Inflation & Deflation
Understanding inflation and deflation is critical for investment advisers because they directly affect purchasing power—the real value of money and investment returns. A client's nominal return means nothing if inflation has eroded its purchasing power.
What Is Inflation?
Inflation is a general increase in prices and a corresponding decrease in the purchasing power of money. When inflation occurs, each dollar buys fewer goods and services than before.
Causes of Inflation
Demand-Pull Inflation
- Too much money chasing too few goods
- Economy growing faster than productive capacity
- Consumer and business demand exceeds supply
- Often occurs during economic expansions
Cost-Push Inflation
- Rising production costs push up prices
- Causes include: higher wages, raw material costs, energy prices
- Supply chain disruptions can trigger cost-push inflation
- Can occur even during weak economic conditions
Measuring Inflation
Investment advisers must understand the key inflation measures:
Consumer Price Index (CPI)
The Consumer Price Index (CPI) is the most widely used measure of inflation:
| Feature | Description |
|---|---|
| What It Measures | Price changes for a basket of consumer goods and services |
| Who Publishes | Bureau of Labor Statistics (monthly) |
| Components | Housing, food, transportation, medical care, apparel, recreation, education |
| Primary Use | Adjusting Social Security benefits, tax brackets, TIPS |
Core CPI excludes volatile food and energy prices to show underlying inflation trends.
Producer Price Index (PPI)
The Producer Price Index (PPI) measures wholesale price changes:
| Feature | Description |
|---|---|
| What It Measures | Prices received by domestic producers |
| Timing | Leading indicator for CPI (producer costs flow to consumer prices) |
| Use | Early warning sign for consumer inflation |
GDP Deflator
The GDP Deflator is the broadest measure of inflation:
- Includes all goods and services in GDP (not just a fixed basket)
- Adjusts automatically as spending patterns change
- Used to calculate "real" (inflation-adjusted) GDP
Real vs. Nominal Returns
This concept is critical for investment advisers to understand and communicate to clients:
| Term | Definition | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Nominal Return | The stated return on an investment | Bond pays 5% |
| Real Return | Return after adjusting for inflation | 5% - 3% inflation = 2% |
Formula: Real Return ≈ Nominal Return − Inflation Rate
Example
A client earns a 7% return on their portfolio while inflation is 3%:
- Nominal return: 7%
- Real return: 7% − 3% = 4%
- The 4% represents the actual increase in purchasing power
Critical Insight: If a bond pays 3% and inflation is 4%, the real return is negative 1%. The client is losing purchasing power even though they're receiving positive nominal returns.
Effects of Inflation on Investments
Different asset classes respond differently to inflation:
| Investment Type | Effect of Inflation | Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed-rate bonds | Hurt | Fixed payments lose purchasing power |
| Cash and savings | Hurt | Purchasing power erodes |
| Common stocks | Mixed | Companies may pass costs to consumers, but margins can suffer |
| Real estate | Generally benefits | Hard asset; values and rents often rise with inflation |
| Commodities | Generally benefits | Prices rise with inflation |
| TIPS | Protected | Principal adjusts with CPI |
| Floating-rate securities | Protected | Rates adjust with market rates |
Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS)
TIPS are Treasury bonds specifically designed to protect against inflation:
| Feature | How It Works |
|---|---|
| Principal adjustment | Face value increases with CPI |
| Interest payments | Fixed rate paid on adjusted principal |
| Maturity | Investor receives greater of adjusted or original principal |
| Deflation protection | Cannot receive less than original face value |
Example: A $1,000 TIPS with 2% coupon during 3% inflation:
- Principal adjusts to $1,030
- Interest payment: 2% × $1,030 = $20.60 (vs. $20 originally)
What Is Deflation?
Deflation is a general decrease in prices and an increase in the purchasing power of money. While this sounds positive, deflation is actually more dangerous than moderate inflation.
Dangers of Deflation
| Problem | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Delayed purchases | Consumers wait for lower prices, reducing demand |
| Declining revenues | Businesses earn less as prices fall |
| Debt burden increases | Fixed debt payments become harder to make with falling income |
| Deflationary spiral | Lower prices → lower profits → layoffs → less spending → even lower prices |
Historical Example
The Great Depression saw severe deflation, with prices falling over 25%. Wages and profits collapsed, unemployment soared, and the debt burden became crushing for borrowers.
Inflation's Impact on Different Client Situations
Investment advisers must consider how inflation affects different clients:
Retirees on Fixed Income
| Concern | Adviser Response |
|---|---|
| Fixed income loses purchasing power | Include TIPS, I-Bonds, or inflation-adjusted annuities |
| Social Security adjusts for CPI | Explain that adjustments may not fully cover their expenses |
| Healthcare costs rise faster than CPI | Plan for higher healthcare inflation |
Younger Accumulators
| Concern | Adviser Response |
|---|---|
| Long time horizon to grow wealth | Stocks historically outpace inflation long-term |
| Wages may rise with inflation | Human capital provides some inflation protection |
| Home purchase becomes more expensive | Locked mortgage payments become easier over time with inflation |
High-Net-Worth Clients
| Concern | Adviser Response |
|---|---|
| Real estate and alternative assets | Often provide inflation hedges |
| TIPS and commodities | Consider as portfolio diversifiers |
| Tax brackets adjust with inflation | But capital gains don't—can create hidden tax increases |
In Practice: How Investment Advisers Apply This
Portfolio construction for inflation protection:
- Include TIPS for explicit inflation protection
- Consider real estate (REITs or direct ownership)
- Evaluate commodities as inflation hedges
- Review bond duration—longer duration bonds suffer more from unexpected inflation
- Stocks provide some long-term inflation protection through pricing power
Client communication:
- Always discuss returns in real terms, not just nominal terms
- Help clients understand that "safe" investments like CDs may lose purchasing power
- Explain that inflation is the "silent tax" on savings
On the Exam
The Series 65 exam tests your understanding of:
- Real vs. nominal returns — calculating and explaining the difference
- Inflation measures — CPI, PPI, GDP deflator
- TIPS — how they protect against inflation
- Investment impact — which asset classes benefit/suffer from inflation
- Purchasing power — the real-world impact of inflation on clients
Expect 2-3 questions on inflation. Common formats include calculating real returns and identifying which investments protect against inflation.
Key Takeaways
- Inflation erodes purchasing power; deflation increases it but is economically dangerous
- CPI is the most common inflation measure; PPI is a leading indicator
- Real return = Nominal return − Inflation rate
- Fixed-rate bonds and cash are hurt most by unexpected inflation
- TIPS, real estate, and commodities provide inflation protection
- Investment advisers must discuss returns in real terms with clients
- Negative real returns mean clients are losing purchasing power despite positive nominal returns
- Deflation is rare but can create a dangerous deflationary spiral
Which investment is MOST negatively affected by unexpected inflation?
An investor earns a 7% return on her portfolio while inflation is 2.5%. What is her approximate real rate of return?
The Consumer Price Index (CPI) is published by:
1.5 Interest Rates & Yield Curves
Continue learning