Appraisal Approaches, Independence, and Delivery

Key Takeaways

  • Match the sales comparison, cost and income approaches to the evidence available for the property.

  • An appropriate factual correction can be requested without influencing the independent result.

  • For covered first liens, provide valuation copies on the applicable earlier-of timeline and check overlapping HPML obligations.

Last updated: November 2026

Recognize what the valuation answers

An appraisal is a reasoned opinion of a property's value as of a specified date, based on the scope and evidence of the assignment. It helps a lender assess the collateral. A contract price records what buyer and seller agreed to pay. An inspection for a buyer can address condition and defects. An appraisal can consider condition without replacing an inspection or guaranteeing that the borrower should pay the contract price.

Comparable sales generally support the sales comparison approach. The appraiser evaluates recent, relevant transactions and adjusts a comparable for differences in features, location, condition or timing as supported. For example, an illustrative comparable sold at $335,500, has a feature worth $8,000 more than the subject and lacks a feature worth $5,500 present in the subject. Adjusting the comparable down for its superior feature and up for the missing feature gives $333,000. One adjusted comparable is evidence; the final opinion still considers the full set of relevant data and quality of each comparable.

The cost approach examines land value and the cost of reproducing or replacing improvements, with appropriate deductions for depreciation. It can be helpful for newer or specialized improvements, where market support and reliable cost data exist. The income approach examines what the property can earn, using relevant market information and an appropriate method such as a gross rent multiplier for some residential assignments. Different property types and assignment conditions warrant different methods. A creditor should understand what the report supports before using the conclusion.

Protect independent judgment while reviewing the report

For a valuation covered by Regulation Z § 1026.42, a covered person may not use coercion or other improper means to cause the stated value to rest on a factor other than the preparer's independent judgment. Pressuring an appraiser to reach a target value, threatening to withhold appropriate payment or conditioning future work on the result can impair that judgment. The lender can request consideration of appropriate additional property information, ask for support for a conclusion or request that an error be corrected. The facts and process matter.

An applicant may point out an incorrect room count or a relevant comparable transaction. Route the issue through the lender's review or reconsideration-of-value process. Verify the supporting information and avoid dictating a result. Under applicable Fannie Mae appraisal quality requirements, the lender must have a borrower-initiated reconsideration-of-value process for loans requiring the appraisal report. A second valuation is another source of evidence and should be assessed for reliability.

Deliver the right records by the right dates

Regulation B § 1002.14 generally requires a creditor to provide copies of all appraisals and other written valuations developed in connection with an application for credit secured by a first lien on a dwelling. Provide them promptly upon completion or no later than three business days before consummation or account opening, whichever is earlier. For a file that does not consummate or open, the copying duty generally still applies. An applicant may expressly waive the copy timing and agree to receive a copy at or before consummation or account opening, subject to applicable law. Obtain the waiver at least three business days before that event, except when the waiver only concerns clerical changes to a version supplied at least three business days beforehand. If the transaction does not go through after a waiver, provide the copies within 30 days of determining it will not consummate or open. Copies are free, although an otherwise lawful, reasonable valuation cost can be collected under applicable rules. The initial notice of the right to copies is a different step.

For covered higher-priced mortgage loans not exempt from the appraisal provisions, Regulation Z § 1026.35(c) generally calls for a written appraisal by a licensed or certified appraiser who physically visits the interior. A specified resale scenario can require a second appraisal. The rule compares the buyer's price to what the seller paid, with separate cases when the seller acquired the property 90 days or less before the buyer's agreement (more than 10% price increase) and 91 to 180 days before (more than 20%). Check the exceptions, including for specified acquisitions and properties. The creditor may charge for only one of those required appraisals. Apply both Regulation B and applicable Regulation Z appraisal and copy requirements independently.

Official Sources

Test Your Knowledge

A comparable sold for $335,500. It has a feature worth $8,000 more than the subject and lacks a feature worth $5,500 present in the subject. What adjusted comparable amount follows from these assumptions?

A

$333,000.

B

$349,000.

C

$338,000.

D

$322,000.

Test Your Knowledge

A borrower points out a factual error and provides a relevant comparable that the appraiser may have missed. What is appropriate under the applicable independence rule?

A

Demand that the appraiser raise the value to the purchase price.

B

Tie the appraiser's payment to the result.

C

Route the factual correction and comparable through the proper review process for independent consideration.

D

Promise the borrower a specific revised value.

Test Your Knowledge

A creditor completes a written valuation for a covered first-lien dwelling application far in advance of expected closing, with no waiver. When should it provide the copy?

A

Only at signing.

B

At the next annual review.

C

At any time if an early valuations notice was sent.

D

Promptly upon completion, while also meeting the three-business-day outside deadline.

Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.