Mortgage Reporting, Credit Reports, and Identity Alerts
Key Takeaways
Determine HMDA coverage for the institution and the transaction before recording the data and disposition.
Confirm a permissible purpose before obtaining a consumer report. A credit-report-based denial can trigger both FCRA and ECOA duties.
Treat an identity warning as a prompt for independent verification under the applicable alert rules and the organization's written program.
Separate reporting about the market from a consumer's credit file
The Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA) and Regulation C collect data to help the public and officials see whether institutions serve local housing needs, inform decisions about public investment and identify possible discriminatory lending patterns. The reporting institution tests its own coverage under § 1003.2(g), then applies the product and transaction exclusions. The law can cover both depository and nondepository institutions. A job title, a Florida license or the presence of collateral does not settle the reporting question.
Volume tests use the two preceding calendar years, tested separately for closed-end mortgages and open-end lines. Under the current general transactional exclusions, fewer than 25 closed-end originations in either of those years ordinarily excludes closed-end transactions, and fewer than 200 open-end originations in either year ordinarily excludes the open-end category. Qualification as a financial institution also carries requirements that vary by institution type. Separate statutory partial exemptions can affect which data points an eligible institution reports. For example, a covered institution that closed 20 closed-end mortgages in one prior year and 40 in the next fails the mandatory closed-end volume test even if it reported eligible open-end files. Confirm institutional coverage and both annual counts before using an exclusion.
The institution generally records covered applications, originations and purchases. A decision to deny a covered application can be reportable. Fields include the action taken and its date, applicant and property information as applicable, and loan characteristics such as purpose and amount. A withdrawn file and a denied file are distinct dispositions. A file still pending at year-end generally stays out of that year's submission and is reported for the year of final action. Under the normal annual schedule the institution submits the prior calendar year's data by March 1. Large reporters have additional quarterly submissions. Protect individual records even though modified data are made public.
Establish a purpose before accessing a report
Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), a mortgage lender may use a consumer report for a permitted purpose, such as evaluating an extension of credit in a transaction involving that consumer, and must certify the purpose as required. Written instructions from the consumer are a separate permissible basis. A borrower asking for credit and a neighbor whose house is for sale are different cases. Staff cannot use a workplace reporting account to see whether the neighbor might need a refinance.
Suppose an underwriter denies an application partly because of recent delinquencies listed by a consumer reporting agency. The FCRA notice must identify the reporting agency, explain it did not make the decision and state the rights to dispute the information and get a free report on timely request within 60 days. If a numerical score was used in taking the adverse action, provide the statutory score disclosure with the required accompanying information. ECOA and Regulation B separately address notice timing and the creditor's reasons. One communication can satisfy both sets of content requirements when it includes all applicable elements. The reporting agency's contact information does not give the creditor's actual reasons.
Verify identity before extending credit
The Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions Act (FACTA) amended the FCRA to address identity theft among other consumer reporting issues. If a report has an initial fraud alert or active-duty alert, use reasonable policies and procedures to form a reasonable belief about the applicant's identity before extending covered new credit. When an alert specifies a phone number, use it or take other reasonable verification steps under the statute. An extended fraud alert calls for contact in person or using the contact method designated under the alert to confirm the new credit application is genuine. A security freeze restricts access to a report under a separate rule.
The Red Flags Rule requires covered institutions and creditors with covered accounts to maintain an identity theft prevention program designed to identify, detect, respond to and periodically update relevant red flags. Follow the policy when a report, identity document or address conflicts with the application. For example, with an extended alert and an applicant-supplied phone number different from the one in the alert, use the alert contact method or meet in person and document the identity verification. Staff should pause questionable processing and route unresolved cases to the appropriate team. The alert affects the verification steps even if the file would otherwise meet the lender's credit standards.
Official Sources
- Regulation C §§ 1003.1–5, purpose, institutional scope, transaction exclusions and reporting
- FCRA permissible purposes, 15 U.S.C. § 1681b
- FCRA report-based adverse action, 15 U.S.C. § 1681m
- FCRA fraud alerts and credit freezes, 15 U.S.C. § 1681c-1
- FTC identity theft Red Flags Rule scope and implementation
A covered institution denies a covered, nonexempt mortgage application. What does the denial mean for HMDA?
Report only loans that close.
Report the covered application with the applicable denial disposition.
Report a withdrawn application because no mortgage was made.
Assign the denial to the applicant's credit reporting agency.
A lender declines a mortgage partly because of a consumer report. The applicant wants to know who made the decision. What should the lender do?
Issue only a copy of the report.
Tell the applicant the reporting agency made the credit decision.
Give the applicable FCRA notice, including that the agency did not decide, and meet ECOA notice duties.
Tell the applicant to ask the agency for the creditor's underwriting reasons.
A consumer report has an extended fraud alert with a designated phone number different from the number on the loan application. What is an appropriate next step before extending the new mortgage credit?
Contact the consumer using the alert contact method or in person to confirm the application is genuine.
Use the application phone alone.
Approve based on credit score if the property appraises.
Remove the alert from the underwriting file once identifiers appear to match.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.