18.5 Scars and Skin or Subcutaneous Lumps

Key Takeaways

  • Examine size, depth, mobility, surface and growth before deciding that a lump is benign.

  • An unexplained enlarging or deep mass needs timely investigation. Discuss suspicious soft tissue tumours with the specialist service before biopsy or excision.

  • A hypertrophic scar stays within the original wound. A keloid can grow beyond it. Functional restriction or an atypical changing lesion warrants assessment.

Last updated: November 2026

Describe the lesion before naming it

Ask when the lump began, how quickly it changed and whether there was a wound, piercing, injection, infection or trauma. Ask about pain, bleeding, neurological symptoms and impaired function. Measure and document size and position. Assess the surface, colour, consistency, tenderness, mobility relative to skin and deeper structures, and whether there is a punctum or discharge. A photograph with consent or a recorded measurement can help assess change at follow-up. A painless lump can still need urgent investigation.

PatternLikely possibility and next decision
Soft, mobile subcutaneous mass with stable size and normal overlying skinMay be a lipoma. If the clinical diagnosis is secure and it is asymptomatic, discuss observation and when to return. New growth or fixation changes the plan.
Firm dermal or superficial nodule with a central punctumSuggests an epidermoid cyst. Rupture can cause inflammation without bacterial infection. Assess pain, drainage, surrounding cellulitis and any fluctuant collection.
Small, firm, stable dermal papule that dimples when compressed from the sidesMay be a dermatofibroma. Check for atypical pigmentation or interval growth.
Tender warm fluctuant massConsider abscess and assess for drainage and systemic involvement. A repeatedly inflamed site can have an underlying cyst or another local cause.
Unexplained growing, deep or fixed massInvestigate promptly. A concerning mass may need specialist imaging and biopsy planning even if painless.
Bleeding, ulcerated or enlarging lesion arising in the skinAssess for skin cancer and use the appropriate specialist pathway.

Ultrasound can triage a small accessible soft tissue mass when the diagnosis is uncertain. MRI is generally preferred for local assessment of a large, deep or indeterminate lesion. Follow the local pathway and contact the sarcoma team before biopsy or excision when malignancy is suspected. A biopsy track can affect definitive surgical planning. The European Society of Musculoskeletal Radiology flags masses at least 5 cm, indeterminate imaging and clinical suspicion as referral indications. A smaller lesion with concerning growth still requires assessment. Ireland's national sarcoma network can advise on referrals and specialist work-up.

HSE lumps overview · BAD epidermoid cyst guidance · BAD dermatofibroma guidance · ESSR soft tissue mass guideline · Irish sarcoma network

Prepare a referral. Include the time course, measured dimensions, site, depth and relation to surrounding structures. Record previous imaging, any intervention and whether the lump was previously removed. A recently enlarging mass should not be labelled a haematoma solely because the patient remembers a minor knock. Document a reassessment plan when choosing observation for a lesion with a secure benign diagnosis.

Assess scarring by its boundary and effect

A normal scar evolves after skin injury and often flattens or fades. An atrophic scar sits below surrounding skin, as can occur after inflammatory acne. A hypertrophic scar is raised but remains within the boundaries of the injury. A keloid extends beyond those boundaries and can persist, grow, itch or hurt. Ask about earlier scars and about the original wound. A scar across a joint can limit motion if it contracts. Assess movement and consider rehabilitation or specialist care, particularly after a burn.

Address the underlying inflammatory disease where it is still active. Once the skin is healed, options for symptomatic raised scars may include silicone gel or sheeting. A specialist can consider intralesional corticosteroid treatment for a troublesome keloid. Excision alone can be followed by recurrence, so plan any procedure with an appropriate specialist. An apparent scar without a convincing preceding injury, or a scar-like lesion with unexpected growth, ulceration or a new firm nodule, should be reassessed. Some skin tumours resemble scar tissue. A new persistent ulcer in a long-standing scar warrants evaluation for malignancy, including squamous cell carcinoma.

Worked distinction. An itchy raised ridge follows the exact outline of a healed surgical incision and has become less prominent over time. This fits a hypertrophic scar. A firm lesion that keeps extending past an ear-piercing site fits a keloid and may merit specialist treatment if troublesome. A new enlarging deep thigh lump with no wound is a different presentation. Assess it as a soft tissue mass and avoid unplanned removal.

BAD keloid guidance · Scar Workshop consensus · BAD dermatofibrosarcoma guidance · NCCP skin cancer referral routes

Test Your Knowledge

A 43-year-old has a painless, enlarging thigh mass that measures about 7 cm and feels deep to the subcutaneous tissue. There is no overlying wound. What is the best next step?

A

Arrange routine cosmetic excision without imaging

B

Observe until the mass becomes painful

C

Treat as an inflamed epidermoid cyst without further assessment

D

Arrange prompt specialist assessment and imaging before biopsy or excision

Test Your Knowledge

A firm itchy lesion continues to extend beyond the original wound after an ear piercing. The skin is intact and there is no warmth or discharge. Which diagnosis and management consideration best fit?

A

Keloid, with specialist options such as intralesional corticosteroid if symptoms warrant treatment

B

Hypertrophic scar, with routine complete excision as the first step

C

Abscess, with immediate antibiotics because the lesion is raised

D

Atrophic scar, with drainage of the depressed area

Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.