Referral Payments, Earned Fees, and Fee Changes
Key Takeaways
For a covered settlement referral, trace the benefit, agreement and activity that influenced provider selection.
Substantiate compensation for actual services, including the amount and what the recipient did.
Review a fee's permissibility, compensation rules and the variation permitted on the consumer's disclosure as separate decisions.
Follow the benefit and what prompts it
RESPA Section 8 and Regulation X apply to settlement services involving federally related mortgage loans within their scope. Section 8(a) prohibits giving or accepting a thing of value pursuant to an agreement or understanding to refer covered settlement business. A thing of value can include sponsorships, gifts or services. A referral can include conduct that affirmatively influences a person's selection of a provider when the person will pay or have a charge attributable to the service. The parties can show an understanding through conduct or a pattern of payments as well as a signed agreement. Trace when the benefit was given and what the recipient was expected to do.
For example, a title company offers an originator event tickets for every three borrowers sent to it. Record the benefit, the repeated referral condition and the settlement role. Even an inexpensive reward can raise the issue when exchanged for referrals. The regulation recognizes normal promotional and educational activity if it is not conditioned on referrals and does not defray expenses the referral source otherwise would incur. To assess that provision, check both conditions using the actual event records. The name attached to a program does not decide coverage.
Identify actual service and value
Section 8(b) regulates splitting a charge for a covered settlement service except for services actually performed. When two parties share a charge, identify which service each performed. For a single provider's high charge with no split, price alone does not establish an unearned split under § 8(b). Other disclosure, program or pricing rules can still apply. For example, if the firm kept the whole amount but included a charge without a valid disclosure basis, send the file for the applicable consumer-disclosure review even though the split element is absent. A fee or salary paid for services actually performed, goods actually furnished or facilities actually provided can fall within a permitted category. Evaluate the recipient's work and whether the amount reasonably relates to its market value. A referral's value cannot be included in deciding what the actual work is worth.
Suppose a title company pays an unrelated publisher $600 per month for three genuine ads. Comparable unrelated arrangements support that price and the payment carries no referral condition. Verify the agreement, placements, invoices and price comparisons before treating payment as compensation for advertising. Now suppose the company pays an additional $300 each month when a stated number of loan files reach it. The $300 has a referral condition. Real ads in the same arrangement do not establish a distinct service supporting that bonus. An invoice that says “marketing” cannot supply work that did not occur.
The affiliated business rule can protect an arrangement that meets specified disclosure, required-use and value conditions. An ownership disclosure by itself provides no authority to share a settlement charge without work. If a recipient is a loan originator, also review Regulation Z's independent restrictions on transaction terms, prohibited proxies and compensation sources. Confirm who actually paid and what controls the amount. For example, a higher commission tied to choosing a higher note rate in a covered transaction needs review under § 1026.36(d), even when nobody referred the borrower to a third party.
Check whether the consumer can be charged the disclosed change
A creditor quoted an $800 origination charge on the valid Loan Estimate. The fee rises at settlement to $875 and there is no supported reason to use a revised estimate. The charge is subject to the no-increase standard in the example. Calculate $75 of excess and apply the applicable correction or refund timing. The underlying origination service can be real even though the additional charge is not allowed under the disclosure comparison. Conversely, a reasonable and timely cost disclosure does not validate a payment made for referrals.
If the parties say a new fee reflects actual additional work, ask for the change, the contract, who performed the work and any evidence needed for a TRID revision. Reconcile the provider bill, lender or seller credit and amount the consumer actually paid. A settlement agent can help reconstruct the ledger, and the creditor remains responsible for the applicable Closing Disclosure requirements. When the referral facts or the fee basis remain uncertain, route the records for review before approving the charge or arrangement.
Official Sources
- RESPA § 8, 12 U.S.C. § 2607
- Regulation X § 1024.14, kickbacks and unearned fees
- Regulation X § 1024.15, affiliated business arrangements
- CFPB RESPA FAQs on gifts, promotions and marketing services
- Regulation Z § 1026.36, compensation
- Regulation Z § 1026.19, good faith and corrections
- U.S. Supreme Court, Freeman v. Quicken Loans, 566 U.S. 624
A title insurer promises event tickets to an originator in exchange for each group of covered settlement referrals. Which feature is central to Section 8(a)?
The benefit is tied to sending settlement business
The tickets are intangible
The agreement is impermissible only above a listed retail price
The borrower chose the loan product
An invoice pays two providers part of a covered settlement service charge. One provider performed the settlement work and the other performed no service. What should the reviewer investigate?
Only whether the borrower received the fee estimate
An unearned split of a settlement charge
Whether the service was delivered on a weekday
The compounding rate on the note
An $800 origination charge becomes $875 with no valid revision, no credit and no other relevant change. How much exceeds the allowable charge?
$0
$25
$75
$875
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.