10.3 High-Risk Fractures, Joint Dislocations, Compartment Syndrome, and Septic Arthritis
Key Takeaways
Escalating pain and pain on passive stretch raise concern for acute compartment syndrome. Release external constriction and seek urgent senior orthopaedic assessment. A small diastolic-to-compartment pressure difference supports concern. Established compartment syndrome requires immediate decompression.
Palpable distal pulses can persist in acute compartment syndrome. Use serial neurovascular and pain assessments in at-risk patients and act on deterioration.
For an open long-bone fracture, give IV prophylaxis immediately if it has not been given. Protect the wound, assess tetanus prophylaxis, splint and arrange timely orthoplastic care. Grade the whole injury.
Displaced intracapsular hip fractures in older adults can disrupt retinacular perfusion. Replacement arthroplasty is generally appropriate. Use the patient's function and health to guide the choice.
An acutely painful swollen joint may be infected. Aspirate promptly before empirical treatment when feasible in a stable adult. Give immediate antimicrobials for sepsis or shock and arrange joint drainage in parallel.
Acute compartment syndrome after injury or surgery
Acute compartment syndrome (ACS) develops when pressure within a closed myofascial compartment impairs local tissue perfusion. Bleeding or oedema raises pressure in a space with little capacity to expand. Venous outflow deteriorates, tissue oedema increases and the pressure rises further. Untreated ischaemia can permanently damage muscle and nerves. Rhabdomyolysis, renal injury and ischaemic contracture can follow.
Look for ACS after a tibial shaft fracture, forearm fracture, high-energy crush injury, prolonged external compression, limb surgery or reperfusion. A tight cast, dressing or splint can increase the pressure. An open fracture can still have intact deep fascia and develop ACS. Injury severity, perfusion and the time course vary, so use the clinical findings to establish urgency.
Record the mechanism and time of injury, time of the examination, consciousness, pain and response to analgesia, and neurological and vascular findings. Repeat and document observations hourly while the patient remains at risk under the British Orthopaedic Association standard. Include patients with limited communication or regional blockade in the monitoring plan.
Recognise an evolving deficit
- Increasing pain out of proportion to the injury or a rising analgesic requirement can be an early warning.
- Pain on passive stretch of the muscles in the affected compartment supports the diagnosis. Passive plantarflexion or toe flexion stretches the anterior leg compartment. Passive finger extension stretches volar forearm flexors. Compare with previous examinations and the other limb where possible.
- Tense swelling and sensory changes support concern. Loss of sensation in the first dorsal web space can reflect deep fibular nerve dysfunction in anterior leg ACS. Altered plantar sensation can indicate involvement of the tibial nerve in deep posterior ACS.
- Preserved pulses are common. Compartment pressure can impair small-vessel perfusion while flow persists through the main arteries. Pulselessness can occur late or indicate an associated arterial injury. Escalate when the pattern suggests compartment syndrome even with a warm or perfused foot.
Clinical findings can be subtle in a sedated or obtunded patient, during regional anaesthesia or when pain reporting is difficult. Consult the senior surgical team and consider pressure monitoring early in these settings.
Pressure measurement and urgent decompression
When the examination is equivocal or incomplete, measure pressure in the suspected compartments alongside the diastolic blood pressure. Use the trend and the clinical findings in the decision.
The July 2025 BOAST considers a difference below 30 mmHg an increased risk that calls for a consultant decision about decompression or continued monitoring. An absolute compartment pressure above 40 mmHg also prompts consideration of urgent decompression. For example, a diastolic pressure of 62 mmHg and a compartment pressure of 37 mmHg give a difference of 25 mmHg. Escalate immediately with both readings and the clinical findings. Established clinical ACS requires immediate surgery.
The same standard advises elevating the limb after release of circumferential dressings and reassessing within 30 minutes. In an equivocal case, reassess symptoms and perfusion and continue documented hourly checks if risk remains. In a diagnosed case, proceed with urgent operative decompression while removing external constriction. A scheduled reassessment, imaging or a pressure measurement should never delay treatment of established ACS.
For lower-leg fasciotomy, two incisions usually release all four compartments. The anterolateral incision accesses the anterior and lateral compartments and the posteromedial incision the superficial and deep posterior compartments. Document tissue viability and debride non-viable muscle. Plan soft-tissue management with plastic surgery within 24 hours and re-explore within 72 hours or earlier if clinically necessary. Late presentation with established tissue damage requires senior individualised assessment, including renal risk.
BOAST diagnosis and management of compartment syndrome, July 2025
Open fractures and the Gustilo–Anderson classification
An open fracture communicates with the external environment through a wound. The bone may be visible initially and retract, or the skin wound may be small. Deep contamination, damaged tissue and impaired perfusion increase the risk of infection and failure of union.
| Gustilo–Anderson grade | Typical injury |
|---|---|
| I | Small clean wound, usually around 1 cm or less, with limited soft-tissue injury. |
| II | Larger wound with limited soft-tissue damage and without the extensive devitalisation or loss characteristic of type III. |
| IIIA | High-energy injury with extensive soft-tissue damage or contamination. Adequate local tissue remains to cover bone after debridement. |
| IIIB | Extensive soft-tissue loss, often with periosteal stripping and exposed bone. Reconstructive soft-tissue coverage is required. |
| IIIC | Associated arterial injury requiring repair to preserve limb viability. |
The grade describes the whole injury. A small wound may conceal high-energy damage. An 8 cm wound with extensive avulsion and adequate local cover can be IIIA. Establish the definitive grade after operative assessment of viability, contamination and coverage. Start urgent care as soon as an open fracture is recognised.
Original Gustilo–Anderson study · Gustilo type III subclassification
Initial wound care and orthoplastic referral
- Assess the whole patient and the limb. Address life-threatening injury and bleeding first. Document pulses, capillary refill, sensation and motor function. Realign and splint as appropriate and repeat the neurovascular assessment. Signs of arterial compromise call for immediate surgical escalation.
- Give IV prophylaxis early. Under BOAST and NICE NG37, give it as soon as possible, ideally within one hour of injury. Give it immediately in the emergency department if it was missed. Select agents using the hospital's open-fracture policy, allergy history and contamination pattern.
- Protect the wound. Before formal debridement, handle the wound only to remove gross contaminants and obtain clinical photographs under the local policy. Cover it with sterile saline-moistened gauze and an occlusive layer. Leave irrigation, exploration and definitive closure to the operative team.
- Assess tetanus separately. Check the injury and immunisation history using the Irish NIAC chapter 21 table. For a tetanus-prone wound in a person with unknown or incomplete immunisation, give tetanus-containing vaccine and tetanus immunoglobulin (TIG) as indicated. For a person with at least five appropriately spaced doses, the table calls for a booster if the last dose was more than ten years ago, and TIG if immunocompromised. Give vaccine and TIG at different sites when both are indicated.
- Plan debridement and coverage with orthopaedics and plastic surgery. In the BOAST pathway for long-bone, hindfoot and midfoot injuries, debride immediately when there is major contamination or vascular compromise. Aim for debridement within 12 hours for other high-energy injuries and within 24 hours for other low-energy injuries. Plan definitive cover at initial surgery or within 72 hours of injury. Use the Irish trauma network pathway for transfer and locally applicable antimicrobial care.
BOAST Open Fractures · NICE NG37 complex fractures · HSE major trauma guidance for older adults · Irish NIAC tetanus guidance, September 2026
Proximal Femoral Fractures in Older Adults: Intracapsular versus Extracapsular Injuries
Prompt analgesia, optimisation and orthogeriatric care support safe surgery and recovery. The Irish Hip Fracture Database 2025 report describes the current audit measure as surgery within 48 hours of first presentation and within normal working hours. This measure tracks quality. Correct reversible problems promptly and aim for timely surgery. Irish Hip Fracture Database 2025
Clinical Presentation
The typical presentation involves an elderly patient following a ground-level mechanical fall. Physical examination classically reveals a shortened and externally rotated lower extremity, severe hip or groin pain, inability to bear weight, and agonizing pain upon gentle passive axial rotation of the hip. (Occult or impacted fractures may present with knee or thigh pain alone and preserved weight-bearing).
Vascular Anatomy and Fracture Classification
The surgical management of hip fractures is fundamentally governed by the anatomical relationship of the fracture line to the hip joint capsule and the vascular supply of the femoral head:
- Blood Supply to the Femoral Head: Retinacular vessels along the femoral neck, supplied chiefly by the medial femoral circumflex artery, make a major contribution to the adult femoral head. Contributions from other vessels vary. The artery of the ligamentum teres usually contributes little in adults. Femoral-head circulation dissection study
- Intracapsular Fractures (Subcapital and Transcervical):
- Located proximal to the insertion of the hip joint capsule along the intertrochanteric line;
- Avascular necrosis and non-union: Displacement can disrupt retinacular perfusion to the femoral head and increase the risk of osteonecrosis and fixation failure.
- Garden Classification (for intracapsular fractures):
- Garden I: Incomplete or impacted fracture with valgus impaction of the femoral head;
- Garden II: Complete, undisplaced fracture;
- Garden III: Complete fracture with partial displacement;
- Garden IV: Complete fracture with full displacement;
- Surgical Management Strategy:
- Undisplaced or impacted fractures: Internal fixation is an option. Patient factors and fracture features guide selection. Hemiarthroplasty may be considered in some older patients.
- Displaced fractures in older adults: Replacement arthroplasty is generally appropriate. Hemiarthroplasty replaces the femoral head using a femoral component with a stem. Total hip replacement also replaces the acetabular surface. The NICE pathway considers total replacement when a person could walk outdoors independently with at most a stick, has no condition making it unsuitable and is expected to remain independent in activities of daily living beyond two years. NICE recommends cemented implants when performing arthroplasty for hip fracture. Discuss the replacement options with the orthopaedic team. The HEALTH trial found no significant reduction in secondary procedures with total replacement over 24 months and a small functional difference that did not reach clinical importance. NICE CG124 hip fracture recommendations · HEALTH trial
- Extracapsular Fractures (Intertrochanteric and Subtrochanteric):
- Located distal to the capsular attachment. The femoral head blood supply is generally less threatened than in a displaced intracapsular fracture. Stability, comminution and fracture pattern influence fixation and union.
- Intertrochanteric Fractures: A sliding hip screw allows controlled impaction. NICE prefers an extramedullary implant for trochanteric fractures above and including the lesser trochanter, with an exception for reverse-oblique fractures. The fixation plan depends on the individual fracture pattern and local practice.
- Subtrochanteric Fractures: Occur in the diaphyseal zone within distal to the lesser trochanter. Subjected to intense deforming muscle forces (iliopsoas flexes and externally rotates the proximal fragment; abductors abduct it). NICE recommends intramedullary fixation. Nail dimensions depend on the fracture configuration.
Recognise and reduce acute joint dislocations
Anterior shoulder dislocation can follow forced abduction and external rotation. The usual deltoid contour flattens and the acromion becomes prominent. The arm may be supported in slight abduction. Document distal circulation and examine the axillary nerve before and after reduction. Test sensation over the lateral deltoid and, when feasible, deltoid contraction. A Bankart lesion affects the anteroinferior labrum. A Hill–Sachs lesion is an impaction defect in the posterolateral humeral head produced by contact with the anterior glenoid rim. Review radiographs for associated fracture and confirm reduction according to the local pathway.
Posterior native hip dislocation can result from a dashboard impact to the knee while the hip is flexed. The limb is typically shortened, adducted and internally rotated. Check sciatic function, including foot dorsiflexion and dorsal foot sensation, and document vascular status before and after reduction. Delayed reduction increases the risk of femoral-head osteonecrosis. Arrange prompt orthopaedic reduction under appropriate sedation or anaesthesia as soon as the patient's other injuries permit. After reduction, reassess alignment and use CT to assess joint congruity, associated fractures and retained fragments.
Defence Medical Command joint-dislocation guidance · NSW Emergency Care Institute hip-dislocation pathway
Assess upper limb fractures and localise an associated nerve deficit
After acute trauma, document skin integrity, perfusion, sensation and individual motor nerve function before and after manipulation or splinting. Test radial nerve function with wrist or finger extension, median function with thumb opposition and ulnar function with finger abduction. To assess the anterior interosseous branch of the median nerve, ask for tip-to-tip thumb and index finger pinch. Compare sides and distinguish pain-limited effort from an objective deficit. A new or worsening deficit after manipulation can signal compression or injury and warrants immediate review.
| Presentation | First decisions |
|---|---|
| Adult with wrist deformity after a fall | Assess skin, capillary refill and median nerve function. Obtain wrist radiographs. Seek prompt reduction or specialist assessment for marked deformity, threatened skin or neurovascular compromise. Management also depends on displacement, stability and the person's functional needs. |
| Focal scaphoid tenderness after a fall | Maintain suspicion when initial radiographs are normal. Protect the wrist and arrange prompt further assessment. NICE NG38 advises considering first-line MRI after clinical examination in suspected scaphoid fracture. Apply the local imaging pathway. |
| Child with displaced supracondylar humerus fracture | Document pulse, refill and radial, median (including anterior interosseous) and ulnar function. Splint, provide analgesia and obtain urgent orthopaedic assessment. A cold underperfused hand needs emergency intervention. |
| Adult with an isolated stable compression palsy, for example radial weakness after sleeping with the upper arm compressed | Confirm the distribution, assess for stroke, trauma or radiculopathy and address pressure on the nerve. NICE recommends splint referral and review at six weeks for clear stable cases with no root signs, with neurological referral if no improvement. Rapid progression or associated traumatic deficit needs a different, more urgent pathway. |
BOA distal radial fractures · BOA childhood supracondylar fractures · BOA peripheral nerve injury · NICE NG38 fracture imaging · NICE NG127 compression palsy
Septic arthritis of a native joint
Suspect septic arthritis in an acutely painful, hot or swollen joint with marked pain on passive and active movement. Fever may be absent. A knee is a common presentation. Bacterial infection and the host inflammatory response can rapidly damage cartilage. Staphylococcus aureus and streptococci are important organisms. Consider risk of MRSA or resistant Gram-negative organisms, and assess for gonococcal infection when the history and associated findings suggest it. Prosthetic joint infection and paediatric bacterial arthritis require their own pathways.
- Obtain samples and assess for sepsis in parallel. In a stable adult with suspected native joint infection, obtain an urgent aseptic aspirate before empirical antibiotics when feasible. In sepsis or septic shock, start antimicrobials promptly and obtain blood cultures first if this causes no meaningful delay. Aspiration and source control remain urgent.
- Interpret tests together. Send fluid for bacterial culture and Gram stain, white cell count and differential, and crystals. If the sample is limited, prioritise bacterial identification. A synovial white cell count above 50,000/µL supports infection. A count below 25,000/µL lowers probability while infection remains possible. A negative Gram stain or the presence of urate or CPPD crystals leaves infection in the differential.
- Treat and secure source control. Involve orthopaedics urgently. Large joints commonly need arthroscopic washout. Open washout may be appropriate with adhesions or cartilage or bone damage. Choose initial IV treatment using local microbiology guidance, Gram stain, allergy and resistance risks. Tailor the regimen to cultures and determine oral step-down and duration with the treating team.
Worked example. A stable adult with a hot knee and a readily accessible effusion can have the joint aspirated before antibiotics. The same presentation with new hypotension and impaired perfusion needs immediate sepsis treatment. Draw cultures promptly where feasible and arrange aspiration and drainage in parallel.
In children, consider bacterial arthritis when a child with a painful joint refuses to use the limb or bear weight. A hip effusion may be deep and may present as knee pain. Seek urgent paediatric and orthopaedic review. If a child is well appearing and stable, aspiration before antibiotics can be appropriate under close observation and with a timely sampling plan. In an ill-appearing child or rapidly progressive infection, start empirical therapy immediately, after blood cultures if feasible, and obtain the joint sample as soon as possible. Age affects the likely organism. In preschool children, Kingella kingae is an important consideration alongside Staphylococcus aureus. PIDS/IDSA 2023 acute bacterial arthritis in children guideline · BSCOS paediatric musculoskeletal infection consensus
A 23-year-old amateur rugby player sustains a closed, mid-shaft fracture of the right tibia following a heavy tackle. The limb is immobilized in a plaster backslab in the emergency department, and he is admitted to the orthopaedic ward. Six hours later, he reports severe, rapidly escalating pain in his right shin that is completely refractory to repeated doses of intravenous morphine. On physical examination, the anterolateral compartment of his right leg is tense and woody. Passive plantarflexion of his right ankle and toes elicits excruciating agony. Bilateral dorsalis pedis and posterior tibial arterial pulses are easily palpable and bounding. Light touch sensation across the dorsal first web space of his right foot is diminished compared to the left. What is the most appropriate definitive immediate action?
Release the splint and circumferential padding to expose the skin, and arrange immediate four-compartment decompressive fasciotomy with orthopaedics
Elevate the right leg on multiple pillows above heart level and administer an intravenous bolus of 5000 units unfractionated heparin
Reassure the patient that the pain is expected following a tibial fracture, administer a higher dose of intravenous morphine, and re-examine in the morning
Perform an urgent Doppler arterial ultrasound to confirm the presence of palpable distal pulses before considering surgery
An 82-year-old with a displaced intracapsular femoral neck fracture lived independently and walked outdoors without an aid before injury. She has no condition that makes total replacement unsuitable and is expected to remain independent in activities of daily living for more than two years. Which procedure should the orthopaedic team consider over hemiarthroplasty under NICE CG124?
Closed reduction and percutaneous fixation with three parallel cannulated cancellous screws
Closed reduction and internal fixation utilizing a Dynamic Hip Screw (DHS)
Insertion of a long cephalomedullary intramedullary nail with distal locking screws
Cemented Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA)
A 28-year-old motorcyclist is brought to the resuscitation bay following a collision with a car at 50 km/h. He has sustained an open fracture of his right tibia. On examination, there is an 8 cm jagged laceration over the anterior shin through which bone ends were momentarily visible before spontaneous retraction. Extensive contusion and skin avulsion are noted, but adequate local muscle and subcutaneous tissue are present to allow primary soft-tissue coverage of the bone once debrided. The foot is warm and pink with palpable dorsalis pedis pulses and normal sensation. Which is the most likely provisional Gustilo–Anderson grade and appropriate immediate emergency department care?
Gustilo-Anderson Grade I; wash the wound extensively with tap water, close the skin with non-absorbable sutures, and apply a plaster cast
Gustilo-Anderson Grade IIIB; apply a tight arterial tourniquet, withhold antibiotics until operative cultures are taken, and elevate the leg
Gustilo–Anderson IIIA. Give IV prophylactic antibiotics immediately, obtain clinical photographs and cover the wound with a saline-moistened occlusive dressing, assess tetanus prophylaxis and realign and splint.
Gustilo-Anderson Grade IIIC; transfer immediately to the interventional radiology suite for urgent arterial embolisation
A child falls on an outstretched hand and has a displaced supracondylar fracture. The injured hand is cool, capillary refill is prolonged and the radial pulse is absent. What is the best next step?
Obtain emergency orthopaedic assessment for reduction and management of threatened perfusion, with an immediate documented neurovascular examination
Apply a sling and make a routine clinic appointment
Observe for six weeks as for an isolated stable compression palsy
Delay escalation until nerve conduction results are available
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.