8.1 Differential Diagnosis of the Acute Abdomen, Peritonitis, and Appendicitis

Key Takeaways

  • Use the timing and location of abdominal pain with examination and reassessment. Visceral pain can become localised when the parietal peritoneum is irritated.

  • Peritoneal signs or shock warrant early resuscitation and surgical assessment. A benign early examination can occur in time-critical conditions.

  • For suspected appendicitis, clinical risk and patient context guide imaging and surgical review. Ultrasound is usual first imaging in an intermediate-risk child.

  • Suspected perforation warrants prompt antibiotics and urgent surgical assessment. CT is useful when indicated and available; repair depends on the circumstances.

  • Severe pain with vascular risk warrants urgent mesenteric CT angiography. Lactate cannot independently exclude ischaemia or establish bowel necrosis.

Last updated: November 2026

Assess the Acute Abdomen

First determine whether the patient has shock, bleeding, peritoneal irritation or a time-critical vascular, obstetric or surgical cause. Record onset, site, radiation and migration of pain, vomiting, bowel function, medications, operations and relevant vascular and pregnancy history. Consider abdominal and extra-abdominal causes. Provide analgesia, reassess perfusion and obtain early senior or surgical input when the presentation is high risk. Irish acute surgical assessment standards distinguish stable appendicitis from diffuse peritonitis, unstable bleeding and other conditions needing more urgent assessment.

Where the Pain Comes From

Visceral pain from distension, traction, ischaemia or inflammation is often poorly localised. Foregut pain often presents in the epigastrium, midgut pain near the umbilicus and distal bowel or pelvic visceral pain in the lower abdomen. These patterns guide the differential. They do not identify an organ by themselves. Parietal peritoneal irritation often produces more localised pain that worsens with movement, percussion or coughing. Early appendicitis can therefore begin with periumbilical pain before localising to the right iliac fossa.

Peritoneal Signs

FindingInterpretation
Involuntary guarding or rigiditySuggests peritoneal irritation, particularly when contraction persists with a relaxed patient.
Local pain on gentle percussion, cough or movementSupports local parietal irritation. Repeated abrupt rebound testing adds discomfort and may be unnecessary.
Right-sided pain elicited by left lower-quadrant palpationA Rovsing sign can support appendicitis in the appropriate context.
Pain on passive extension of the right hip or on internal rotation of the flexed hipPsoas or obturator signs can occur with anatomically adjacent inflammation and have limited sensitivity.
Severe pain with little early tendernessConsider mesenteric ischaemia, especially with embolic risk. A reassuring early examination is insufficient.

In older, frail or immunosuppressed people the examination can be less conspicuous. Reassess after initial treatment or when symptoms evolve. With shock or likely generalised peritonitis, start resuscitation and secure surgical review and source control in parallel. Choose imaging that answers the urgent clinical question and avoid unnecessary delay to definitive care.

HSE acute surgical assessment standards

Distinguish diverticulitis from diverticular bleeding

Acute diverticulitis often causes steady left lower quadrant pain and focal tenderness, with fever or changed bowel habits. Consider other surgical, urinary and gynaecological causes in the relevant setting. Diverticular bleeding typically presents with rectal bleeding and uses the lower gastrointestinal bleeding pathway. Diverticulosis found incidentally without symptoms does not itself warrant antibiotics.

Assess vital signs, systemic illness, immunosuppression and evidence of a complication. Guarding, diffuse peritonism, severe uncontrolled pain, an abdominal mass, sepsis or obstructive symptoms warrant urgent hospital assessment. Suspected complicated disease may need contrast CT to assess for abscess, perforation or obstruction. Give inpatient IV antibiotics when indicated by local guidance and seek urgent surgical review. A drainable abscess or free perforation can require source control.

In a clinically well patient with uncomplicated disease and reliable review, NICE NG147 supports considering simple analgesia and a no-antibiotic strategy with clear return advice. Systemic illness, immunosuppression or significant comorbidity changes the antibiotic decision. Use the local protocol for regimen selection, and reassess if symptoms persist or worsen.

HSE diverticular disease and diverticulitis · NICE NG147

Suspected Acute Appendicitis

Luminal obstruction can contribute to distension and inflammation. Appendicitis can progress to gangrene, perforation, phlegmon or abscess. The time course varies. New focal guarding after migratory pain increases concern, even when the patient appears well. A pelvic or retrocaecal appendix can present atypically. Consider other bowel disease, ureteric stone and reproductive causes where relevant.

Use Scores to Inform, Then Reassess

A suitable clinical score can help separate low-risk patients from those needing observation, imaging or urgent surgical assessment. The original Alvarado score gives two points each for right lower-quadrant tenderness and leucocytosis, and one each for migration, anorexia, nausea or vomiting, direct rebound tenderness, raised temperature and left shift. The maximum is 10. Use the locally adopted score and definitions. The current WSES guidance uses clinical scores alongside assessment and selective imaging.

Worked example: A patient with migration, anorexia, nausea, right lower-quadrant tenderness, direct rebound, fever, leucocytosis and left shift gets 1 + 1 + 1 + 2 + 1 + 1 + 2 + 1 = 10. Escalate a high-risk presentation promptly. The number does not determine surgical management on its own, and the example requires all eight actual findings.

Choose the Investigation for the Patient

  • Adults: CT abdomen and pelvis with IV contrast is often the initial imaging study when needed. It can show appendiceal inflammation, an abscess and alternative diagnoses. Select the imaging strategy and contrast with the radiology and surgical teams in the individual case.
  • Children: Assess clinical risk. An intermediate-risk child who needs imaging usually has ultrasound first. Reassess and consider either further imaging or observation when ultrasound is nondiagnostic and concern persists. This is consistent with the paediatric surgical section.
  • Pregnancy: Use ultrasound or MRI, guided by the local pathway and availability. After a nondiagnostic ultrasound and persistent suspicion, MRI without gadolinium is often appropriate. Involve obstetric and surgical teams where indicated. Delay carries risk when a time-critical diagnosis remains possible.

Manage by Severity and Findings

Early surgical assessment is appropriate for high clinical suspicion or complicated disease. Laparoscopic appendicectomy is the standard surgical approach, with perioperative antibiotic prophylaxis according to local policy. Clinicians can discuss antibiotics without immediate surgery in selected uncomplicated cases, including uncertainty, treatment failure and recurrence. If there is generalised peritonitis or deterioration, prioritise source control. Contained appendiceal abscess or phlegmon may be treated with antibiotics, selective image-guided drainage when suitable, or surgery depending on the patient and setting. Arrange follow-up after nonoperative abscess care because of possible underlying neoplasia. The plan for imaging, colon assessment or interval surgery is specialist-led. Postoperative antibiotic duration depends on severity and adequacy of source control.

WSES appendicitis 2025 edition · IDSA imaging guidance

Perforated Peptic Ulcer

Sudden severe upper abdominal pain with peritoneal signs suggests perforation, particularly with ulcer history or NSAID use. The leakage initially causes chemical irritation and can progress to infection and shock. Examination varies with location and whether leakage has sealed. Free gas under the diaphragm on an erect chest film supports perforation, but a normal film cannot exclude it. WSES prefers CT where available for suspected perforated ulcer. Plain radiography may help when CT is unavailable or delayed. If uncertainty persists, discuss targeted imaging including water-soluble contrast when appropriate.

With generalised peritonitis and significant free air, seek emergency surgical source control. Restore perfusion with reassessed IV fluid, keep the patient nil by mouth, start IV broad-spectrum antibiotics according to local guidance and consider gastric decompression and acid suppression. When perforation is already evident and the patient is unstable, avoid delaying source control for routine additional imaging. Laparoscopic or open surgery is selected according to stability, expertise and findings. Primary repair is an option for a small perforation. An omental patch is used selectively. Assess suspicious gastric lesions for malignancy and arrange biopsy or follow-up endoscopy when appropriate. Review NSAIDs and assess and treat H. pylori as indicated. Nonoperative treatment is reserved for highly selected stable patients with a sealed perforation and no peritonitis or sepsis, under close surgical observation.

Acute Mesenteric Ischaemia

MechanismWhen to suspect it
Arterial embolismAbrupt pain with atrial fibrillation, cardiac thrombus or another embolic source.
Arterial thrombosisVascular disease and sometimes prior postprandial pain, food avoidance or weight loss.
Non-occlusive ischaemiaShock, low cardiac output or critical illness with sustained hypoperfusion.
Mesenteric venous thrombosisThrombophilia, intra-abdominal inflammation, malignancy or portal disease.

Severe unexplained pain out of proportion to examination is a classic clue. Later guarding or rigidity may indicate infarction. Lactate is a marker of severity and can rise for other reasons. A normal lactate cannot exclude early mesenteric ischaemia and a high lactate alone cannot establish bowel necrosis.

Request urgent IV contrast CT angiography with arterial and portal venous phases and notify surgery and vascular or interventional teams. Avoid positive oral contrast. Emergency CTA should proceed when suspicion is high, including in kidney impairment after considering the urgency and coordinating with radiology. Imaging helps identify the vascular lesion and bowel injury. Reduced bowel-wall enhancement, pneumatosis or portomesenteric venous gas can support concern for advanced ischaemia in context.

Begin concurrent resuscitation and broad-spectrum antibiotics. Use the cause, bleeding risk and planned procedure to guide anticoagulation. Mesenteric venous thrombosis without peritonitis is usually treated initially with anticoagulation. Non-occlusive ischaemia requires correction of the precipitating low-flow state, with specialist escalation. Arterial occlusion requires urgent consideration of revascularisation, endovascular, open or hybrid as appropriate. Peritonitis or likely necrosis requires urgent exploration. Resect non-viable bowel and consider a planned second look when viability remains uncertain.

WSES perforated ulcer guidance · ESVS mesenteric guideline 2025 · WSES acute mesenteric ischaemia guidance

Loading diagram...
Clinical Triage and Management Flowchart for the Acute Abdomen
Test Your Knowledge

A 23-year-old previously healthy man presents to the emergency department with 18 hours of abdominal discomfort. The pain began as a dull, poorly localized ache around his umbilicus accompanied by nausea and loss of appetite. Over the past 6 hours, the pain has sharpened significantly and shifted to his right lower quadrant. On examination, his temperature is 37.8°C, heart rate is 96 bpm, and blood pressure is 128/78 mmHg. Palpation reveals marked tenderness localized to McBurney's point with involuntary guarding and exquisite focal percussion tenderness. Deep palpation in the left lower quadrant elicits sharp pain in the right lower quadrant. His white blood cell count is 14.8 x 10^9/L with 84% neutrophils. What is the most appropriate next step in the clinical management of this patient?

A

Obtain urgent surgical assessment for suspected acute appendicitis and arrange imaging or operation according to the local pathway

B

Discharge the patient with a 7-day course of oral co-amoxiclav and arrange outpatient ultrasonography

C

Perform immediate diagnostic flexible colonoscopy to inspect the ileocaecal valve for terminal ileitis

D

Admit for a 5-day course of high-dose intravenous hydrocortisone and bowel rest

Test Your Knowledge

A 62-year-old woman with a history of severe osteoarthritis managed with daily over-the-counter naproxen presents to the emergency department with sudden-onset, agonizing abdominal pain that began 3 hours ago. She describes the onset as immediate and explosive, stating she felt a tearing sensation across her upper abdomen. She is lying completely flat on the stretcher and cries out when the trolley is gently bumped. On examination, she is pale and diaphoretic; heart rate is 116 bpm, blood pressure is 96/60 mmHg, respiratory rate is 26 breaths/min (shallow thoracic breathing), and temperature is 37.4°C. Her abdomen is globally board-like rigid, with diffuse involuntary guarding and absent bowel sounds. An erect chest radiograph reveals a thin, crescentic sliver of free radiolucent gas beneath the right hemidiaphragm. Following the insertion of two large-bore intravenous cannulae and initial IV crystalloid resuscitation, what is the most appropriate next step in management?

A

Perform urgent upper gastrointestinal endoscopy to identify and thermally coagulate the bleeding ulcer

B

Continue resuscitation, start IV broad-spectrum antibiotics and involve surgery immediately for emergency source control

C

Administer 200 mL of oral barium contrast to delineate the anatomical boundaries of the duodenal perforation

D

Initiate high-dose oral proton pump inhibitor therapy and admit to the ward for serial 4-hourly abdominal examinations

Test Your Knowledge

A 76-year-old man with a history of permanent atrial fibrillation and previous ischemic stroke presents with 4 hours of excruciating, constant central abdominal pain. He rates the pain as 10/10 and appears visibly distressed, diaphoretic, and agitated. On physical examination, his heart rate is 122 bpm (irregularly irregular), blood pressure is 108/64 mmHg, respiratory rate is 24 breaths/min, and temperature is 37.1°C. His abdomen is soft, mildly distended, and non-tender, with no involuntary guarding, rebound tenderness, or palpable masses; active bowel sounds are present. Arterial blood gas analysis reveals: pH 7.29, pCO2 30 mmHg, pO2 88 mmHg, HCO3- 14 mmol/L, and arterial lactate 5.2 mmol/L (reference range < 2.0 mmol/L). His white blood cell count is 21.4 x 10^9/L. What is the most appropriate next diagnostic step?

A

Perform transabdominal ultrasonography of the right upper quadrant to assess for acalculous cholecystitis

B

Order an urgent barium meal follow-through study to identify mucosal ulceration of the proximal jejunum

C

Perform urgent biphasic CT mesenteric angiography without positive oral contrast

D

Reassure the patient, administer intravenous cyclizine, and repeat the arterial blood gas in 6 hours

Test Your Knowledge

A 68-year-old with known diverticulosis develops constant left lower quadrant pain, fever and focal guarding. BP is 91/57 mmHg and she is newly confused. What is the most appropriate plan?

A

Treat with outpatient analgesia only because the pain is confined to the left lower quadrant

B

Book a routine screening colonoscopy and await findings before treatment

C

Arrange emergency hospital management for suspected complicated diverticulitis and sepsis, with IV treatment and urgent source assessment

D

Assume uncomplicated diverticular bleeding despite no rectal bleeding

Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.