Ability to Repay and Qualified Mortgages
Key Takeaways
A creditor makes the ability-to-repay determination before or at consummation of a covered transaction.
General QM uses product, underwriting, price and fee requirements. There is no fixed 43% General QM debt-to-income ceiling.
Compare payment obligations beyond any introductory period when reviewing a nontraditional product.
Start with the transaction and the decision
Regulation Z generally applies the ability-to-repay (ATR) rules to covered closed-end consumer credit secured by a dwelling. A home equity line of credit is open end and follows separate rules. Reverse mortgages and certain short-term bridge or construction credit are exceptions to the ATR and QM provisions. A construction phase of 12 months or less may qualify for an exception even when the permanent mortgage that follows requires its own ATR analysis. Determine coverage before selecting a test.
At or before consummation of a covered transaction, the creditor must make a reasonable, good-faith determination that the borrower can repay. Consider eight factors: current or reasonably expected income or assets other than the value of the securing dwelling, employment status if relying on employment income, payment on the proposed mortgage, payments on known simultaneous loans secured by the same property, mortgage-related obligations, current debts plus required alimony and child support, monthly debt-to-income ratio or residual income, and credit history. Use reasonably reliable third-party records for information relied on, subject to the rule's specific exceptions. A low initial payment or valuable collateral cannot replace an evaluation of the actual payment obligation and the borrower's resources.
For example, a borrower plans to use a simultaneous second lien for part of the purchase price. An underwriting file that uses the first mortgage plus taxes and insurance but overlooks the known second lien is incomplete. Address the payment on that lien, whether any other claimed income is reasonably available, and whether documented resources support repayment. Using only the initial advertised payment may produce the wrong result on a loan scheduled to adjust or recast.
Apply the General QM criteria
A Qualified Mortgage (QM) is one way to meet the federal ATR requirements. General QM generally excludes negative amortization, interest-only payments and balloon payments, and limits the term to 30 years. Check the required underwriting payment, considering the maximum rate that can apply in the first five years after the first regular periodic payment is due under § 1026.43(e)(2)(iv). The creditor considers and verifies specified income or assets and debts and considers monthly debt-to-income or residual income. The current General QM definition replaced the former 43% DTI cap with a price-based standard. Other QM categories may have their own criteria. A covered non-QM loan can be made if the applicable ATR and other rules are satisfied.
For the General QM price test, compare the regulatory APR to the average prime offer rate (APOR) for a comparable transaction on the rate-set date. The maximum spread depends on the loan category. The face amount of the note selects the applicable size tier. For price testing an interest rate that can change in the first five years, use the rule's special APR treatment. The following limits apply in 2026; each pricing test requires a spread strictly below the listed amount.
| 2026 General QM price category | Disqualifying spread begins at |
|---|---|
| First lien at least $137,958 | 2.25 percentage points |
| First lien $82,775 to under $137,958, excluding loans in the manufactured-home category below | 3.5 percentage points |
| First lien below $82,775 or first lien on a manufactured home below $137,958 | 6.5 percentage points |
| Subordinate lien at least $82,775 | 3.5 percentage points |
| Subordinate lien below $82,775 | 6.5 percentage points |
Separately test points and fees. The face amount selects the fee tier, but a percentage cap is applied to the statutory total loan amount. In 2026, starting at the largest tier, the caps are 3% for at least $137,958, $4,139 for $82,775 to under $137,958, 5% for $27,592 to under $82,775, $1,380 for $17,245 to under $27,592, and 8% below $17,245. Fees may equal the cap. For a $250,000 first-lien fixed-rate note, a 7.95% APR and 5.70% APOR give a 2.25-point spread, so it fails the General QM price test even if its fees pass. A statutory total loan amount of $248,000 gives a $7,440 fee cap. These thresholds serve a different purpose from the high-cost mortgage tests.
Evaluate legal protection and payment risk
For General QMs, the type of ATR protection depends on the separate higher-priced covered transaction test under § 1026.43(b)(4). A non-higher-priced General QM gets a safe harbor; a higher-priced General QM receives a rebuttable presumption. Seasoned QM has its own rule. The higher-priced covered transaction test is distinct from HPML escrow or appraisal classification under § 1026.35.
Federal interagency nontraditional mortgage guidance highlights payment shock and layered risk. If a loan's minimum payment is $900 while $1,100 in interest accrues, making that payment adds $200 to principal if the contract permits negative amortization. An interest-only payment of $1,100 leaves principal unchanged in the same example. Review future payments, rate changes, documentation and simultaneous financing together. An apparently manageable starting payment can conceal several risks at once.
Official Sources
A conventional fixed-rate first lien has a face amount of $250,000 and a 2026 General QM pricing spread of exactly 2.25 percentage points. Its fees satisfy the separate cap. What follows?
It qualifies because the price limit permits equality.
It fails the General QM price test.
It qualifies if its DTI is exactly 43%.
It is automatically a HOEPA high-cost loan.
A borrower uses a known simultaneous second mortgage on the same home. In a standard ATR file, what should the creditor do with the second mortgage?
Consider its payment when evaluating repayment ability.
Omit it if another lender will fund it.
Treat the usable loan proceeds as the buyer's income.
Consider it only if it is already on the credit report.
A loan permits a $900 minimum payment when monthly interest is $1,100. What happens to principal if that payment is made and the contract adds unpaid interest to principal?
Principal falls by $900.
Principal is unchanged because the minimum was paid.
Principal falls by $200.
Principal increases by $200.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.