facts. If the two options instead differ in cash required or timing, document the consumer's need, compare the differences and determine how those facts affect the consumer-interest analysis.
Check the optional safe harbor on its own terms
To use the loan-option safe harbor, obtain options from a significant number of creditors with which the originator regularly does business. The commentary identifies three or more, or all if the originator regularly does business with fewer than three. Present qualifying options for each type of interest the consumer expressed: a loan with an APR that cannot increase after consummation, one whose APR may increase, or a reverse mortgage. The following criteria apply to the forward mortgage choices. To compare rates, the commentary generally uses the initial rate if it is fixed for five years or more. For an index-based loan with a shorter initial period, it uses the fully indexed rate at consummation without the introductory discount or premium.
| Option criterion | What to compare |
|---|---|
| Lowest interest rate | The rate among the applicable offers. |
| Lowest total dollar amount of discount points, origination points or origination fees | Compare the sum of those charges. In a tie, select the loan with the lowest interest rate among the tied offers. |
| Lowest rate without the listed risk features | Exclude options with negative amortization, a prepayment penalty, interest-only payments, a balloon in the first seven years, a demand feature, shared equity or shared appreciation. |
A suitable option can satisfy more than one criterion. Pay attention to the likely qualification judgment and any requirement to highlight the qualifying options if more than three are presented for a type of transaction. The rule specifies separate treatment for reverse-mortgage options. Check actual offers and apply all of the conditions when relying on a safe harbor. Even outside the safe harbor, review whether direction was compensation-driven and whether the consummated transaction was in the consumer's interest. Keep the quotes, comparison date and reasons that support the recommendation. The record helps show what the borrower could actually obtain, which options were discussed and how those options addressed the borrower's priorities.
Official Sources
A borrower consummates a covered loan after a broker directs them to a higher-rate option solely because the creditor pays the broker more. An equally available lower-rate option has identical costs and features, and the borrower likely qualifies. What is the relevant concern?
The compensation-based direction implicates the covered steering prohibition
The borrower must have made a title referral
A fixed-rate product is always immune from steering
A signed CD by itself resolves the issue
Which cost comparison belongs in the loan-option safe harbor under § 1026.36(e)(3)?
Highest amount financed at closing
Lowest total dollar amount of the specified discount points, origination points or origination fees
Lowest valuation fee as the only option
Largest lender-paid commission available
An originator regularly does business with two creditors and wants to use the option-presentation safe harbor. Which review sources meet the significant-number interpretation?
The creditor with the higher compensation only
One of the two and a former unrelated employer
Both creditors with which the originator regularly does business
None if the consumer accepts the first price quote
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.