17.3 The Irish National Early Warning System (INEWS), ISBAR Clinical Handover, Open Disclosure, and Incident Reporting
Key Takeaways
INEWS v2 uses one oxygen saturation scoring row and assigns 3 additional points for supplemental oxygen.
An aggregate INEWS score of 3 requires SHO or ANP review within one hour. Any single component scoring 3, or a heart rate of 40 or less scoring 2, triggers immediate review.
An INEWS score of 0–1 requires at least six-hourly observations during the first 24 hours after admission. Act sooner if anyone raises a clinical concern.
Under the Patient Safety (Notifiable Incidents and Open Disclosure) Act 2023, providers must disclose and report incidents that meet the statutory notifiable criteria.
Use ISBAR for escalation and local reporting for patient safety incidents. Report a suspected medicine reaction to the HPRA even when causality is uncertain.
The Irish National Early Warning System (INEWS Version 2)
INEWS v2 is the adult inpatient track-and-trigger system in National Clinical Guideline No. 1. It is used to recognise and respond to deterioration in non-pregnant patients aged 16 years and over in acute inpatient care. Use the warning system for the clinical setting and population, including the separate maternity, paediatric and emergency department systems where applicable. Start urgent assessment and escalation whenever the clinical condition warrants it. See the HSE guideline and observation resources.
Obtain and interpret the observations
Record the seven scoring components using the adult observation chart and look for trends. Count the respiratory rate for a full minute. Measure peripheral oxygen saturation (SpO₂) and document room air or the oxygen device and delivery rate. A higher oxygen requirement at the same saturation can signal deterioration even when the aggregate score is unchanged. Check pulse rate, rhythm and quality, measure blood pressure and temperature, and assess alertness.
For baseline observations, confirm identity and record the measurement time. Use a correctly sized blood pressure cuff and record the temperature and how it was measured according to local policy. Check the oximeter signal if a reading does not match the clinical picture. Measure and document urine output over a defined interval when indicated, using the appropriate fluid balance record. For example, 25 mL over one hour for a 70 kg patient is about 0.36 mL/kg/hour. This is below the chart's threshold for notifying the doctor. Urine output is separate from the INEWS total. Record and escalate abnormal observations and reassess at the required interval.
The chart uses one SpO₂ scoring row and separately assigns 3 points for supplemental oxygen. An individually prescribed treatment target for a patient at risk of hypercapnic respiratory failure guides oxygen titration. Use the same INEWS scoring row to record their measured saturation. For example, a patient with an oxygen target of 88–92% who is at 92% on supplemental oxygen scores 2 for saturation and 3 for oxygen use. Check the trend and the response protocol. A Registrar or Consultant may authorise a modified response in the circumstances described below.
ACVPU records alertness, new confusion (including new altered mental status), response to voice, response to pain or unresponsiveness. New confusion or reduced alertness scores 3. Record the Glasgow Coma Scale separately where indicated and check blood glucose when alertness is impaired. The three-fold chart includes a neurological observation panel for this purpose.
Scoring, escalation and response
Use the adult observation chart to score each component and add the seven scores. Use both the aggregate and the single-parameter triggers when deciding how to escalate.
| Component | Score 3 | Score 2 | Score 1 | Score 0 | Score 1 | Score 2 | Score 3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Respiratory rate (breaths/min) | ≤8 | — | 9–11 | 12–20 | — | 21–24 | ≥25 |
| SpO₂ (%) | ≤91 | 92–93 | 94–95 | ≥96 | — | — | — |
| Oxygen | — | — | — | Room air | — | — | Supplemental oxygen |
| Systolic BP (mmHg) | ≤90 | 91–100 | 101–110 | 111–249 | ≥250 | — | — |
| Heart rate (beats/min) | — | ≤40 | 41–50 | 51–90 | 91–110 | 111–130 | ≥131 |
| Alertness (ACVPU) | — | — | — | Alert | — | — | New confusion, V, P or U |
| Temperature (°C) | ≤35.0 | — | 35.1–36.0 | 36.1–38.0 | 38.1–39.0 | ≥39.1 | — |
The chart flags other reasons to review a patient. Check systolic blood pressure manually and arrange medical review at ≥200 mmHg, even when the value contributes zero points. A fall of 20% from the usual systolic pressure in a normally hypertensive patient also requires medical review. Notify the doctor about urine output below 0.5 mL/kg/hour.
Apply the escalation pathway
| Trigger | Minimum observations | Escalation and response |
|---|---|---|
| Score 0–1 | Every 6 hours for the first 24 hours after admission, then every 12 hours | Nurse in charge reviews a new score of 1. Escalate sooner for clinical concern. |
| Score 2 | Every 6 hours | Nurse in charge reviews. Seek an urgent response if clinical concern warrants it. A heart rate of 40 or less activates the separate emergency trigger below. |
| Aggregate score 3 | Every 4 hours | Notify nurse in charge and team or on-call senior house officer (SHO). SHO or advanced nurse practitioner (ANP) service reviews within 1 hour. Check whether a single parameter scored 3. |
| Score 4–6 | Every hour | Notify nurse in charge and team or on-call SHO. SHO or ANP service reviews within 30 minutes. Screen for sepsis as indicated. If there is no response to treatment within 1 hour, contact the Registrar and/or ANP service. Consider continuous monitoring and higher-level care. |
| Score ≥7 | Every 30 minutes | Notify nurse in charge and team or on-call Registrar, and inform the team or on-call Consultant. Registrar, Consultant or ANP service reviews immediately. Continuous monitoring is recommended. Plan transfer to higher-level care and activate the emergency response system as appropriate to the hospital model. |
| Any single score of 3, or heart rate ≤40 (score 2) | Every 30 minutes or as indicated by condition | Notify nurse in charge and team or on-call SHO for immediate SHO or ANP service review. If there is no response to treatment or concern persists, contact the Registrar or Consultant. Consider activating the emergency response system. |
| Healthcare worker, patient or family concern | As indicated by condition | Bring the concern to the bedside nurse or nurse in charge. The nurse in charge reviews and escalates according to clinical urgency, including when the score is low. |
For example, a respiratory rate of 22 and a saturation of 95% on room air yield an aggregate score of 3 if all other values score zero. The aggregate tier calls for four-hourly observations and SHO or ANP review within an hour. A patient whose only abnormality is a heart rate of 38 has an aggregate score of 2. That heart rate triggers immediate SHO or ANP review and at least half-hourly observations or monitoring suited to the patient's condition.
Modified and deferred escalation
The HSE user guide distinguishes the calculated score from the response. Record observations and score them using the standard thresholds. A Registrar or Consultant may document a modified escalation and response protocol after the first 24 hours of admission if appropriate to the patient's clinical condition. Record the reason and the time and date of the next review, which is due within 24 hours or sooner if clinically indicated. Continue recording the calculated INEWS score.
An appropriately competent registered nurse may defer escalation for up to 30 minutes when the cause of discomfort or a new trigger is likely to be readily reversible. Document the reason, intervention and review time on the chart. Escalate under the usual protocol if symptoms persist or the score stays the same or increases. Escalate immediately when the patient's condition warrants urgent attention.
Clinical communication with ISBAR
Use ISBAR to communicate the reason for review, the patient’s status and the requested action. The HSE observation chart includes the structure for escalation calls.
The ISBAR Framework
The five parts of ISBAR help the receiving clinician identify the patient, assess urgency and agree a plan.
- I - Identify:
- State your name, professional grade (e.g., Intern, SHO, Registrar), and current ward/location.
- Clearly identify the patient: full name, date of birth (DOB), Medical Record Number (MRN), and bed location.
- Confirm the identity and role of the clinician you are speaking with.
- S - Situation:
- Concisely describe the current clinical problem and the specific reason for contact.
- State the patient's current aggregate INEWS score and individual parameter triggers.
- Explicitly express the level of clinical urgency (e.g., "I am escalating an emergency review because Mr. Brennan is deteriorating after surgery and has an INEWS score of 9").
- B - Background:
- Detail the patient's primary admission diagnosis, date of admission, and attending consultant team.
- Provide key comorbid medical history (e.g., severe ischaemic heart disease, CKD stage 4, immunosuppression).
- Summarize the hospital trajectory over the past 24 to 48 hours (e.g., Day 2 post-laparotomy for perforated diverticulitis).
- Mention relevant medications (e.g., anticoagulants, insulin) and known drug allergies.
- A - Assessment:
- Present a systematic physiological evaluation using the ABCDE (Airway, Breathing, Circulation, Disability, Exposure) approach.
- Detail current vital signs: respiratory rate, oxygen saturation, inspired oxygen, blood pressure, heart rate, temperature, and ACVPU (with GCS where indicated).
- Report pertinent physical findings (e.g., cold peripheries, abdominal guarding, basilar lung crackles).
- Report crucial bedside investigation results (e.g., ABG lactate, arterial pH, ECG rhythm, point-of-care haemoglobin).
- State your working clinical diagnosis or differential.
- R - Recommendation:
- Explicitly state what clinical action you need the receiving clinician to take.
- Specify a precise timeframe for review (e.g., "I need you to come to the bedside to evaluate this patient immediately").
- Confirm the treatment and monitoring plan while help is on the way.
- Establish contingency plans if clinical deterioration accelerates prior to arrival.
Handover Settings
Use the same structure in settings such as these.
- Shift Handovers: Morning and evening sign-out rounds between daytime teams and on-call night teams.
- Deteriorating Patient Escalation: Ward nurses contacting on-call doctors, or junior doctors escalating to registrars and consultants.
- Inter-Hospital Transfers: Transferring unstable patients between hospitals (e.g., transferring acute stroke patients for mechanical thrombectomy or major trauma patients to national trauma centres).
Open disclosure after a patient safety incident
Start by protecting the patient from further harm, seeking appropriate help and documenting the facts. Explain what is known, acknowledge uncertainty, apologise when appropriate and arrange follow-up. Discuss with the patient whom they want involved, and work with the designated person or local disclosure lead. The HSE Open Disclosure Policy, effective June 2025, applies across the HSE and HSE-funded services.
- The Patient Safety (Notifiable Incidents and Open Disclosure) Act 2023 requires the provider to disclose incidents within its notifiable categories and notify the relevant regulator. Check the statutory definition and HSE guidance effective January 2026. The provider must notify the relevant regulator within seven calendar days once satisfied that a notifiable incident occurred. Follow the applicable notification route and make the required written follow-up after the disclosure meeting. For example, Schedule 1 includes an unintended and unanticipated death caused by transfusion of ABO-incompatible blood that was not attributable to the patient's illness or underlying condition.
- For other patient safety incidents, HSE policy and professional guidance still call for open and timely communication. Part 4 of the Civil Liability (Amendment) Act 2017, as amended, provides a voluntary statutory disclosure process.
- When a provider makes a disclosure in accordance with the applicable statutory process, specified information and any apology have legal protections. For example, the information or apology is not an admission of liability and is inadmissible as evidence of fault or liability in the relevant proceedings. The statutory framework also protects indemnity cover. See section 10 of the 2017 Act and section 10 of the 2023 Act.
For a disclosure meeting, choose a private setting, explain the incident in plain language and allow time for questions. Describe the care the patient needs now, agree how and when they will hear more, and record the meeting and follow-up in accordance with the applicable process. Share what is known at the time and explain how the team will resolve remaining uncertainties.
Incident reporting and learning
Address immediate harm, make the situation safe and document the facts. Under the HSE Incident Management Framework, a patient safety incident can involve harm, reach the patient without discernible harm, or be prevented from reaching them by timely intervention or chance. A wrongly drawn-up syringe intercepted before administration is a near miss. A dose given in error without discernible harm is a no-harm incident. An injury from the error is a harm event.
Report incidents and near misses promptly through the HSE local process so that they are recorded in the National Incident Management System (NIMS). Local arrangements identify who records the event. Check separate statutory disclosure and notification duties where applicable. The review should be proportionate to the severity and opportunities for learning. Use the information to identify patterns, make changes and share learning.
Report a suspected adverse drug reaction
The Irish Health Products Regulatory Authority (HPRA) collects suspected medicine reactions for pharmacovigilance. Treat and document the patient’s problem first. Report a clinically plausible reaction even when causation is uncertain. Serious reactions, those involving newly authorised medicines or products under additional monitoring, and reactions in pregnancy, breastfeeding, children or older adults are particularly important. An inpatient event may also need local incident reporting or open disclosure, depending on what occurred. Pharmacovigilance has its own purpose and reporting route.
Include a patient identifier such as age, the suspect product, the reaction and the reporter’s contact details. Add timing, dose, completion or withdrawal, concurrent medicines and clinical outcome when available. Include brand and batch where possible, especially for vaccines or biologics. An individual report helps identify a safety signal. It cannot establish incidence or prove that the medicine caused the event.
HPRA guidance for healthcare professionals.
How several defences can fail
In James Reason’s model, a hazard can cause harm when weaknesses align across several protective barriers. Active failures include slips, lapses, mistakes and unsafe acts close to the point of care. Latent conditions include poorly designed tools, insufficient capacity or training, and a backup process that has not been validated.
For example, a look-alike syringe may reach a patient when staff are interrupted and identification or checking barriers also fail. A systems review asks what happened, how working conditions or equipment shaped decisions, and how to improve each barrier. The HSE approach to just culture supports reporting and fair, shared accountability. It also recognises that deliberate harm or complete disregard for safety procedures requires appropriate action. Follow the incident and any relevant professional or workplace process based on the specific circumstances.
Clinical audit and testing an improvement
Clinical audit measures care against a defined, evidence-based standard. Agree on the criterion, eligible patients, data and governance. Collect and analyse the baseline data, compare them with the standard, report the findings, make improvements and re-audit. A safety incident can reveal a useful audit question. An incident review explains the event and its contributory factors. An audit measures how consistently the wider service follows the agreed standard.
Worked example. A ward has agreed that all abnormal adult observations should be escalated within the expected INEWS response time. It finds evidence of timely escalation in 36 of 50 eligible episodes (72%). The team checks whether actual calls were late or the resulting actions were poorly documented. In a Plan–Do–Study–Act cycle it trials a revised escalation prompt on one ward, tracks timely escalation and staff workload, then retains, adapts or abandons the prompt using those results. Once changes are in place, it re-audits against the same criterion. If 45 of 50 episodes now meet the criterion, performance is 90%, an improvement of 18 percentage points. Further improvement is needed to meet the ward’s agreed standard.
HSE Incident Management Framework · Reason’s original model · HSE Clinical Audit Toolkit.
A 64-year-old man who underwent an emergency right hemicolectomy 48 hours ago is being cared for on a general surgical ward. At 02:00, the ward staff nurse records the following vital signs: respiratory rate 28 breaths/min, oxygen saturation 94% on room air, inspired oxygen room air, systolic blood pressure 94 mmHg, heart rate 118 beats/min, ACVPU is Alert (A), and temperature 38.6°C. The nurse calculates the INEWS Version 2 aggregate score. According to National Clinical Effectiveness Committee (NCEC) National Clinical Guideline No. 1 and the HSE Patient Observation Chart, what is the total INEWS score and the required mandatory escalation action?
Total score 4; notify the intern to review the patient by the morning surgical ward round at 08:00.
Total score 6; repeat vital signs in 4 hours and request a routine physiotherapy referral.
Total 9. Notify the nurse in charge and team or on-call Registrar, inform the Consultant and arrange immediate Registrar, Consultant or ANP service review.
Total score 12; immediately initiate external chest compressions and activate the cardiac arrest team.
An inpatient with type 2 diabetes develops severe hypoglycaemia after a tenfold insulin administration error. The team treats her promptly and she recovers. The provider confirms that this incident does not meet a statutory notifiable category and arranges a disclosure under Part 4 of the Civil Liability (Amendment) Act 2017, as amended. What should the team do?
Clinicians must strictly avoid expressing sorrow, regret, or offering an apology, as any apology automatically constitutes an admission of legal negligence under Irish tort law.
An open disclosure meeting should only be held if the patient or family initiates formal legal proceedings through the High Court.
Clinicians should attribute the error entirely to the individual nurse who administered the injection to protect the medical team from liability.
Explain the known facts and follow-up plan, apologise as appropriate and follow the statutory disclosure process.
A hospital clinical risk committee investigates an incident where a 54-year-old surgical patient received an incompatible packed red blood cell transfusion (group A red cells administered to a group O recipient), triggering an acute hemolytic transfusion reaction managed in the ICU. The incident is reported through the National Incident Management System (NIMS) and a multidisciplinary systems analysis review follows. The investigation reveals that: the emergency department doctor mislabeled the pre-transfusion crossmatch sample due to being interrupted during a cardiac arrest; the blood bank laboratory was operating with an unvalidated manual backup procedure during a software outage; and the ward nurses failed to execute the independent bedside identity check required by local policy due to extreme clinical overcrowding. According to James Reason's Swiss Cheese model of accident causation, what does this incident illustrate?
Harm occurred because multiple latent systemic vulnerabilities and defenses failed across organizational layers, aligning with active frontline human errors rather than isolated single-person negligence.
The error is solely attributable to gross personal misconduct by the ward nurses, who should be immediately struck off the nursing register without analyzing hospital systems.
Systems-based safety models are inapplicable to healthcare, and clinical errors can only be prevented by punitive disciplinary measures against frontline staff.
Adverse transfusion events represent unavoidable random acts of nature that cannot be mitigated by administrative safeguards or technology.
A patient develops a severe suspected adverse reaction to a correctly prescribed medicine, needs inpatient treatment and then improves after the drug is stopped. The team documents the reaction but cannot prove causality. What further pharmacovigilance action is appropriate in Ireland?
Wait for a recurrence after deliberate re-exposure
Ask the patient to report only if the manufacturer confirms causality
Use NIMS as the sole route for medicines pharmacovigilance
Report the suspected reaction to the HPRA with patient, product, reaction and reporter details
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.