TRID Fee Tolerances and Refund Calculations

Key Takeaways

  • Classify each charge using who retained it and whether the consumer could shop.

  • Compare zero-tolerance items individually and group only eligible charges in the 10% calculation.

  • Use the valid baseline, separate lender credits from charges, and document any refund.

Last updated: November 2026

Find which estimate controls

The TRID good-faith comparison begins with the applicable Loan Estimate, or a properly revised estimate where Regulation Z permits the change to be used. A final invoice supplies the actual charge. It does not establish by itself that a higher amount is permitted. Determine who retained the fee, who selected the service provider and whether the provider was affiliated. Consider valid revisions before applying the tolerance. Use amounts borne by the consumer and the unrounded underlying figures when making the comparison. The displayed disclosure can round some figures.

The three comparison methods under § 1026.19(e)(3) apply to different costs:

MethodCommon applicationsDecision
No increase over valid estimateFees retained by creditor, broker or affiliate for applicable services, required services for which the consumer cannot shop, and transfer taxesExamine each applicable charge individually
10% aggregate limitRecording fees and qualifying required shoppable services paid to an eligible unaffiliated provider on the written list, or where no independent choice is made under the applicable ruleCompare sums for the relevant services actually performed
Permitted variationBona fide prepaid interest, property insurance premiums and initial escrow, and certain other amounts including a required service the consumer chooses from outside the provided list when allowed to shopCheck whether the estimate was based on best information reasonably available

When a creditor lets the borrower shop, it generally provides a separate list identifying at least one available provider per required shoppable service and tells the borrower they can choose another. An affiliate's charge is generally treated separately from the unaffiliated pool. If the creditor permits shopping but fails to provide the required list, the official commentary applies the 10% aggregate rule to the qualifying unaffiliated charge and zero tolerance to applicable creditor or affiliate charges. The creditor still had a duty to provide the list. A charge the creditor collects and passes on to an unaffiliated provider does not automatically become a fee retained by the creditor.

A bona fide amount in the permitted-variation category still requires a good-faith estimate based on the best available information. For example, if the expected closing date was correctly used to estimate prepaid interest but the closing moved, a change can be permissible. An unreasonable estimate or omitted known required charge cannot be excused merely by citing the category.

Calculate the correction

Assume the following amounts are consumer-paid, with no justified estimate revision. The eligible 10% group consists of recording and an unaffiliated title service selected from the creditor's list. Both services were performed.

ChargeValid estimateActual paidComparison
Origination$800$850$50 excess
Appraisal required, shopping prohibited$500$475No excess
Recording$100$140Include in aggregate
Required title service, eligible listed unaffiliated provider$900$1,010Include in aggregate
Initial escrow collection$650$710Permitted variation if based on best information

The aggregate baseline is $1,000 and the maximum is $1,100. The actual aggregate is $1,150, so its excess is $50. The lower appraisal price does not erase the $50 origination excess because the no-increase test is individual. The total excess is $100. If an estimated shoppable service was never performed, remove its estimate from the eligible aggregate comparison under the commentary. Excluding cancelled services prevents their estimates from forming artificial room for increases in other charges.

A decrease in total lender credits can also be an increased cost to the consumer for good-faith purposes. Check the actual total creditor credits, including any specific amounts paid by the creditor for named charges, against the disclosed total under applicable rules. Do not count a seller's contribution as a replacement for the creditor's credit. Revisions supported by qualifying facts are addressed under the revised estimate rules.

Where the consumer has paid an excess subject to the no-increase or aggregate requirements, the creditor can cure it under § 1026.19(f)(2)(v) by refunding it no later than 60 days after consummation and delivering or placing in the mail a corrected Closing Disclosure reflecting the refund by that same deadline. A corrected form alone does not pay back the excess. Keep enough evidence to show both actions.

Official Sources

Test Your Knowledge

A lender's $800 origination fee becomes $850. A required appraisal for which the consumer could not shop falls from $500 to $475. What is the excess from these two items before any other adjustment?

A

$25.

B

$50.

C

$75.

D

$0.

Test Your Knowledge

Valid estimates in the 10% group total $1,000, and the actual charges total $1,150. All estimated services in the group were performed. How much exceeds the applicable limit?

A

$0.

B

$100.

C

$50.

D

$150.

Test Your Knowledge

A creditor allows shopping and supplies the required list. The consumer independently selects a qualified unaffiliated provider outside the list. How is the applicable charge generally tested?

A

Apply zero tolerance because the service was required.

B

Apply the 10% test to the individual charge.

C

Exclude all disclosures because the borrower selected the provider.

D

Apply the best-information good-faith test for permitted variations.

Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.