13.1 Steady & Unsteady Conduction, Extended Surfaces (Fins)
Key Takeaways
Fourier's law defines conduction heat flux as q'' = -k*dT/dx, where thermal conductivity k follows k_solid > k_liquid > k_gas and generally decreases with temperature in pure metals due to electron-phonon scattering.
Thermal resistance networks linearize complex composite geometries: conduction resistance is R_th = L/(kA) for slabs, ln(r2/r1)/(2pikL) for cylinders, and (r2-r1)/(4pikr1*r2) for spheres, combined via 1/(UA) = sum(R_th).
Critical radius of insulation is r_cr = k/h for cylinders and 2k/h for spheres; adding insulation to a bare cylinder where r_o < r_cr increases total heat loss until r_o = r_cr, beyond which heat loss decreases.
Extended surfaces (fins) improve heat dissipation governed by d^2(theta)/dx^2 - m^2theta = 0 with m = sqrt(hP/(kAc)); fins are justified only when fin effectiveness epsilon_fin = sqrt(kP/(h*Ac))*tanh(mL) > 2, typically on the gas/air side where convective h is low.
Transient conduction is governed by the Biot number Bi = hLc/k_solid; for Bi < 0.1, internal thermal gradients are negligible and the lumped capacitance model (T(t)-T_inf)/(T0-T_inf) = exp(-BiFo) = exp(-t/tau) applies with time constant tau = rhoVc_p/(h*As).
Steady & Unsteady Conduction, Extended Surfaces (Fins)
Conduction is the mode of heat transfer in which energy is transferred from more energetic particles of a substance to adjacent, less energetic particles as a result of microscopic interactions: atomic lattice vibrations (phonons) and molecular collisions, alongside free electron transport in conducting media. In mining engineering operations—ranging from the thermal management of high-power continuous miner electric motors, dragline brake assemblies, and underground transformer vaults to steam pipeline insulation in thermal power co-generation units—mastery of steady and transient conduction is vital for equipment reliability and safety.
1. Fourier's Law of Heat Conduction & Thermal Conductivity Mechanisms
Fourier's law is the phenomenological governing law of conductive heat transfer. It states that the time rate of heat transfer through a material is proportional to the negative gradient in temperature and to the area through which the heat flows at right angles to that gradient:
Where:
Note
The Negative Sign: The negative sign in Fourier's law is a physical requirement of the Second Law of Thermodynamics, ensuring that heat flows spontaneously down the temperature gradient from higher temperature to lower temperature (where , making ).
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| FOURIER'S LAW & THERMAL RESISTANCE CONCEPT |
| |
| Higher Temp (T1) Lower Temp (T2) |
| +---------------------------------------------------+ |
| | ---> Heat Flux q'' = -k*(dT/dx) | |
| | | |
| Area A | Material Thermal Conductivity = k | Thickness L |
| | | |
| +---------------------------------------------------+ |
| x = 0 x = L |
| |
| Thermal Resistance Analogy: |
| [T1] o--------------------/\/\/\/\/\/--------------------o [T2] |
| R_th = L / (k*A) |
| Heat Flow: q = (T1 - T2) / R_th = Delta_T / R_th |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
Microscopic Mechanisms of Thermal Conductivity ()
Thermal conductivity varies across states of matter based on microscopic energy transport carriers:
Where is the electronic contribution (free electron migration) and is the lattice vibration contribution (phonons).
- Pure Metals: Dominated by free electrons (). Pure copper () and aluminum () exhibit extremely high conductivity. Under the Wiedemann-Franz Law, the ratio of thermal conductivity to electrical conductivity () is proportional to absolute temperature:
- Alloys: Impurity atoms and structural dislocations scatter free electrons, significantly depressing thermal conductivity (e.g., carbon steel , austenitic stainless steel ).
- Non-Metallic Solids (Dielectrics): Heat conducts exclusively through lattice phonons (). In disordered structures (glass, refractory bricks), phonon scattering by amorphous boundaries yields low conductivity ().
- Liquids: Energy is transported by longitudinal acoustic molecular vibrations. In general, thermal conductivity in liquids decreases with increasing temperature, with water being a notable anomaly where rises to a maximum near before decreasing.
- Gases: Governed by kinetic theory of gases: . Thermal conductivity in gases is independent of pressure across standard industrial operating ranges () and increases with .
| Material Class | Typical Material | Thermal Conductivity | Primary Carrier |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pure Metal | Pure Copper / Silver | Free electrons () | |
| Structural Metal | Mild Steel (0.2% C) | Free electrons + Phonons | |
| Refractory / Ceramic | Fireclay Brick / Alumina | Lattice phonons () | |
| Liquid | Water at | Molecular collisions | |
| Insulator / Gas | Mineral Wool / Still Air | Molecular diffusion |
2. Three-Dimensional General Heat Conduction Equations
Applying the First Law of Thermodynamics to a differential control volume yields the general three-dimensional transient heat conduction equation with internal heat generation.
Cartesian Coordinates
For a homogeneous, isotropic material with constant thermal conductivity ():
Where is the thermal diffusivity, quantifying a medium's ability to conduct thermal energy relative to its capacity to store thermal energy.
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| SPECIAL FORMS OF CONDUCTION EQUATION |
| |
| 1. Fourier Equation: nabla^2 T = (1/alpha)*(dT/dt) (No heat gen, unsteady)|
| 2. Poisson Equation: nabla^2 T + (q_g_dot / k) = 0 (Steady, heat gen) |
| 3. Laplace Equation: nabla^2 T = 0 (Steady, no heat gen) |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
Cylindrical Coordinates
Spherical Coordinates
3. One-Dimensional Steady Conduction & Thermal Resistance Networks
Under steady-state conditions without internal heat generation, heat flow is governed by direct thermal circuit analogies ().
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| THERMAL RESISTANCE FORMULAS BY GEOMETRY |
| |
| Geometry Conduction Resistance R_th Heat Rate q |
| -------------------- -------------------------------- ------------------------- |
| Plane Slab (Area A) R_th = L / (k*A) q = k*A*(T1 - T2) / L |
| Cylinder (Length L) R_th = ln(r2/r1) / (2*pi*k*L) q = 2*pi*k*L*Delta_T/ln(r2/r1|
| Sphere (Radii r1, r2) R_th = (r2 - r1) / (4*pi*k*r1*r2) q = 4*pi*k*r1*r2*Delta_T/(r2-r1|
| Convective Boundary R_conv = 1 / (h*A) q = h*A*(T_s - T_inf) |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
Composite Plane Walls in Series & Overall Heat Transfer Coefficient ()
For a composite wall consisting of multiple material layers with convective fluid boundaries on both sides:
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| COMPOSITE WALL THERMAL NETWORK CIRCUIT |
| |
| Fluid (T_inf1, h1) | Layer A (L_A, k_A) | Layer B (L_B, k_B) | Fluid (T_inf2, h2) |
| | | | |
| [T_inf1] o---/\/\/\/---[T1]---/\/\/\/---[T2]---/\/\/\/---[T3]---/\/\/\/---o [T_inf2] |
| R_conv1 R_cond,A R_cond,B R_conv2 |
| 1/(h1*A) L_A/(k_A*A) L_B/(k_B*A) 1/(h2*A) |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
Radial Systems: Composite Cylindrical Pipes
For an insulated industrial pipe of inner radius , outer metal radius , and insulation outer radius , carrying hot fluid at () surrounded by ambient air at ():
4. Critical Radius of Insulation
Adding insulation to a flat plane wall always increases conductive resistance (), thereby reducing heat transfer. However, adding insulation to a curved surface (cylinder or sphere) introduces two competing thermal effects:
- Conduction Resistance: Increases logarithmically with insulation outer radius ().
- Convection Resistance: Decreases linearly with external surface area ().
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| CRITICAL RADIUS OF INSULATION BEHAVIOR |
| |
| Thermal Resistance (R) |
| ^ |
| | / R_total = R_cond + R_conv |
| | / |
| | / \ |
| | / R_cond \ |
| | / \ |
| | / \_ R_conv |
| | / \_ |
| | / R_total MINIMUM \_ |
| | +------------*--------------------> (Max Heat Dissipation Rate) |
| | | | |
| +---+------------+--------------------------------------------> Outer Radius (r) |
| r_1 r_cr = k / h |
| |
| - If r_initial < r_cr: Adding insulation INCREASES heat transfer (ideal for cables). |
| - If r_initial > r_cr: Adding insulation DECREASES heat transfer (steam pipes). |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
Derivation for a Cylindrical Geometry
Expressing total thermal resistance per unit length as a function of insulation outer radius :
Differentiating with respect to and setting the derivative to zero to find the extremum:
Evaluating the second derivative reveals , confirming that is at a mathematical minimum, and heat dissipation is at a maximum.
Derivation for a Spherical Geometry
Important
Practical Design Rules:
- Electrical Conductors & Cables: Keep outer radius so that adding dielectric insulation maximizes heat dissipation, preventing copper core thermal runaway.
- Steam & Process Fluid Pipelines: Ensure the bare pipe outer radius , so that every millimeter of insulation added immediately reduces costly heat losses.
5. One-Dimensional Steady Conduction with Uniform Heat Generation
When thermal energy is generated uniformly throughout a solid volume at rate (e.g., Joule heating in electrical busbars, core nuclear reactions, or concrete curing exotherm), internal temperature distributions become parabolic.
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| HEAT GENERATION: PLANE SLAB VS SOLID CYLINDER |
| |
| Plane Slab (-L <= x <= +L, Cooled to Tw): Solid Cylinder (0 <= r <= R, Cooled Tw): |
| |
| Centerline (x = 0) Centerline (r = 0) |
| T_max = T0 T_max = T0 |
| /\ /\ |
| / \ / \ |
| / \ / \ |
| Tw ______/ \______ Tw Tw ______/ \______ Tw |
| -L +L 0 R |
| |
| T(x) - Tw = (q_g*L^2 / 2k) * [1 - (x/L)^2] T(r) - Tw = (q_g*R^2 / 4k) * [1 - (r/R)^2]|
| T_max - Tw = q_g * L^2 / (2*k) T_max - Tw = q_g * R^2 / (4*k) |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
1. Plane Slab of Thickness Cooled Symmetrically ()
Starting from , integrating twice and applying symmetry :
If one surface () is perfectly insulated and the opposite face () is maintained at , the boundary conditions are identical, and maximum temperature occurs at the insulated wall with .
2. Solid Cylinder of Radius Cooled at Surface ()
Integrating with :
6. Extended Surfaces (Fins): Governing Equations & Performance
Extended surfaces (fins) are engineered protrusions designed to enhance heat dissipation from a primary surface into a surrounding fluid by increasing effective convective surface area. They are ubiquitous on mining compressor cylinder heads, electronic power converters, and air-cooled heat exchangers.
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| FIN DIFFERENTIAL CONTROL VOLUME |
| |
| Base (x=0) dx Tip (x=L) |
| +----------+ +------------+ +--------+ |
| | T = Tb | ======> | q_x | ======> q_(x+dx) | | |
| | | +------------+ +--------+ |
| +----------+ | |
| v dQ_conv = h * (P*dx) * (T - T_inf) |
| |
| Governing Fin Equation: d^2(theta)/dx^2 - m^2 * theta = 0 |
| Where: theta(x) = T(x) - T_inf, m = sqrt( h*P / (k*Ac) ) |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
Derivation of Governing Fin Equation
Applying energy balance on a 1D differential element of length , perimeter , and cross-sectional area :
Defining excess temperature and fin parameter :
General solution: .
The Three Canonical Fin Boundary Conditions
| Boundary Condition at Tip () | Temperature Profile | Total Fin Heat Transfer Rate |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Infinitely Long Fin (, ) | ||
| 2. Adiabatic / Insulated Tip () | ||
| 3. Convective Tip () |
Tip
Corrected Fin Length (): Instead of evaluating cumbersome convective tip hyperbolic series, apply the insulated-tip formula using a corrected length: . For a rectangular fin of thickness , ; for a pin fin of diameter , .
Fin Efficiency () vs. Fin Effectiveness ()
- Fin Efficiency (): The ratio of actual heat transferred by the fin to the maximum hypothetical heat transfer if the entire fin surface were maintained at base temperature :
- Fin Effectiveness (): The ratio of heat transferred with the fin to the heat transfer from the bare base area without the fin:
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| CRITERIA FOR EFFECTIVE FIN DESIGN |
| |
| - Thermal conductivity k MUST be high (use aluminum k=205 W/m*K or copper k=386). |
| - Convective coefficient h MUST be low (fins on air/gas side, NOT liquid/water side). |
| - Perimeter-to-area ratio (P / Ac) MUST be large (thin, slender, closely spaced fins).|
| - Justification Threshold: epsilon_fin >= 2.0 (if epsilon_fin < 1, fin acts as |
| an insulator and impedes heat dissipation!). |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
7. Transient Conduction & The Lumped Capacitance Method
In transient (unsteady-state) conduction, temperature varies with both spatial position and time (). When internal conductive resistance within a solid is negligible compared to external convective resistance, internal temperature gradients vanish, and the solid behaves as a single spatially uniform lumped thermal capacitance.
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| LUMPED CAPACITANCE ENERGY BALANCE |
| |
| Solid Body: Volume V, Area As, Density rho, Specific Heat cp, Initial Temp T0 |
| |
| - dE_stored / dt = dQ_conv / dt |
| - rho * V * cp * (dT/dt) = h * As * (T - T_inf) |
| |
| Temperature Response: |
| (T(t) - T_inf) / (T0 - T_inf) = exp( - (h*As / (rho*V*cp)) * t ) |
| = exp( - t / tau ) = exp( - Bi * Fo ) |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
Governing Non-Dimensional Parameters
- Characteristic Length ():
- Plane slab of thickness cooled on both sides:
- Long cylinder of radius :
- Sphere of radius :
- Cube of side :
- Biot Number (): Ratio of internal conductive resistance to external convective boundary resistance:
Important
Validity Criterion: The lumped capacitance method is strictly valid if and only if . When , the maximum temperature variation across the solid body is less than 5%, and spatial gradients can be safely neglected.
- Fourier Number (): Dimensionless time variable measuring the rate of heat conduction relative to thermal storage:
Where is the Thermal Time Constant of the system (seconds).
8. Step-by-Step Worked Calculation: Industrial Cable Insulation & Pin Fin Heat Sink
Worked Example 1: Critical Insulation Radius for Mining Feeder Cable
A high-voltage electrical cable in an underground mine shaft has a bare copper radius of and is coated with rubber insulation (). The cable is exposed to ventilation air with convective heat transfer coefficient .
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| CABLE INSULATION CALCULATION STEPS |
| |
| 1. Calculate Critical Radius: |
| r_cr = k / h = (0.16 W/m*K) / (20 W/m^2*K) = 0.008 m = 8.0 mm |
| |
| 2. Compare with Bare Cable Radius: |
| r_bare = 5.0 mm < r_cr (8.0 mm) |
| |
| 3. Critical Insulation Thickness: |
| t_cr = r_cr - r_1 = 8.0 mm - 5.0 mm = 3.0 mm |
| |
| 4. Physical Interpretation: |
| Adding up to 3.0 mm of rubber insulation INCREASES current carrying capacity |
| by maximizing heat dissipation rate from the copper core. |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
Worked Example 2: Transient Cooling of Steel Bearing Ball
A chrome-steel bearing sphere (, , , ) is quenched from in an agitated oil bath at with . Determine the time required for the sphere center to cool to .
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| BEARING QUENCHING CALCULATION STEPS |
| |
| STEP 1: Calculate Characteristic Length (Lc) |
| Lc = R / 3 = (0.025 m) / 3 = 0.008333 m |
| |
| STEP 2: Check Biot Number Validity |
| Bi = h * Lc / k = (160 * 0.008333) / 40 = 0.03333 |
| Since Bi = 0.0333 < 0.1, Lumped Capacitance is VALID! |
| |
| STEP 3: Calculate Thermal Time Constant (tau) |
| tau = (rho * cp * Lc) / h |
| = (7800 kg/m^3 * 460 J/kg*K * 0.008333 m) / (160 W/m^2*K) |
| = 29880 / 160 = 186.75 seconds |
| |
| STEP 4: Calculate Cooling Time t |
| (T(t) - T_inf) / (T0 - T_inf) = exp( - t / tau ) |
| (100 - 50) / (800 - 50) = 50 / 750 = 0.06667 |
| ln(0.06667) = - t / 186.75 |
| -2.70805 = - t / 186.75 ===> t = 505.7 seconds (approx 8.43 minutes) |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
A cylindrical electrical power transmission cable of 6 mm radius is insulated with a synthetic polymer of thermal conductivity k = 0.18 W/(m·K). The surrounding air provides a convection heat transfer coefficient of h = 15 W/(m²·K). What is the critical radius of insulation, and what happens to the total heat dissipation if a 3 mm thick insulation layer is added?
Critical radius is 6 mm; heat dissipation remains unchanged.
Critical radius is 12 mm; heat dissipation increases.
Critical radius is 12 mm; heat dissipation decreases.
Critical radius is 24 mm; heat dissipation decreases.
Under which set of engineering conditions will installing extended surfaces (fins) provide the highest fin effectiveness (ε_fin)?
Low fin material thermal conductivity k, high convective coefficient h, and small perimeter-to-area ratio P/Ac
High fin material thermal conductivity k, high convective coefficient h, and large cross-sectional area Ac
High fin material thermal conductivity k, low convective coefficient h, and large perimeter-to-area ratio P/Ac
Low fin material thermal conductivity k, low convective coefficient h, and thick fin cross-section
A solid copper sphere of 30 mm diameter (density = 8900 kg/m³, specific heat = 385 J/(kg·K), thermal conductivity = 390 W/(m·K)) is immersed in a cooling water stream with h = 260 W/(m²·K). Which statement correctly describes the temperature analysis approach and the thermal time constant of the sphere?
The Biot number is 0.00333 (Bi < 0.1), so lumped capacitance is valid; thermal time constant tau = 65.9 seconds.
The Biot number is 0.333 (Bi > 0.1), requiring Heisler charts; thermal time constant tau = 197.6 seconds.
The Biot number is 0.0100 (Bi < 0.1), so lumped capacitance is valid; thermal time constant tau = 197.6 seconds.
The Biot number is 0.00333 (Bi < 0.1), so lumped capacitance is valid; thermal time constant tau = 131.7 seconds.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.