3.7 Regulation and Duties of the Scheme Trustee
Key Takeaways
A Scheme Trustee must be a trust company registered under the Trust Companies Act 1949 or incorporated under the Public Trust Corporation Act 1995 or the Labuan Trusts Act 1996, and must be registered with the SC.
Only one Trustee may be appointed for each scheme, and it must be independent of the Scheme Provider unless the strict related-party trustee conditions are met.
A related-party Trustee must appoint an auditor registered with the Audit Oversight Board to assess its internal controls once every two years.
Scheme Providers must publish a semi-annual and an annual report for each financial year and send them within two months of the end of the period.
The Trustee may refuse to create or cancel units if doing so would breach the deed, securities laws or guidelines, or would not be in investors' best interests.
Who Can Be a Trustee
| Requirement | Detail |
|---|---|
| Legal form | A trust company registered under the Trust Companies Act 1949, or incorporated under the Public Trust Corporation Act 1995 or the Labuan Trusts Act 1996; a foreign Trustee must be a public company under the Companies Act 2016 or foreign law |
| Registration | Registered with the SC under the Guidelines on the Registration and Conduct of Capital Market Services Providers (Registration Guidelines); the SC may impose conditions and revoke registration for breaches |
| Number | Only one Trustee per scheme |
| Independence | Must be independent of the Scheme Provider |
When registering a Trustee the SC looks at structure (governance, accountability, segregation of duties), competence (controls and processes that protect investors) and resource capabilities (qualified and experienced staff).
Related-party trustees
The SC allows related-party Trustees in some cases, but they must:
- appoint an external auditor registered with the Audit Oversight Board to independently assess their internal controls, processes and systems once every two years;
- submit the scope of that assessment to the SC for approval before it starts; and
- submit the assessment report to the SC one month before the anniversary date.
General Duties
The Registration Guidelines require a Trustee to:
- act honestly and in investors' best interests;
- safeguard investors' rights and interests;
- take reasonable steps to ensure fair treatment of investors;
- not gain an advantage for itself or others, nor cause detriment to investors;
- comply with duties in the deed that are consistent with securities laws; and
- carry out any other duties the SC specifies.
The Trustee's Oversight in Practice
Custody of assets
- All scheme assets are held in the Trustee's name. The Scheme Provider cannot sell or transfer them without the Trustee's express permission.
- Assets are kept separate from the Trustee's own assets and from other schemes.
- A sub-custodian may be appointed with SC approval, but the Trustee remains responsible for it.
- The Trustee ensures the scheme receives its income and entitlements, that net income is properly distributed, and that the fees paid to the Scheme Provider are reasonable and match the deed and prospectus.
Investment policies and transactions
The Trustee must know the scheme's investment policies, check they match the prospectus or disclosure document, and be satisfied they are sound. It then acquires and disposes of investments on the Scheme Provider's instructions; the provider should submit daily investment reports. Investments must never further the interests of the Scheme Provider or related parties at investors' expense.
Dealing in units
The Trustee creates and cancels units at the Scheme Provider's request under the UTF and PRS Guidelines:
- units are created only for cash, paid to the Trustee within 7 business days, at a price set by the deed and Guidelines;
- the Trustee checks that valuation and unit pricing follow the deed; and
- it may refuse to create or cancel units (or the number requested) if that would breach the deed, securities laws or guidelines, or (for cancellations) would not be in investors' best interests.
Accounts and audit
- The Trustee keeps, and ensures the Scheme Provider keeps, proper accounting records.
- Scheme accounts are audited every financial year by an approved auditor appointed by the Trustee. If the SC considers the auditor unsuitable or none has been appointed, it can direct the Trustee to replace or appoint one.
- The Trustee may remove the auditor and appoint another, and unit holders may, by ordinary resolution, ask the Trustee to replace the auditor.
Reports to Investors
Scheme Providers must publish at least two reports each financial year: a semi-annual and an annual report. Each must be sent out within two months of the end of the period and include the financial statements (with the auditor's report and Shariah adviser's report where applicable). Annual financial statements must be audited by an approved, independent auditor appointed by the Trustee.
The annual report includes the Trustee's Report, stating whether in its opinion:
- the Scheme Provider managed the fund within the limits on its investment powers in the deed, the Guidelines and other laws;
- valuation and pricing followed the deed and regulatory requirements; and
- creation and cancellation of units followed the deed and regulatory requirements.
If not, the Trustee must disclose the shortcomings that could affect investors' decisions and the steps taken to fix them and prevent recurrence.
Reporting to the SC
The Trustee must report to the SC if it believes the Scheme Provider has not acted in investors' interests or has breached the deed, the guidelines or SC requirements. To do this it keeps policies and procedures for actively monitoring the provider, including regular compliance reviews of investment limits and processes.
Exam Pointers
| Question cue | Answer |
|---|---|
| Main role of the Trustee | Safeguard the scheme's assets and investors' interests (FIMM practice question) |
| Who appoints the fund's auditor | The Trustee |
| How unit holders can seek a new auditor | Ordinary resolution asking the Trustee |
| Deadline for semi-annual and annual reports | Within two months after the period end |
| Who holds title to the assets | The Trustee (or a custodian to its order) |
Who appoints the auditor of a unit trust fund?
The Unit Trust Management Company
The Trustee
FIMM
The unit holders at every annual meeting
How often must a related-party Trustee have an external auditor registered with the Audit Oversight Board assess its internal controls?
Every year
Only when the SC requests it
Once every three years
Once every two years
A UTMC instructs the Trustee to create units, but the creation would breach the fund's deed. What may the Trustee do?
Create the units and report the breach in the next annual report
Refer the decision to FIMM's Disciplinary Committee
Refuse to create the units, or the number instructed
Create the units because the UTMC is responsible for the fund
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.