8.4 Operational Amplifiers & Active Filter Design
Key Takeaways
- An ideal operational amplifier possesses infinite open-loop voltage gain (A_{OL} = \infty), infinite input impedance (Z_{in} = \infty), zero output impedance (Z_{out} = 0), infinite bandwidth, and zero offset voltage.
- The negative feedback Golden Rules dictate: 1) No current flows into either input terminal (I^+ = I^- = 0), and 2) Feedback forces input terminal voltages equal (V^+ = V^-), creating a virtual ground/short.
- Essential linear op-amp circuits include Inverting (A_v = -\frac{R_f}{R_i}), Non-Inverting (A_v = 1 + \frac{R_f}{R_i}), Unity Buffer (A_v = 1), Summing, Difference, and Instrumentation Amplifiers (A_v = \left(1 + \frac{2R_1}{R_g}\right)\frac{R_3}{R_2}).
- Key non-ideal parameters are Common-Mode Rejection Ratio (CMRR = 20\log_{10}|A_d/A_c|), Slew Rate (SR = \left.\frac{dV_o}{dt}\right|_{max} = 2\pi f_{max} V_p$), input offset current/voltage, and GBW product.
- Active filters (Sallen-Key topology) eliminate bulky inductors; Butterworth filters yield maximally flat passbands, Chebyshev filters provide sharp roll-off with passband ripple, and Bessel filters preserve linear phase delay.
8.4 Operational Amplifiers & Active Filter Design
1. Ideal vs. Practical Op-Amp Characteristics
An Operational Amplifier (Op-Amp) is a high-gain DC-coupled differential amplifier. Under negative feedback, op-amp circuit operation is simplified by the Golden Rules of Op-Amps.
The Golden Rules of Ideal Op-Amps (with Negative Feedback)
- Rule 1 (Infinite Input Resistance): No current enters either input terminal ($I^+ = I^- = 0\text{ A}$).
- Rule 2 (Virtual Short Circuit): Negative feedback forces the differential input voltage to zero ($V^+ - V^- = 0 \implies V^+ = V^-$).
Ideal vs. Practical (741 BJT) Parameter Comparison
| Parameter | Symbol | Ideal Op-Amp | Practical Op-Amp (LM741) | Practical FET Op-Amp (TL081) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Open-Loop Voltage Gain | $A_{OL}$ | $\infty$ | $200,000$ ($106\text{ dB}$) | $200,000$ ($106\text{ dB}$) |
| Input Resistance | $R_{in}$ | $\infty$ | $2\text{ M}\Omega$ | $10^{12}\ \Omega$ ($1\text{ T}\Omega$) |
| Output Resistance | $R_{out}$ | $0\ \Omega$ | $75\ \Omega$ | $50\ \Omega$ |
| Bandwidth | $BW$ | $\infty$ | $1\text{ MHz}$ (Unity Gain $f_T$) | $3\text{ MHz}$ |
| Common-Mode Rejection Ratio | $CMRR$ | $\infty$ | $90\text{ dB}$ | $100\text{ dB}$ |
| Slew Rate | $SR$ | $\infty$ | $0.5\text{ V/}\mu\text{s}$ | $13\text{ V/}\mu\text{s}$ |
| Input Offset Voltage | $V_{OS}$ | $0\text{ V}$ | $1-5\text{ mV}$ | $3\text{ mV}$ |
Key Non-Ideal Parameters
- Common-Mode Rejection Ratio ($CMRR$): Ability to reject common noise signals present at both input terminals.
- Slew Rate ($SR$): Maximum rate of output voltage change per unit time:
- Full-Power Bandwidth ($f_{max}$): Maximum undistorted frequency for a peak output voltage amplitude $V_p$:
2. Linear Op-Amp Configurations
A. Inverting Amplifier
- Voltage Gain: $A_v = -\frac{R_f}{R_i}$
- Input Impedance: $Z_{in} = R_i$
- Virtual Ground: Non-inverting input is grounded ($V^+ = 0\text{ V} \implies V^- = 0\text{ V}$).
B. Non-Inverting Amplifier
- Voltage Gain: $A_v = 1 + \frac{R_f}{R_i}$
- Input Impedance: $Z_{in} \approx \infty$
- Phase: In-phase output ($0^\circ$ phase shift).
C. Voltage Follower (Unity-Gain Buffer)
- $R_f = 0\ \Omega, R_i = \infty \implies A_v = +1$.
- Ideal buffer: $Z_{in} = \infty, Z_{out} = 0$.
D. Summing Amplifier
- Output Voltage:
E. Difference (Differential) Amplifier
- When matched resistors are used ($R_4/R_3 = R_2/R_1$):
F. Three Op-Amp Instrumentation Amplifier
- Consists of two non-inverting input buffer stages driving a differential amplifier stage.
- Overall Voltage Gain:
- Advantages: Single resistor ($R_g$) gain control, ultra-high input impedance on both inputs, superior CMRR.
G. Op-Amp Integrator & Differentiator
- Integrator: $v_o(t) = -\frac{1}{R C} \int_{0}^{t} v_i(\tau) d\tau + v_o(0)$. Practical circuits include parallel $R_f$ across $C$ to limit DC gain.
- Differentiator: $v_o(t) = -R C \frac{dv_i(t)}{dt}$. Practical circuits add series $R_s$ with $C$ to suppress high-frequency noise amplification.
3. Non-Linear Op-Amp Circuits & Comparators
A. Schmitt Trigger (Inverting with Positive Feedback)
Provides positive feedback to introduce hysteresis, eliminating output noise chattering.
- Upper Threshold Point ($V_{UTP}$):
- Lower Threshold Point ($V_{LTP}$):
- Hysteresis Voltage ($V_H$):
4. Active Filter Design & Approximation Responses
Active filters utilize op-amps, resistors, and capacitors (no inductors) to shape frequency response.
Filter Approximation Characteristics
- Butterworth: Maximally flat passband response; smooth monotonic attenuation ($ -20\text{ dB/dec}$ per order $n$).
- Chebyshev: Steep initial roll-off rate; exhibits equal-ripple passband variations.
- Bessel: Linear phase shift (constant group delay); gradual amplitude roll-off; preserves pulse shapes.
Second-Order Sallen-Key Low-Pass Filter (LPF)
- Cutoff Frequency ($f_c$):
- Equal-Component Design ($R_1 = R_2 = R, C_1 = C_2 = C$):
- Passband Voltage Gain ($A_v$) & Quality Factor ($Q$):
- For Second-Order Butterworth Response ($Q = 0.707 = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}$):
- Roll-off Rate: $-40\text{ dB/decade}$ ($-12\text{ dB/octave}$).
An op-amp with a slew rate of SR = 2.5 V/μs is used in an amplifier with a desired output peak voltage of V_p = 10 V. What is the maximum distortion-free operating frequency (full-power bandwidth f_max)?
In a three-op-amp instrumentation amplifier, R1 = 25 kΩ, R2 = 10 kΩ, R3 = 50 kΩ, and the gain resistor is set to Rg = 2.0 kΩ. What is the total closed-loop differential voltage gain A_v?
To achieve a second-order Butterworth low-pass filter response using equal-component Sallen-Key topology with R = 10 kΩ and C = 0.01 μF, what should be the required feedback resistor ratio R_f / R_i and cutoff frequency f_c?