17.2 Informed Consent, Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015, and Advance Healthcare Directives
Key Takeaways
Valid consent is voluntary, sufficiently informed and given with capacity for the decision. Support the person and discuss the risks and alternatives that matter to them.
If timely consent is unobtainable in an emergency, treat immediate threats within the applicable legal limits. Respect a capable adult’s informed refusal and a valid, applicable advance refusal.
Assess capacity for the specific decision and time after providing practicable support. Check the exact decision and authority in any registered agreement, decision representation order or advance healthcare directive.
A valid, applicable advance refusal of life-sustaining treatment needs an express statement that the refusal applies even if life is at risk. Consider relevant requests and document reasons for declining them.
Adult involuntary admission under the Mental Health Act 2001 requires a statutory clinical test, the relevant process at an approved centre and independent review. Seek a separate basis for treating unrelated physical illness.
Informed Consent in Irish Medical Practice
A valid consent requires a voluntary choice, sufficient information in a form the person can understand, and the capacity to decide about the proposed intervention. Ask about the person's priorities and possible pressure from others. Use plain language, interpreters or aids where needed. Explain the nature and purpose of the intervention, expected benefits and relevant risks, reasonable alternatives and the implications of no treatment. Verify understanding and give the person time and a chance to ask questions. Record the discussion, decision and any supports. Use written consent where required and record the information discussed. Consent can be withdrawn.
Discussing material risks
Disclose risks a reasonable person in this patient's position would regard as significant. Elicit information about the individual's circumstances and consider what matters to them. The severity of a consequence, its frequency and its impact on that person can all influence materiality. For example, discuss a risk of persistent voice change before thyroid surgery with a patient whose work depends on their voice, even when it is uncommon. Explain diagnosis and options with enough time for a meaningful decision whenever possible.
Emergencies and refusal
In an emergency, if timely consent cannot be obtained and there is no known valid and applicable refusal, give only treatment immediately needed to save life or prevent significant harm, injury or serious deterioration. Document the urgency, known wishes, any steps to contact support and why delay was unsafe. If a decision-support arrangement or directive is found later, review ongoing treatment promptly. With a capable adult, establish that a refusal is informed and voluntary, discuss alternatives and document the decision. Relatives can help establish the person's wishes. Being related does not confer authority to decide on behalf of an adult.
Children and young people
Section 23 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act 1997 makes a 16- or 17-year-old's valid consent to medical, surgical or dental treatment effective without parental consent. Support and assess the young person's capacity where indicated and involve a parent or guardian if the young person agrees. The HSE distinguishes refusal from consent at this age. Respect the young person's views and, for a serious unresolved refusal, seek senior and legal advice. There may be grounds for a court decision. The HSE limits emergency action without time for court guidance to the minimum needed to prevent death or serious injury. Psychiatric admission under the Mental Health Act has separate rules.
Under age 16, generally seek consent from a parent with guardianship or another legal guardian and involve the child in an age-appropriate way. Irish law has not established a general rule that mature children under 16 can consent on their own. If refusal or disagreement endangers the child, seek senior and legal input, with immediately necessary care given in a time-critical emergency. Discuss confidentiality, safeguarding and statutory reporting as relevant.
Use the separate Irish consent pathway for organ donation
Part 2 of the Human Tissue Act 2024 governs organ transplantation. Its relevant consent provisions commenced on 17 June 2025. For deceased donation of relevant organs, including heart, lungs, liver, pancreas and kidneys, deemed consent can apply when the statutory criteria are met. Speak with the specialist donation team and check the opt-out register and the statutory exclusions. In the deemed-consent route, a properly identified designated family member must confirm there is no objection before retrieval can proceed. The designated person considers what the deceased would have wanted. Where deemed consent does not apply, the relevant professional follows the applicable consent or exclusion pathway. Keep donor treatment, death determination and the donation process distinct and follow specialist governance.
Human Tissue Act 2024, Part 2 · Commencement S.I. 250/2025 · HSE designated family member guidance
The Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015
The principal supported decision-making provisions took effect on 26 April 2023. New adult wardship applications ceased. Existing wards can remain subject to the transition, with individual extensions in certain cases under the 2026 amendment. If an existing wardship order is relevant, check its scope and liaise with the appropriate court office and senior team.
Functional assessment
Presume capacity. Section 3 assesses the ability to make the decision in question at the time it is needed. Take all practicable steps to help the person decide. Allow extra time, adapt information and treat reversible barriers such as delirium, distress or pain where possible. Assess whether the person can do all of the following after support:
- Understand relevant information, including reasonably foreseeable consequences of the available options or of making no decision.
- Retain it for long enough to make a voluntary choice. Short retention can be sufficient.
- Use or weigh it when deciding.
- Communicate the decision by any effective means, including assistive technology.
A person may have capacity for some decisions and need support for others. An impairment, cognitive test result or apparently unwise choice does not establish incapacity. Document the specific decision and time, assistance provided, evidence for each part and the conclusion. For a non-urgent decision, wait and reassess if capacity is likely to improve.
Statutory roles and decisions
| Arrangement | What the clinician checks |
|---|---|
| Decision-making assistant | The person makes the decision. The assistant helps with agreed matters such as obtaining information or communicating choices. The assistance agreement is notified to the Decision Support Service (DSS). |
| Co-decision-maker | Check the registered agreement for the specific decision. The person and co-decision-maker decide jointly. Where the decision requires a signed document, both sign, subject to the statutory procedure for an appointer unable to sign. For a disagreement or change in capacity, seek clarification and review of the arrangement as needed. |
| Decision-making representative | Check the Circuit Court order. The representative can decide on behalf of the person only within the order. Section 44 limits refusal or withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment, subject to the applicable terms and powers under an advance healthcare directive. The court can also make a decision on the person's behalf under section 38. |
| Enduring power of attorney | Check the instrument and applicable law for the person's welfare or property and affairs. An Irish enduring power of attorney does not authorise healthcare treatment decisions. |
| Advance healthcare directive | Check whether the directive is valid and applies to the treatment and circumstances. Check any designated healthcare representative's powers under the directive. |
Apply the section 8 guiding principles. Support participation, use the least restrictive proportionate intervention, act for the person's benefit and give effect, as far as practicable, to their reasonably ascertainable will and preferences. Consult relevant people where appropriate. For non-emergency care with no relevant arrangement, the HSE policy explains how to decide whether intervention is necessary and for the person's benefit under these principles. Clarify past and present wishes, seek senior or legal support for serious disagreements or uncertain authority, and document the basis for the decision. The HSE does not require a court application for every such decision.
Advance Healthcare Directives
Part 8 of the Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015 governs advance healthcare directives (AHDs). An adult with capacity can voluntarily make an AHD addressing future treatment choices. While the person can decide about the treatment, seek their current decision.
Making and applying a directive
- Formal requirements. The AHD is in writing, with the details, dated signatures and witnesses required by section 84. Two witnesses must be adults and at least one must be outside the directive-maker's immediate family. Where the directive-maker cannot sign, another adult who is neither witness can sign at their direction and in their presence. A designated healthcare representative (if appointed) signs in the presence of the directive-maker or their signatory and the witnesses. The DSS does not register AHDs. Keep a copy accessible to the relevant team.
- Validity and applicability. Check voluntariness, any valid revocation or amendment, and anything the person did while capable that was clearly inconsistent with the decision. Confirm that the person now lacks capacity for that decision and that both the treatment and circumstances are materially the same as specified. A valid and applicable refusal has the same effect as the person's current refusal with capacity. For life-sustaining treatment, the AHD must expressly say that it applies even if life is at risk. Basic care, such as warmth, oral food and drink and hygiene, is outside the directive. Artificial nutrition or hydration falls outside that definition of basic care.
- Requests and representatives. Consider a relevant treatment request. If it is declined, record why and give any designated healthcare representative a copy of the reasons as soon as practicable and within seven working days of recording. A representative can ensure implementation, and can interpret wishes or make relevant treatment decisions by reference to the AHD if explicitly authorised.
- Uncertainty and mental health. If there is ambiguity, consult the representative or, if none, family and friends, and seek a second healthcare professional's opinion. If that does not resolve the ambiguity, favour preservation of life. Obtain senior and legal input where needed. Section 85(7) sets exceptions for treatment governed by Part 4 of the Mental Health Act 2001 and for a specified conditional discharge under criminal law. The Part 4 exception does not apply to detention on the grounds in section 3(1)(b). An applicable refusal of treatment for a physical illness unrelated to ameliorating the mental disorder remains effective.
Worked example. If a person with acute respiratory failure lacks capacity and their valid AHD expressly refuses intubation in the current situation even if their life is at risk, follow that refusal. Clarify and provide other appropriate care. A relative who disagrees does not acquire authority to override the directive.
Involuntary Psychiatric Admission in Ireland
As of November 2026, use the Mental Health Act 2001 as amended for these procedures. The Mental Health Act 2026 has been enacted and its provisions require commencement orders. Provide urgent assessment, offer voluntary care where suitable, and use the relevant legal route for admission to an approved centre. An ED assessment or a general ward admission does not constitute involuntary psychiatric admission under this route.
The adult test under sections 3 and 8
A person must have mental illness, severe dementia or significant intellectual disability as defined in the Act and meet one of two criteria:
- Harm. The condition causes a serious likelihood of immediate and serious harm to the person or someone else.
- Deterioration or necessary treatment. Severity so impairs judgment that failure to admit would likely cause serious deterioration or prevent appropriate treatment available only by admission. In addition, reception, detention and treatment in the approved centre must be likely to benefit or alleviate the person's condition to a material extent.
Personality disorder, social deviance or addiction to drugs or intoxicants alone cannot justify involuntary admission. A refusal of care or inability to consent does not by itself meet the admission test.
Adult community and emergency department route
- Apply. Under section 9 a qualifying spouse, civil partner or relative uses Form 1, an HSE authorised officer Form 2, Gardaí Form 3, and another eligible adult Form 4. There is no requirement to exhaust family applicants first. Check the statutory exclusions and observation within the previous 48 hours. Section 12 separately allows Garda custody and an application when the specified immediate serious harm grounds are met.
- Recommend. An eligible registered medical practitioner examines the patient within 24 hours of receiving the application. If satisfied that the statutory test is met, they make a Form 5 recommendation for the specified approved centre, valid for seven days from its making. Under section 13 the applicant arranges transfer. If they cannot, the recommending doctor can ask the approved centre to arrange assisted transfer. Garda assistance applies under the statutory conditions. For a section 12 recommendation, Gardaí take the person to the specified centre.
- Decide. A consultant psychiatrist on staff examines the patient as soon as possible and makes a Form 6 admission order if satisfied the test is met. Section 14 permits holding at the approved centre for examination and decision for up to 24 hours. An initial admission order is normally for up to 21 days.
- Review. Give the patient written notice and send the order to the Mental Health Commission within 24 hours. The Commission arranges legal representation, an independent psychiatric assessment and referral to a Mental Health Tribunal. Under section 18 the tribunal usually decides within 21 days of the order and can affirm or revoke it. The Act permits specified extensions.
If an adult already admitted voluntarily to an approved centre wishes to leave, sections 23–24 provide a separate short holding and second consultant assessment route when criteria are met. If a certificate supports detention, the responsible consultant makes the admission order using Form 13. A child has a separate section 25 route, generally involving a consultant assessment and HSE application to the District Court.
Check the legal authority for each proposed intervention. Part 4 governs mental disorder treatment where applicable. A psychiatric order does not supply consent for unrelated physical treatment. For example, assess capacity and immediate emergency need separately before treating a serious physical injury.
An 82-year-old man with mild vascular dementia and type 2 diabetes has wet gangrene of a toe. The surgical team recommends urgent surgical source control and intravenous antibiotics, explaining the risk of rapidly spreading infection and death without treatment. With support he explains these risks in his own words, retains the information long enough to decide, weighs the alternatives and clearly declines surgery and intravenous antibiotics. He accepts symptom relief. His daughter offers to consent on his behalf because he has dementia. No other statutory authority for treatment applies. What should the team do?
Proceed with emergency surgery under the doctrine of necessity because wet gangrene represents a life-threatening surgical emergency.
Allow the daughter to sign the surgical consent form as legal next of kin on behalf of her father.
Apply to the High Court for an emergency Ward of Court order under the Lunacy Regulation (Ireland) Act 1871.
Respect his informed refusal, provide agreed care, and document the discussion and assessment
A 69-year-old man with advanced motor neurone disease presents with acute respiratory failure due to aspiration pneumonia. He is unresponsive and cannot make a decision about intubation. The team has his written, signed and properly witnessed advance healthcare directive, made voluntarily while he had capacity. It specifically refuses intubation and invasive ventilation in acute respiratory failure, even if his life is at risk. It is valid and applicable to the current decision. His son asks the team to intubate. Which response is appropriate?
Follow the directive, withhold intubation and invasive ventilation, and provide appropriate other treatment and symptom relief.
Proceed with emergency endotracheal intubation under the doctrine of necessity because the patient's son requests life-saving measures.
Overrule the Advance Healthcare Directive on beneficence grounds because the pneumonia is potentially treatable with antibiotics.
Detain the patient involuntarily under the Mental Health Act 2001 to administer emergency respiratory treatment.
A 23-year-old woman in an emergency department has acute mania with psychosis and has twice stepped into moving traffic, believing that she is immune to injury. She declines voluntary psychiatric admission. Her adult brother witnessed the events and is eligible to apply. The team addresses her immediate safety and assesses her physical injuries separately. Which sequence applies if he initiates involuntary admission to an approved centre under the Mental Health Act 2001?
Form 2 application by an Authorised Officer, Form 6 admission order by the emergency medicine registrar, and immediate transfer to a general medical ward.
Form 1 by her brother, examination by an eligible registered doctor within 24 hours of receiving the application and Form 5 if criteria are met, then approved-centre consultant examination and Form 6 if criteria are confirmed
Form 3 application completed by An Garda Síochána, Form 1 recommendation completed by the consultant psychiatrist, and direct detention for 6 months without review.
Form 5 application by the hospital social worker, Form 6 recommendation by the nursing manager, and Mental Health Tribunal review within 48 hours.
During a legally applicable deemed-consent donation pathway for a deceased adult, the specialist team has checked the opt-out register. The designated family member cannot confirm that there is no objection. What should the team do?
Proceed because the register contains no opt-out
Ask any ward visitor to act in place of the designated family member
Use the absence of a clinical advance healthcare directive to replace confirmation
Do not proceed without the required confirmation and follow the specialist donation process
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.