10.4 Statistical Questions, Variability, & Describing Distributions
Key Takeaways
A statistical question is one that anticipates variability in the answers; "How tall am I?" is not statistical, but "How tall are the students in this class?" is.
Every distribution is described by three things together: center, spread, and shape — reporting a mean without a spread is an incomplete answer.
Mean absolute deviation measures typical distance from the mean, and a larger MAD means a more spread-out distribution.
Shape is described as symmetric, skewed right, or skewed left, and the direction of skew is named for the long tail, not the bulk of the data.
Statistical Questions, Variability, & Describing Distributions
Sections 9.3 and 9.4 computed mean, median, mode, range, quartiles, and IQR. This section covers the framing the DRC specification wraps around them: recognizing a statistical question, understanding a data set as a distribution, and summarizing that distribution "in relation to its context."
What Makes a Question Statistical
A statistical question is one that anticipates variability in the answers.
That single criterion decides every item of this type.
| Question | Statistical? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| How old am I? | no | one answer, no variability |
| How old are the students in this program? | yes | answers vary from person to person |
| What did the thermometer read at 8 a.m. today? | no | a single reading |
| What are the daily high temperatures in July? | yes | 31 values that vary |
| How much does this box weigh? | no | one object, one weight |
| How much do the boxes on this pallet weigh? | yes | a distribution of weights |
The tell is usually plural: a group of people, a set of days, a batch of parts. A question about one thing at one time is not statistical, and it does not need a mean.
A Data Set Has a Distribution
A distribution describes how the values are spread across their possible range. Three features describe it, and TABE expects all three:
| Feature | Question it answers | Statistics used |
|---|---|---|
| Center | What is a typical value? | mean, median, mode |
| Spread | How much do values differ? | range, interquartile range, mean absolute deviation |
| Shape | How are values arranged? | symmetric, skewed right, skewed left, gaps, clusters, outliers |
The reporting rule. A center without a spread is misleading. Two crews averaging 40 hours per week are very different if one crew ranges 38–42 and the other ranges 12–68. Always pair the two.
Measuring Spread: Mean Absolute Deviation
Mean absolute deviation (MAD) is the average distance of each value from the mean. Bigger MAD means more spread out.
Procedure:
- Compute the mean.
- Find each value's distance from the mean (always positive — that is what "absolute" means).
- Average those distances.
Worked example. Daily service calls: 8, 10, 12, 14, 16.
| Value | Distance from mean of 12 |
|---|---|
| 8 | 4 |
| 10 | 2 |
| 12 | 0 |
| 14 | 2 |
| 16 | 4 |
Mean . MAD calls.
Interpretation: on a typical day, the number of service calls is about 2.4 away from the average of 12.
Compare a second technician: 2, 7, 12, 17, 22. Same mean of 12, but distances are 10, 5, 0, 5, 10, giving MAD . Same center, very different consistency — and that is precisely what MAD exists to reveal.
Describing Shape
| Shape | Picture | Mean vs. median | Real-world example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Symmetric | balanced around the middle | mean ≈ median | heights of adults |
| Skewed right (positive) | long tail toward high values | mean > median | household income; a few very high values |
| Skewed left (negative) | long tail toward low values | mean < median | scores on an easy test; a few very low values |
| Bimodal | two separate peaks | neither summarizes well | commute times with two shift start-times |
| Uniform | roughly flat | mean ≈ median | rolls of a fair die |
Naming the skew. The direction is named for the tail, not the hump. A distribution with most values on the left and a few stragglers far to the right is skewed right, even though the data "sits" on the left. This is the most-missed vocabulary item in the topic.
Shape drives which center you report
| Shape | Best measure of center | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Symmetric, no outliers | mean | uses every value; nothing distorts it |
| Skewed, or outliers present | median | resistant to extreme values |
| Categorical data | mode | the only measure that applies |
A distribution of salaries with one owner earning ten times the staff wage is skewed right; the median is the honest summary, and the mean is the number a recruiter quotes when they want the figure to look larger.
Summarizing a Distribution in Context
Standard 6.SP.5 asks candidates to summarize a data set by reporting the number of observations, what was measured and in what units, the center, the spread, and any striking overall pattern — all with reference to the context.
Full worked summary. Hours of training completed by 11 new hires: 4, 6, 6, 7, 8, 8, 8, 9, 10, 12, 30.
| Element | Value |
|---|---|
| Number of observations | 11 new hires |
| What was measured | training hours completed, in hours |
| Center (median) | 8 hours |
| Center (mean) | hours |
| Spread (range) | hours |
| Spread (IQR) | , , so IQR hours |
| Shape | skewed right, with a clear outlier at 30 |
| Best summary | median of 8 hours, because the single 30-hour value pulls the mean up to 9.8 |
In context: ten of the eleven new hires completed between 4 and 12 hours of training, clustering around 8 hours, while one hire completed 30 hours — worth investigating separately rather than averaging away.
Reading Variability From a Display
You do not always need to compute. A dot plot or histogram shows spread directly:
- Marks clustered tightly above a few values → small spread, small MAD.
- Marks spread evenly across the whole axis → large spread, large MAD.
- A gap with isolated marks far to one side → an outlier and a skew.
TABE frequently shows two dot plots side by side and asks which data set is more consistent. The answer is the one whose marks are packed into a narrower stretch of the number line — no arithmetic required.
Which of the following is a statistical question?
How many minutes did my bus ride take this morning?
How much does this bag of concrete weigh?
What is the posted speed limit on Highway 12?
How many minutes do the bus rides of the students in this program take?
A quality inspector records the following defect counts over five shifts: 3, 5, 9, 11, 12. What is the mean absolute deviation?
9 defects
8 defects
3.2 defects
4 defects
A distribution of annual salaries at a small firm has most values between $38,000 and $52,000, with two executives earning over $300,000. How should this distribution be described, and which measure of center best represents a typical salary?
Skewed left; the mean best represents a typical salary.
Symmetric; the mean and median are equal.
Skewed right; the median best represents a typical salary.
Bimodal; the mode best represents a typical salary.
Sections you finish are checked off in the contents.